幸运加运气 2022-10-13

May I ask what does "After the major revision returns, the interface displays: In Peer Review. Your manuscript is being evaluated by researchers in your field." mean? Does it mean that it has been sent for review again, or??? I saw someone say it's not for review, what exactly is it??? Sorry, experienced experts, could you please help analyze it? Thank you.

zcphbumaster 2022-10-10

On September 15th, feedback for modifications was given (but it was somewhat confusing whether it was major or minor, as the main title on the submission interface said major, while the details below mentioned minor).
Returned on October 10th, currently under review.
Wishing for good luck.

龙旭 2022-10-07

10.5 is not 09.05. It was written incorrectly.

龙旭 2022-10-07

10.05 Receiving + Copyright Agreement

龙旭 2022-10-07

06.05 Submission
06.18 Review
07.22 Major Revision (4 experts)
08.21 Revised Resubmission
09.28 Pre-acceptance
09.05 Acceptance + Copyright Agreement

Here is a detailed description for everyone's reference. The content is about the chemical cycle of phosphorus in farmland, which has a relatively fast speed. The process took 4 months due to personal delays during the revision. The four external experts and the editor were very professional, and their feedback provided constructive contributions to the manuscript. Thanks to the Editor-in-Chief, Deputy Editor-in-Chief, and the reviewing experts.

Leo-wang 2022-10-06

Is there still no result at the moment?

Leo-wang 2022-10-06

Fast speed, submission is assigned to an editor on the second day, and sent for review on the tenth day.

BestYu 2022-10-05

You can also check the status, but all email correspondence and message notifications will be received by the corresponding author's email.

大地行者 2022-10-05

Excuse me, may I ask how to check the submission status of my article? It was submitted by my supervisor, and I am the first author. Do I need to log in with the teacher's account to see it? Thank you for your help.

小王同学来啦 2022-09-27

Dear OP, have you received any feedback on your article recently?

科研飞猪 2022-09-27

An external review will be conducted in over a month's time, with feedback expected to be received within a month. This feedback is only for reference! Please be patient and you will definitely receive the news.

大魔王512 2022-09-22

Excuse me, did the original poster send the editing work for external review? It has been 4 weeks for me as well, and I am anxious.

小王同学来啦 2022-09-17

Mine too, it's been 18 days since I submitted it for major repairs, but there hasn't been any progress.

BestYu 2022-09-16

Article received, providing everyone with a reference.
5.14 submitted
5.1.6 editor assigned
6.1 in peer review
7.15 rejected and resubmitted
7.24 resubmitted
8.31 minor revision
9.7 revision submitted
9.13 final decision (modified supporting information)
9.14 resubmitted
9.16 accepted

龙旭 2022-09-15

It has been 25 days since R1's major repair without any news. I am getting worried. I would like to ask everyone, on average, how many days does it usually take to receive a reply after returning for repairs?

LLLvin 2022-09-13

How long has the original poster decided to come back? It has been a month already, and it's still in the hands of the editor without being reviewed. I'm getting really anxious.

HL.ZZZ 2022-09-13

Is anyone paying attention to the two new subsidiary publications under JAFC? How is the quality and speed?

zcphbumaster 2022-09-13

Has the OP not received the initial review results yet? Or have they already received some feedback? It has been 35 days since my initial review and there hasn't been any progress. Sigh, feeling anxious.

科研飞猪 2022-09-13

The result of the manuscript review has not come back yet.

zcphbumaster 2022-09-12

Has the result of the main post's external review come back?

zcphbumaster 2022-09-09

2022/08/09 submit
2022/08/09~2022/09/09 Currently under review for one month, still in the initial review stage, hoping for a smooth process.
To be continued...

Coooong 2022-09-07

The paper has been accepted smoothly. Let me share my submission experience.
2022.06.10 submit
2022.07.14 major revision
2022.08.12 resubmit
2022.08.30 minor revision
2022.09.01 resubmit
2022.09.03 minor revision
2022.09.03 resubmit
2022.09.06 accept
Thanks to the editor and reviewers. I hope JAFC will continue to improve.

Coooong 2022-09-07

So it turns out that's how it is. Thank you so much for your response. Currently, the paper has been successfully accepted~

LLLvin 2022-09-06

Have you all submitted for review now?

大魔王512 2022-09-06

Like the original poster, same editor, waiting.

hu bo 2022-09-06

Received on September 2nd, JAFC is really efficient! The editor is also very responsible and efficient!

LALAL 2022-09-05

The same situation, it has been almost a month and it is still in the hands of this editor. May I ask how your final results are? I'm really anxious.

决胜2023 2022-09-05

May I ask how long does this editor take to review your submission? Is it one week or still under review? Thanks♪(･ω･)ﾉ

学术小趴菜 2022-09-05

After half a month of submission, it is suggested to transfer to another journal of ACS, ACS Food Science & Technology. I couldn't find the impact factor.

BestYu 2022-09-05

Did you receive it? Original poster