TheoYan 2023-05-22

On April 26th, the editor gave me 14 suggestions for revisions and asked me to reply after making the changes.
I replied on May 9th.
On May 22nd, the editor said my response was too vague and rejected it. They mentioned that if I want to submit again, I should respond again to the editor's questions regarding highlights, applications, and similar topics.

starry_y 2023-05-18

May 18, 2023 Submitted to Journal

LISHUSHU 2023-05-10

Can I ask if anyone has been waiting for a month without any updates on the first review with the editor?

timeddrx2 2023-05-07

Hello, I also submitted to this journal. The current status is "send back to author". When I click on it, I can see the modification suggestions given by the editor. However, after clicking on "edit submission", I can no longer see the modification suggestions. The corresponding author's email also did not receive any email regarding the modifications. Have you encountered this situation? If so, how did you resolve it?

timeddrx2 2023-05-07

I also submitted to this journal, and the current status is "send back to author." I can see the revision comments given by the editor when I click on it, but I can't see them after clicking on "edit submission." The corresponding author's email has also not received any email with revision comments. Have you encountered this situation, and if so, how did you resolve it?

timeddrx2 2023-05-07

Hello, I also submitted to this journal, and the current status is "send back to author". When I click into it, I can see the modifications suggested by the editor, but I can't see them after clicking on "edit submission". The corresponding author's email also didn't receive the modification email. Have you encountered this situation? If so, how did you resolve it?

LISHUSHU 2023-04-25

with editor中 is already in English. It means "with editor" in English.

LISHUSHU 2023-04-25

My friend, was your first round of review conducted by reviewers?

学术圈在逃科研人才 2023-04-25

2023.3.15 Submission
2023.3.17 Under Review
2023.4.25 Required Reviews Complete

ywl 2023-04-04

How is the situation with your thesis now?

LISHUSHU 2023-03-22

May I ask what's going on now? Any news?

Xchen32 2023-03-07

Excuse me, have you received any results yet?

Zach_whu 2023-02-11

My RRC has also been 15 days, may I ask if you have any results?

脆脆鲨 2023-01-15

May I ask if you have any results now? I have also required a review for over ten days.

爱一个人需要理由吗 2022-12-30

Add me as a friend and let's have a private chat to discuss.

正未搁浅 2022-12-29

Hello classmate, I would like to ask if you have added new reviewers for the second review. It has been over a month since my first review and it has been almost three months since the modifications were made for the second review. It is still in the "under review" status and the dates have changed several times. I would like to ask if this situation is common. Thank you.

小强不是小可爱 2022-12-28

Soon, with high efficiency, the reviewers are conscientious and responsible, and the editors are diligent and efficient in handling the submission process, which takes three months from submission to acceptance.

正未搁浅 2022-12-13

Hmm, thank you, I hope to have a good outcome like you.

青青子衿 2022-12-12

Dec 12, 2022 Decision in Process
A little foreigner on one side, nervous on the other.

青青子衿 2022-12-12

Dec 12, 2022 Decision in Process
Tense

XWZRBY 2022-12-12

Thank you! I hope yours will also be successful soon.

正未搁浅 2022-12-12

Classmate, congratulations!! Look, I told you that you would soon receive a high-quality paper in the top-tier journal! I hope I can also have good luck. I am anxiously waiting for the second-round review results now, it's so slow!

XWZRBY 2022-12-12

The text "2022.12.11 Accept" is already in English.

青青子衿 2022-12-11

Dec 11, 2022 - All reviews are required to be completed.

正未搁浅 2022-12-08

Hmm, thank you for your response. Congratulations, you have been hired and it's right before your eyes. I'll wait a bit longer, it has been two months since the second review, and I don't know what the situation is. I'm anxious to graduate.

XWZRBY 2022-12-07

Before, I only had one reviewer for the manuscript review. Then, the editor invited two rounds of reviewers but couldn't find any new ones. Finally, an editor from a journal with a similar focus as mine reviewed it, so for the second round, only this reviewer was added. The problem is not tricky, it's just that one point hasn't been explained clearly and needs to be clarified.

正未搁浅 2022-12-07

Classmate, congratulations! After the minor revisions, you are all set. Congratulations on receiving a paper from a top-tier journal. I wanted to ask about the final few reviewers. Are they the same as the initial reviewer or did you have to find new ones? Did they ask any particularly tricky questions? I have been in the second round of review for two months now, and the "under review" status has changed three or four times. I have no idea what's going on and it's making me very anxious.

XWZRBY 2022-12-06

2022.12.05 Minor Revision

suny0610 2022-12-03

May I ask, is it normal for a submission to be in the "Decision in Process" status for over ten days? Is this in the initial review by the editor?

Zzjw 2022-12-02

Brother, hello. May I ask if your article has been stuck in the "Required Reviews Completed" status for a long time? My article has been in this state for 20 days already, and I don't know if I should urge or not.