without347 2021-08-27

How long will it be online after sending the proof?

mll1993 2021-08-26

After 33 days of returning for repair, they finally replied to me. There was no "under review" process, and they directly changed to a new reviewer for the second review. The second review response was submitted the day before yesterday.

Iloveranran 2021-08-15

I returned after making revisions on August 4th, but today, on the 15th, it was rejected. Three reviewers agreed to publish, but one rejected it. The editor rejected it too! I don't know what the editor is thinking! Does anyone know if it's possible to argue with this journal?

sdf457889 2021-08-13

Late July review techniques, a total of 3 reviewers provided 11 comments. It took 20 days to make the revisions and submit them. Now it is "under review" again. Hopefully, it will be processed quickly.

minmin 2021-08-12

2021.6.23 Return after second revision
2021.8.12 Received
After nearly five months, it finally landed.

sunny45690 2021-08-03

Notify and sign the agreement three days after acceptance, then provide proof within approximately two weeks.

194593 2021-07-29

This is because someone refused to review the manuscript, so the editor found a new reviewer. Therefore, every time a new reviewer is found, the status date will change.

五把小刷子 2021-07-29

5.7 submitted;
5.10 under review;
5.25 under review;
5.26 under review;
6.13 under review;
6.15 under review;
7.1 under review;
7.28 under review;
I want to ask, in this kind of system, when the time updates but the status remains "under review," what does it mean?

mll1993 2021-07-28

It has been 10 days since it was sent back for repairs and it is still with the editor, an editor from India. It may be due to the pandemic.

安东尼奥 2021-07-27

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to receive the copyright agreement after acceptance?

安东尼奥 2021-07-27

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to sign the copyright agreement after receiving it?

sunny45690 2021-07-20

Starting from April, I submitted to several journals continuously and got rejected. HE gave me the last hope, and I have been hoping that one day my manuscript will be accepted, so I can share my submission experience. Finally, submitting a manuscript is not easy, and I hope everyone can succeed!

I submitted on May 24, and on May 26, it went to the editor. On May 31, it was under review, and on June 24, the review was completed. However, my supervisor didn't notify me promptly, and I only saw the system notification on June 28, requesting revisions before July 15. There were two reviewers, both requiring major revisions and additional experiments. The questions were sharp, but fortunately, it wasn't directly rejected. I am grateful to the editor for giving me a chance to make corrections! After struggling for half a month, I submitted the revised version on July 14, and on July 20, it was accepted. I was worried that it would go through another round of revisions or that my answers to the questions would not satisfy the reviewers and result in rejection. I didn't expect it to be accepted directly. I am overjoyed! Thanks to the reviewers, and thanks to Editor Ramazan Solmaz! The processing speed was really fast.

Lastly, I hope HE continues to improve and increase its impact factor.

Chia 2021-07-18

Your situation is very similar to mine. Have you obtained any results?

194593 2021-07-15

Hello, may I ask how long does it take for this journal to process the manuscript after receiving it?

sdf457889 2021-07-15

Submitted on April 13th, under review as of the 17th.

Iloveranran 2021-07-14

Return of the review comments on July 13th. There were four reviewers, two rejected the manuscript. One of them raised many questions, one requested revisions, and one agreed to accept it. The editor requested revisions and gave 20 days. Let's try our best to make the necessary changes and hope for good luck!

安东尼奥 2021-07-14

May I ask, when did you submit your post, OP?

sdf457889 2021-07-14

"Under review" for two months turned into "required reviews completed," and then changed back to "under review" for one month. On July 13th, it changed again to "required reviews completed." It feels like there may be more bad news than good news. Waiting for the outcome...

mll1993 2021-07-14

I maintained this status for two weeks, waking up every morning to check my inbox.

mll1993 2021-07-14

I also edited and commented on the sentence about the feedback on repairs. It was submitted at the end of May, and the feedback on repairs came back on July 4th. There are four minor repairs that have not been completed yet.

194593 2021-07-13

I would like to share my submission experience. After being rejected from the first journal, I resubmitted to IJHE. Due to the comprehensive data, the submission process went smoothly.

On April 16, 2021, I submitted to the journal.
On April 19, 2021, it was with the editor.
On May 4, 2021, it was under review.
On June 20, 2021, there was a minor revision. There were two reviewers, both suggesting minor revisions. No additional experiments were required, only textual modifications. The editor gave three weeks for revision.
On July 9, 2021, the revised version was submitted.
On July 13, 2021, it was accepted.

Proofreading should be done soon. I wish everyone a successful submission and hope IJHE continues to improve.

冲冲冲啊 2021-07-12

I remember receiving a similar response for my submission, and it was accepted after making the revisions suggested by the reviewer.

工大科研人 2021-07-12

I would like to ask everyone, is it a good outcome to start with this, or should I use a polite opening? I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript received positive feedback from the reviewers. Although the reviewers raised many questions, they did not state their opinions, so I am currently unsure.

Paper. Chen 2021-07-11

This year, I submitted two papers to IJHE. One was reviewed and accepted relatively quickly, while the other took more time. Both papers have been accepted and are currently awaiting publication online. How long will it take for them to be published online? And how long after the online publication can we expect to see the inclusion results? Can any experts provide some insights?

1. Paper 1:
- Received: April 11, 2021
- Received in revised form: May 27, 2021
- Accepted: June 6, 2021
- Available online: [insert date]

2. Paper 2:
- Received: March 29, 2021
- Received in revised form: June 14, 2021
- Accepted: June 23, 2021
- Available online: [insert date]

Iloveranran 2021-07-07

The editing process is very slow, 5-30 with the editor, and it was not until 6-13 that it went under review. The review process was quite fast, and by 7-1 all required reviews were completed. However, it is now 7-7 and I still haven't received any feedback. The speed of the editor... I hope to receive good news soon! Otherwise, this long wait would have been in vain!

Iloveranran 2021-07-07

The editing process is very slow, with the editor taking 5-30 days. It wasn't until 6-13 that it went under review. The peer review process, on the other hand, was quite fast, with required reviews completed by 7-1. It's now 7-7 and I still haven't received any feedback. The speed of the editor... I hope to receive good news soon! The long wait wouldn't be in vain then!

顺理成章 2021-07-06

I would like to ask, will this journal have the "under review" status, or will there be feedback directly after the "with editor" status within a month?

顺理成章 2021-07-06

How long will it take for you to edit it?

顺理成章 2021-07-06

投 means "to submit" and with eitor seems to be a typo. Assuming you meant "with editor," the translation is as follows:

Submitted on July 4th, with editor on July 5th.

123hh 2021-07-05

May I ask which journal you submitted to?