Verified Reviews - INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ROBUST AND NONLINEAR CONTROL
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

yaoyaozi 2022-06-17

Hello, my situation is quite similar to yours before. May I ask if you could kindly provide me with the contact information of the editor-in-chief?

大队长0041 2022-06-06

2021.4 Submission
2021.6 First review result - Major revision
2021.11 Revised
2022.6 Accepted
It took 14 months, 7 months after the first review revision, with no assigned ADM in the system. Couldn't find anyone to follow up, couldn't find the contact information of the responsible associate editor. Found the contact information of the editor on the homepage, followed up with the editor, received a reply from the editor, and two days later, it was accepted.
Not sure if the system has been changed, but no one is managing the old system anymore.

lfj0101 2022-06-04

Hello, may I ask if you resubmitted your manuscript after it was rejected? Do you need to respond to all the comments from the previous reviewer when resubmitting?

yaoyaozi 2022-06-03

Dear all, I have already submitted my paper for a year now, similar to the previous commenter. The second round of revisions was requested in November, but I haven't received any outcome yet. I am curious if the entire journal is currently experiencing delays.

wenjinghe 2022-06-01

Has the status of the original poster changed? I have been in the first review for 6 months, and now I have returned from major repairs for over a month, but I have not been assigned an adm. It is still under review.

i6277 2022-06-01

Does anyone know how fast the review process is?

大队长0041 2022-05-23

Have you found the person responsible for urging?
I submitted it in April last year, gave feedback for major revisions in June, received the revised version in November, and then entered an endless waiting period. There is no allocated ADM in the system, so it is impossible to find anyone to urge.

梅花盛开 2022-05-22

It has been a year, definitely need to remind.

yaoyaozi 2022-05-22

Who can help me with some guidance? After a major overhaul, it will take one month to return for reevaluation. It has been exactly one year since the submission. Do I really have hope? I also don't dare to rush.

始于足下 2022-05-19

The RNC submission system has been changed, now it is https://wiley.atyponrex.com/dashboard?siteName=RNC, not ScholarOne anymore.
In the previous ScholarOne system (where I submitted before), I couldn't find the New Submission option after searching for a while. The old ScholarOne submission website has been changed. Let's use the new website for submissions, as the old ScholarOne system is no longer available for submissions.

科研小怪 2022-05-13

The International Journal of Robust and Nonlinear is an authoritative international journal in the field of control theory and applied mathematics, second only to TAC and AC. Many top experts publish their articles in this journal. It is a mainstream magazine in many prestigious universities, including those in the 985 and 211 projects. It is highly regarded for evaluating professional titles and other related assessments.

yyds_SCI 2022-01-04

Reapply and be directly hired after revision.

Ervin 2021-11-15

May I ask, how long does it take to allocate after the first round of revisions? I have been waiting for over half a month and still haven't been assigned.

Adept142 2021-09-19

22-Apr-2021--07-Aug-2021 major revision
16-Aug-2021--18-Sep-2021 accept
After the first review, the evaluation of the recommendation will last for about two weeks. After the second review, the final opinion will be given within three to four days. After all, some major issues in my previous submission to other journals have been resolved, and the reviewers have been very positive. Overall, I am lucky, and I wish everyone a pleasant submission experience~

yyds_SCI 2021-09-01

Translated text:
Submitted on 28-Jul-2021.
Still under review until now.
I wanted to ask everyone, it has been over a month and it is still under review. When will there be feedback? Should I ask the editor?

xhcvvvv 2021-08-27

What is the duration for the third review to produce results?

xhcvvvv 2021-08-26

May I ask how long it will take for the second trial to produce a result?

leung 2021-08-24

How long is your second trial?

xhcvvvv 2021-08-10

Thank you, we have already provided the review comments.

31008110422 2021-08-08

@xhcvvvv You can remind them for the manuscript now.

贞子缠身 2021-08-05

How long did your "under review" and "evaluating recommendation" occur at the same time?

贞子缠身 2021-08-05

How long has it been since you submitted your contribution until now?

xhcvvvv 2021-07-30

May I ask everyone, how long does it take for the results to be available if both states "under review" and "evaluating recommendation" appear at the same time? It has been a month for me and it is still in this state, I'm getting worried.

xhcvvvv 2021-07-30

May I ask how long both states, "under review" and "evaluating recommendation," have been present at the same time? It has been like this for a month now.

double oneone 2021-07-19

I have been in this state since June 28th. It has been over 11 months from submission until now, a long wait.

哈哈哈木木哦 2021-07-18

It has been five months, and there is still no feedback from the first trial.

xhcvvvv 2021-07-16

No news for the past half month.

double oneone 2021-07-16

Has the result come out now? It has been half a month since my second trial went back and this state appeared.

xhcvvvv 2021-07-16

The second evaluation recommendation has been two weeks, and there is still no result. Who knows how long it will take for the result to be announced? Thank you.

Ready 2021-07-08

Less than a week, the editor rejected it directly. I have to say the efficiency is very high.

Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript

Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.

Search

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started