科研努力奋斗的小黄人 2023-07-09

I am also a reviewer. After receiving the "under review" feedback, I found that there was only one reviewer, and many of the comments were "reading as followed." I don't know what it means.

IF100 2023-07-06

It is said that there is a DIP status, which most likely means rejection. I hope I am that small probability, after all, it has been 5 months, and I am exhausted both physically and mentally!!

IF100 2023-07-06

@老菜鸟一枚: I found out through email.

zzzzer 2023-07-05

You are too fast. The editors and reviewers are barely keeping up, and you've already made minor revisions! I submitted one month earlier than you, and it's only now going through the first round of revisions.

投稿必中666 2023-07-05

23 May, 2023 Submitted
24 May, 2023 With editor
25 May, 2023 Under review
6 June, 2023 Required review completed
7 June, 2023 Minor revision
16 June, 2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
20 June, 2023 With editor
23 June, 2023 Under review
30 June, 2023 Required review completed
30 June, 2023 Minor revision, editor requested language editing
4 July, 2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
4 July, 2023 With editor
5 July, 2023 Accept

芒顿小镇 2023-07-05

I waited for 16 days for the first submission to be reviewed. I thought the second review would be faster, but I didn't expect to wait for a long time again.

洋芋豆 2023-07-05

This journal feels too popular, I guess the editor is too busy. It has been a week since I submitted, but it is still "with editor".

芒顿小镇 2023-07-05

Has it been 10 days since returning for rework with the editor? Has anyone encountered this situation before?

IF100 2023-07-04

OP, don't you have the "decision in process" status? My status has been like this for a week already.

洋芋豆 2023-07-04

You can directly send the AI or PS combined source files to the editorial department.

1OOO 2023-07-03

The reviewer said that the images are unclear. The images in the uploaded Word document are clear, but they are blurry in the PDF file. What should be done in response? (The images in the text are blurry, the images need to be redrawn to ensure that the text and illustrations in the figures are clear.)

仝了个仝飞 2023-07-03

These four months of yours, this journal can also be considered slow.

迷鹿南北 2023-07-03

I have put in a lot of effort and hard work. In my second year of doctoral studies, my second article has been accepted. As a way to fulfill my pledge, I would like to share my submission experience with everyone and wish that all of you will have your articles accepted as well!

迷鹿南北 2023-07-03

2023.2.28 - Submitted to journal
2023.3.1 - With editor
2023.3.25 - Under review
2023.4.8 - Required reviews completed
2023.4.19 - Required reviews completed
2023.4.26 - Major revision
2023.5.24 - Revision submitted to journal
2023.5.25 - With editor
2023.5.26 - Under review
2023.6.12 - Required reviews completed
2023.6.16 - Minor revision
2023.6.30 - Required reviews completed
2023.6.30 - With editor
2023.7.2 - Accept

1OOO 2023-07-02

Final major revision, a total of 5 reviewers, and no significant differences.

洋芋豆 2023-07-02

Received in less than three months, the materials are very fast.

YXT-H 2023-07-01

7.1 accept in English means to agree to something or to receive something willingly.

高质量科研民工 2023-07-01

Who is editing you? Mine is pretty fast.

洋芋豆 2023-06-30

Is it rejected after the first review?

小青虫123 2023-06-30

There is only one reviewer, and it feels like there is bias towards the article.

zzzzer 2023-06-30

It can be reviewed in about 2 weeks.

洋芋豆 2023-06-30

Hello, may I ask how long it would take to submit for review after "with editor" without rejecting the manuscript?

洋芋豆 2023-06-29

6.29 with editor

洋芋豆 2023-06-28

DIP in just over a month, very fast.

洋芋豆 2023-06-28

June 28, 2023 submission

任雪花飘 2023-06-28

What happened in the end? Thank you!

alien振 2023-06-28

0624 RRC
0626 MAJOR REVISION It's still a reviewer's opinion, it's already the third round... Couldn't you have given all the comments at once? In the previous round, you didn't mention it, and now you're giving new ones after I made the changes. It feels like the boss in China is giving different students a look each round...

zzzzer 2023-06-28

"有DIP有可能就是拒" translates to "Having DIP may possibly mean rejection" in English.

大混子渣渣 2023-06-28

I will be back in about a month after the first trial, without any DIP.

任雪花飘 2023-06-27

May I ask how long it took for you to receive the first-instance opinion? Was there a dip in between? It has been 8 days since my first-instance trial, and I haven't received any updates yet. Thank you.