Verified Reviews - Journal of Alloys and Compounds
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Sarah 2023-07-01

It's been nearly 10 days with the editor, but there's been no news at all. Is this journal always this slow? It would be better if they just rejected it directly, so as not to waste other people's time.

Sarah 2023-06-27

What's your situation now? Have you received any feedback from the editor? I have been with the editor for a week, but there haven't been any updates.

紫宸-小小 2023-06-25

6.10 submit - Submit by 6th October
6.12 with editor - Sent to the editor on 12th June
6.22 required reviews completed - Completed necessary reviews by 22nd June
6.24 required reviews completed - Completed necessary reviews by 24th June

Sarah 2023-06-25

May I ask how long it has been since your status was updated? Have you sent any email reminders?

啦啦啦咯 2023-06-20

Is yours still with the editor?

嘴巴选手小天 2023-06-18

6.17 接受 translates to "Acceptance on 6.17" or "Accepting on 6.17" in English.

jiafeimao123 2023-06-17

Snail, what happened in the end? I have also been waiting for seven days and it is still RRC. There are four reviewers.

jiafeimao123 2023-06-15

The first round of RRC took 14 days, with 5 reviewers and 5 revisions. The second round of RRC has already been three days. It's so annoying.

X22 2023-06-14

May I ask how you're doing now?

asdfdcv 2023-06-09

It has been ten days, how are you guys hungry?

Scientific G 2023-06-08

23.3.21 Submission, one week later under review,
23.5.6 Two reviewers suggested major revisions, additional experiments were conducted during this period,
23.5.30 Submitted revised manuscript,
23.6.7 Accepted.
Overall, the process was relatively fast. The reviewers' questions were very professional. Thanks to their suggestions, the quality of the article has been improved.

zsdkfjwoigdkm 2023-06-07

June 5th - Revised and returned
June 6th - Accept

nbkina 2023-06-06

Yeah, it's been a week since I heard from the editor.

炼土术士 2023-06-06

5.24 Submission
5.30 with the editor, too slow.

内置网上的核糖体 2023-06-05

It has been a week since submission and it is still submitted to the journal.

快点毕业aa 2023-06-03

Excuse me, has everyone been waiting for almost a week like me, still "with editor" for JAC? Has the speed slowed down recently?

little-stone 2023-06-01

Thank you Na Chen for editing. You are truly an excellent editor, with skills and standards!

asdfdcv 2023-06-01

The text is already in English and does not require translation.

ZDDLL 2023-06-01

I am too, 5 days directly Decision in Process.

MlhNXuN 2023-05-30

4.18 under - This phrase does not have a clear meaning on its own as it is missing the context. It could potentially refer to being "under" a certain measurement, amount, or deadline.

5.29 under - Similar to the previous phrase, this also does not have a specific meaning without additional context. It could indicate being "under" a particular measurement, amount, or deadline.

雨嘀嗒嘀嗒 2023-05-29

4.11 Submission
4.17 Under review
4.23 Under review
The current status has not changed. Do you need to remind them to submit the manuscript?

asdfdcv 2023-05-28

After eight days of RRC, the rejection letter is finally coming.

asdfdcv 2023-05-27

It has been eight days since the last communication. In the meantime, I even sent a polite email to inquire, but received no response. It doesn't feel good to be left hanging.

asdfdcv 2023-05-24

Excuse me, how many days is the final RRC for the brothers?

yxqlx 2023-05-22

Just submitted 3 days ago and the decision is already in process. I'm sure it will be rejected, but why can't they just reject it sooner? It has been stuck for a week now, I want to switch as soon as possible.

贩卖机 2023-05-21

3.09 Submitted
3.09 Received by the editorial department
3.11 Under review
3.26 Awaiting completion of review
4.1 Major revision
4.25 Return of major revision
4.27 Received by the editorial department
5.7 Under review
5.20 Accepted

The May Day holiday for the editorial team may have caused some delay in time. Generally, the review process takes around 15 days, which is considered acceptable. Wishing jac continued success.

wildwolf123 2023-05-16

Thank you for your response. I thought everyone needed to confirm before entering the review process.

嘴巴选手小天 2023-05-16

No need for everyone to confirm.

wildwolf123 2023-05-15

OP, do all authors need to confirm before proceeding to the next step when submitting? Or is it okay if they don't confirm? I'm not sure about this since it's my first time submitting and I'm hesitant to rush the co-authors who are all experienced professionals.

嘴巴选手小天 2023-05-15

The speed is still very fast, both times from submission to major revisions, and both articles were completed within one month. Highly recommended!

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started