SC---30 2022-12-21

Is there any result, bro?

LYZ 2022-12-15

Individual submission process for reference:
First submission: March 1, 2022
Under review: April 1, 2022
Decision in process: May 4, 2022
Major revision: August 7, 2022
Revised submission: September 18, 2022
Under review: October 5, 2022
Decision in process: November 8, 2022
Accept: December 15, 2022
Wishing everyone success!

SC---30 2022-12-07

Status Status date
submit 2022-10-6
under review 2022-10-15
Required Reviews Completed 2022-12-5
Is this status indicating a potential rejection?

TYUTJYL 2022-11-09

I am too. I have been submitting for 7 months, still with the editor. I have reminded them twice, but there has been no response.

风浪雨奏 2022-11-01

The submission made on June 12th is still "with editor" as of now (November 1st). What is the situation?

西游菜鸟 2022-10-26

Has been submitted for four months, still with the editor, it's surprisingly slow, so frustrating.

阿福宝贝 2022-10-23

In Zimmerman's editorship, the speed is slow, but fortunately, it is more objective and fair.

beyond_guo 2022-10-20

It has been three and a half months, with the editor, staying motionless.

hnustzzz 2022-10-19

It has been 5 months on my end.

Mascot_ 2022-10-19

It has been a whole two and a half months now, and the status has always been "with editor." Oh my goodness! The manuscript should still be in the hands of Editor Z, and the associate editor hasn't been assigned yet.

TYUTJYL 2022-09-26

It has been several months with no news at present. Sending a reminder once, but it doesn't work.

deem 2022-09-21

Same size z, same May submission, currently still with editor, reminded twice, no response.

hnustzzz 2022-09-20

May 17, 2022 Post
May 20, 2022 With editor, assigned to Editor Z
Currently, there is no news, the system will remind again after one reply is urged to assign the editor.

binnwey 2022-09-18

2022.9.1 Submission
2022.9.13 with editor
2022.10.4 Decision in Process

quanuquan 2022-09-06

The decision has been in process for 8 months now, and there has been no progress. I have even followed up twice, but they completely ignored me.

Hahaha 2022-08-22

Journals are great, but the reviewer's comments offer no assistance in improving the paper.

Cheny 2022-08-13

Hello, may I ask if your two revisions are minor revisions? Will the revised version also be reviewed by the editor?

Cheny 2022-08-13

Hello! May I ask, is "revise" a minor revision, and does a minor revision go through the reviewer again?

阿福宝贝 2022-08-11

At that time, we didn't mention major or minor revisions. The suggestion was to revise. Major revisions certainly require further review, but giving an opportunity for modifications implies that the chances are quite high.

RM-ST 2022-08-10

May I ask if the editor-in-chief is requesting minor revisions or major revisions? If it's major revisions, do we need a second external review?

阿福宝贝 2022-08-09

After modification, it was not submitted for review. Four months later, the editor accepted it directly. From submission to acceptance, it took exactly 20 days, one year in total.

IamAReader 2022-08-08

Decision in Process. Looking back on the past three months, with five more months to go, the road ahead seems long and distant. I have already forgotten about this article...

阿福宝贝 2022-08-05

Wow, that's awesome! With Editor 120 days, I want to see how long it will be delayed.

bingo666 2022-08-01

Submitted to the editor for 1 month, under review for 6 months, decision in progress for 1 month. Feedback received from 2 reviewers and associate editor, and their feedback was acceptable. However, the editor rejected it with only one reason: it does not fit within the scope of the journal and suggested submitting elsewhere. It is puzzling why the rejection for not fitting within the journal's scope did not occur before the external review.

风浪雨奏 2022-08-01

It has been over a month since submission, and it is still with the editor. Is this normal?

我也想卷，可我太菜了 2022-07-22

Do you have any results now? My decision has been in process for four months and still no news... Who is your editor?

dsada 2022-07-16

Now it is no longer top-tier, International Journal of Mining Science and Technology is the top-tier now! Their impact factor is 7.6, which is much higher. It is estimated that it will be even higher in the future! IJRMMS is no longer good enough.

aaqwea 2022-07-09

This journal is overall pretty good.

阿福宝贝 2022-07-04

I originally didn't want to complain, but I can't stand it anymore. I submitted the article on August 29th last year, received revision suggestions on February 28th this year, made revisions according to the suggestions and submitted it again on April 8th. Since then, it has been in the "with editor" status. I know the review process can be slow, and most articles take about a year to be reviewed. However, I feel like my article won't be published by the end of this year, and it will probably be delayed until next year.

IamAReader 2022-07-01

under review for nearly 4 months; decision took 2 months; still no news, I'm really frustrated with this journal.