mll1993 2021-11-16

I went back to make revisions with the editor 40 days ago and sent it for external review. It has been 43 days now, but there is still no progress or response.

未来大咖 2021-11-12

It has been twenty days since the minor repair, but it is still with the editor. I don't know why it is taking so long. Even if they only spend one day to review each issue, it should have been finished long ago. Unfortunately, they just refuse to handle it for you.

今天论文送审了嘛 2021-11-06

10.27 Submission
10.28 with editor
10.31 with editor
Still in the hands of the editor until now. I am waiting!

未来大咖 2021-11-04

At the same time, a second alloy article that was repaired and returned was also received. It has been more than ten days since then, and there has been no progress. The editor's date has been stuck on the second day after the repair. Should we remind them?

Lang Hu 2021-11-04

Little repair was submitted on August 12th and the acceptance email was received on August 13th.

未来大咖 2021-11-04

I want to know how long it took for you to receive your revisions. It has been 11 days since I returned my revisions and it is still with the editor. I need this article urgently for graduation!

Iloveranran 2021-10-23

My also with editor twice, under review twice, does their updating on this date mean changing the editor and reviewer?

爱因斯坦的公式 2021-10-08

I am also at this point in time, too slow.

哒啦啦 2021-10-07

8.15 submit
8.16 with editor
8.20 with editor
9.3 under review
9.25 under review
9.27 under review
Does anyone have a similar situation? The review process is taking a long time, and I am getting a bit anxious.

mll1993 2021-10-04

Finally, on October 3rd, after waiting for over a month, the second revision was submitted for external review.

mll1993 2021-10-02

The first round had four reviewers, all of whom were minor revisions.

124 2021-09-27

May I ask how many reviewers' comments you received for your first round of revisions?

mll1993 2021-09-27

Submission in May, returned for revision on July 4th. Four minor revisions were made, and the revised version was submitted in mid-July. After 33 days of review with the editor, on August 20th, the editor sent me a new reviewer's comments for a second round of revisions. I returned the revised version on August 23rd, and until today, it has been 35 days and the status is still "with editor." I really can't understand this series of actions.

sunny45690 2021-09-27

That should be fine. After receiving it, just pay attention to signing the agreement and the email with proof. If you didn't see the email at that time, there would be enough time to change the proof. Don't worry, even if you don't reply to them, they will remind you, haha.

陈江河 2021-09-26

7.15 Submission
8.20 Repair suggestions
9.02 Submission
9.20 Second repair
9.22 Submission
9.23 Acceptance

Sunny-Meng 2021-09-24

So, how long were you online later?

Sunny-Meng 2021-09-24

Received on the 9.5th, three days later Elsevier sent an email saying "Track your article!" At that time, I couldn't connect, and until now, I haven't received the next email. I wanted to ask the OP if this would have any impact and if they have experienced a similar situation before.

qweqw 2021-09-19

I would like to ask, the journal guidelines state that no more than 12 figures and tables are allowed, but most of the published articles in the journal have exceeded this limit. Can I exceed 12 figures and tables when making revisions?

xiaoyuer123 2021-09-16

Generally, it takes about two weeks with the editor. Don't be too impatient.

xiaoyuer123 2021-09-16

The review comments have come back, waiting for the editor to make a decision.

未来大咖 2021-09-15

I vomited twice for this journal, with two identical experiences. If you're about to graduate, never submit here. With the editor, it takes a month just to find a reviewer in person. Otherwise, they would reject your submission. If this journal continues like this, it won't be long before it goes downhill. Everyone, please refrain from submitting!

未来大咖 2021-09-15

Did you send the email? I'm convinced. It's been a month with the editor. What's the processing speed for the editing?

mll1993 2021-09-14

I returned for the first repair and waited for more than 40 days with the editor. Now, for the second repair, it is still stuck with the editor since August 25th. This journal is too slow!

不想再等了 2021-09-14

Did you send an email? Classmate.

筱团 2021-09-12

Until today, I am still with the editor, and the date remains on August 28th. I plan to send an email to inquire about the situation because this is becoming too much of a hassle.

不想再等了 2021-09-09

8.23 required reviews completed
8.25 required reviews completed
8.26 required reviews completed
What happened that there has been no feedback given until today??

未来大咖 2021-09-05

I want to ask if the post author has submitted it for review now. My situation is the same as yours. With the editor, it has been ten days and the status hasn't changed.

筱团 2021-09-02

This time
Submitted on August 19
With editor on August 21
With editor on August 28 and it stayed that way. Did the reviewers not accept the manuscript?

工大科研人 2021-08-30

It's been almost 50 days, and there is still no news after the first review for modification. Did the reviewer go on vacation? It's agonizing.

sunny45690 2021-08-28

The proof will be online in about 3 days after submission.