么禾 2022-06-27

Can we discuss it?

xyxyxy971015 2022-06-19

It took a month and a half in total. The journal did not have a template, so I uploaded it using the OE template.

DavidWang 2022-06-08

Excuse me, senior, do you have any results?

ssd 2022-06-02

No, the date of May 4th has been changed once but the status has not changed.

科研打工人 2022-06-01

Did you receive a reply yet? We submitted our contributions around the same time.

科研打工人 2022-06-01

May I ask if you have received a response to your paper now?

科研打工人 2022-06-01

Excuse me, have you received a reply? I have also submitted a contribution for some time and I am considering whether to remind them.

科研打工人 2022-06-01

Excuse me, do you have a reply now?

赢赢 2022-05-28

Do you have a template for this journal?

linaom 2022-05-22

The paper on infrared target detection is really frustrating. It was rejected in the second review. One reviewer agreed to accept it, but the other one actually claimed that my experiment was a repetition of his and did not meet the criteria mentioned in the paper. I even shared the code openly and provided a pre-trained model.

ssd 2022-05-13

Posted on 2021.11.19 and still under review.

科研打工人 2022-05-11

Is there a reply now?

科研打工人 2022-05-11

2022.3.25 Submission,
2022.3.28 Under review,
2022.5.11 Still under review,
It feels like the journal is taking longer, and I don't know when the results will be out. I wanted to ask everyone about the publication cycle.

Xgao 2022-05-11

Excuse me, have you received a reply now? I also submitted an article on February 25th, and I haven't heard back yet. I am considering whether or not to send an email to remind them.

华容道 2022-05-11

The review requested on May 9th has been completed and is awaiting the editor's handling.

华容道 2022-05-11

May 9th, the review is finished and waiting for editing.

信小洛 2022-05-06

The editor's handling and response speed is very fast, and the reviewer is also very responsible. Overall, it was a very good submission experience.

linaom 2022-05-05

I submitted my work around the same time as you.
The first review (major revision) was done on April 9th, but there is still no result now.

华容道 2022-05-05

Posted on December 11, 2021.
Received reviewer's comments on March 3, 2022, major revisions.
Returned reviewer's comments on March 31, 2022.
May 5, 2022, second review results unknown.

There have been two updates on April 9 and May 4, but the current results are unknown.

邪恶的Q大和M 2022-05-02

Posted on December 9, 2021.
Received reviewer comments on March 3, 2022.
Returned revised manuscript on May 1, 2022.
Accepted on May 1, 2022.
First-time submission, overall experience was very good! The first review process took a little longer, possibly due to Christmas and Chinese New Year holidays. We delayed returning the revised manuscript with reviewer comments, but our response was still very diligent. Haha, I submitted to the system on May 1st at 10 PM and received the acceptance email just ten minutes later. Efficiency is impressive!!! Thanks to Editor-in-Chief Harvey Rutt and reliable reviewers. Wishing the journal continued success! I will continue to submit articles related to thermal imaging.

我茶凉了 2022-04-14

2.14投出 - Submitted on 2.14
2.20 under review - Under review since 2.20
4.14了，期间邮件催过一次无回信 - On 4.14, during the period, a reminder email was sent once with no response.

ssd 2022-04-12

I am also 5 months old, this journal has been particularly slow since last year.

科研ing~ 2022-04-11

I have been applying for half a year, and it is still "Under review."

蓝色鸣鸟 2022-03-26

2022.03.25 under review translates to "2022.03.25 being reviewed" in English.

setBossTrue 2022-03-26

It is possible that, for example, finding new reviewers or receiving feedback from reviewers could keep the status unchanged but change the timeline (specifically, what would change the timeline is unclear). I have already updated the timeline 4-5 times during the first review, and I am starting to wonder if I will receive feedback from all 8 reviewers at once when the time comes...

蓝色鸣鸟 2022-03-21

2022.01.22 Submission
2022.02.13 Under review
2022.03.02 Under review

(Did the date change once during the under review process???)

ssd 2022-03-07

It has been 4 months, those who are eager to graduate should be cautious.

ssd 2022-02-22

It's been so slow recently. I have been waiting for three months and still haven't got any results.

青青子衿悠悠我心 2022-02-15

The acceptance rate of the journal has been updated to 32.8% on the official website, and the review cycle and others have also been updated.

Damonbird 2022-01-24

Initial review took three months, with no news. I almost wrote a reminder letter but suddenly received feedback just five days before the three-month mark, possibly related to Christmas. The feedback requested minor revisions, which I uploaded five days later. The same day, it was accepted, with a very fast turnaround and a pleasant surprise. I hope everyone can successfully publish their own articles~~~