YYRYY 2023-05-17

2023.2.27 Submission
4.24 Required reviews completed
5.12 Decision in process
5.13 Reject
Four reviewers provided their opinions for more than 20 days, and their comments were quite reasonable.

gezary 2023-05-15

Hello, how can I get in touch with the editor-in-chief? Where can I find the email address?

gezary 2023-05-15

I would like to ask, where can I find the email address to send a reminder for the manuscript?

B1565165 2023-05-13

Hello, I submitted my application in November 2023 and it has been under review since then. May I know where I can find the tracking link to see how many reviewers have completed the review?

cjbhhh 2023-05-06

So difficult, I have worked on it for a month, and the editor directly rejected it.

天涯的心跳 2023-05-05

None of the judges said rejected, they all said recommended for publication, but it needs major revisions... That troublemaker Wang Qingguo directly rejected it... Shapi Journal, ruining my youth.

小样投降 2023-05-04

Hello, what is the attitude of your reviewers and why did the editor reject it?

天涯的心跳 2023-05-03

This journal, to be honest, is really damn slow. I submitted my paper at the end of November last year and received the rejection notice at the end of April. During this period, I reminded them countless times, but they didn't respond. The editor-in-chief also has a bad temper, saying if you can't wait, withdraw your submission... In the end, they rejected my paper. They wasted half a year, cursed at me, and gave me a rejection... It's ridiculous, seriously delaying my submission of other papers. It's slow and rubbish, a second-tier TOP journal. Damn it!

YYDBB 2023-04-30

Where is this going? My February is already over and there hasn't been any change in three months. I feel so hopeless.

Shenghuajiang 2023-04-28

May I ask if you have obtained the results for your current thesis?

xueyingjiang 2023-04-28

Ask everyone, how is the recent processing speed of this journal?

cjbhhh 2023-04-26

Does anyone know why after I was "with editor," the editor invited me, and then I went back to being "with editor" again?

Fiona 2023-04-23

Where can I see the tracking link?

Fiona 2023-04-23

I would like to ask, where can I see several reviewers agreeing and several reviewers rejecting, and is there a tracking link? Thank you very much.

qqwqs 2023-04-07

Are you experiencing a high rate of reoccurrence after repair? Or is the high rate of reoccurrence occurring right after initial investment?

ZhongaChong 2023-04-05

May I ask if the editor is requesting a revised plagiarism report due to a high similarity rate? Is everyone submitting plagiarism reports through the iThenticate official website? It is too expensive.

海派流星 2023-04-04

I have finished typesetting my edited version, which is 17 pages long. When I submitted my initial draft, I didn't follow the requirement of double spacing. It seems like I used 1.3 spacing instead. The final document turned out to be 30 pages long.

Lif 2023-04-01

Initial Date Submitted: Jan 28, 2023
With Editor: Feb 1, 2023
Editor Invited: Feb 3, 2023
Under Review: Feb 18, 2023
Required Reviews Completed: Mar 9, 2023
Completed - Reject: Mar 31

Chris 2023-03-27

Hello, my paper is currently in minor revisions. The reviewer has no objections, but the editor-in-chief wants the article to be shortened. Currently, my paper is in a font size of 12 and double-spaced, spanning 47 pages. I would like to ask if it is necessary to strictly adhere to the instructions and reduce it to within 20 pages. Thank you for your reply!

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

I suggest everyone not to rush to submit the manuscript. It's useless. The editor often gets impatient and says things like if you can't wait, then withdraw your submission.

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

I'm not sure about anything else, but if I keep urging for the article submission two or three more times, the chief editor will get annoyed, and I guess my paper will be in trouble... still slow.

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

Indeed, I am still looking for the fourth reviewer. It has been almost two months, but I can't just resubmit with only three reviewers... It's really difficult, and the editor-in-chief is getting impatient with the reminder.

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

Still haven't received the revised manuscript. They say they are inviting a fourth reviewer, but haven't been able to find a suitable candidate since the end of January. They have sent three reminders since February, and it seems like the editor-in-chief is getting frustrated. I feel so uneasy and uncomfortable. It has put me in a difficult position. I hope this won't affect the acceptance of the paper.

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

Alas, it's too slow. Recently, I have been reminded several times to submit my manuscript, and the editor is getting impatient. I wonder what fate awaits my paper... I feel miserable.

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

It seems to be the editor-in-chief, maybe they have been urging several times recently, and the editor-in-chief is a bit impatient. I wonder what fate awaits my thesis... I don't know if there will be any impact...

天涯的心跳 2023-03-15

It seems to be the editor-in-chief. Maybe he has been urging several times recently, and the editor-in-chief is a little anxious. I don't know what fate my paper will have...

lcqlcq 2023-03-14

Hello, may I ask if I am contacting the editor-in-chief via email? Or is it the deputy editor-in-chief? Thank you.

天涯的心跳 2023-03-14

"He insists on finding the fourth reviewer... They are really like a married couple..."

天涯的心跳 2023-03-14

It has been 4 months since submission, and it took 3 of us to complete the review. We desperately need to find one more person, as we cannot proceed with revisions after 3 people have finished... It's really frustrating...

天涯的心跳 2023-03-14

I'm really fed up. It has been almost 4 months since submission, and there are still only 3 reviewers reviewing it. They keep saying they are looking for the 4th reviewer, stubbornly insisting on waiting for all 4 reviewers to finish before requesting revisions. It's so frustrating to urge them repeatedly. Sometimes, if lucky, they may respond after being reminded, but most of the time, there is no response at all. It feels like it will never end, and the speed is unbelievably slow. I guess I will receive a rejection when I'm 100 years old.