Zigned 2022-08-05

Submitted at the end of January 2022, received major revisions in mid-May, and submitted the revised manuscript on July 18th. It has been half a month now and it is still "with associate editor". I would like to know if we need to wait for the editor's handling before it is given to the reviewers, or if the reviewers are currently reviewing it as well.

WAITING1 2022-08-03

Has your results come back? I submitted mine in mid-March and it has been almost a month with the status "With Associate Editor," but I still haven't received any results.

huangtao 2022-07-30

Posted on January 21, 2022
First review comments returned on June 5, 2022, with agreement from two reviewers
Revised manuscript submitted on June 8, 2022
Directly accepted on July 27, 2022

Aptom 2022-07-27

2021.12.24 Submitted
2022.5.13 Reconsider, Major Revisions
2022.6.15 Resubmitted
2022.7.27 Accepted as a Paper

The initial review took nearly 5 months with three reviewers. The editor mentioned that one of the reviewers did not respond, so they had to find another reviewer, which delayed the process for a few months. However, after making the revisions, it was processed quickly. The editor was very helpful, despite one reviewer not responding, the editor still decided to accept the paper.

cdee 2022-07-15

Excuse me, has the original poster (OP) received the results? How long ago did they submit it?

Double Wang 2022-07-13

I can't believe it, this is too unfair. May I ask what specific status "under review" of IEEE TVT means? My submission became "under review" just one week after.

yqshao 2022-07-08

The deputy editor agreed to revise and resubmit, but the editor disagreed, and there is no way to appeal.

axida_letpub 2022-06-28

2022.06.28 Con Associate Editor

醒醒科研了 2022-06-28

1. On August 3, 2021, the initial draft was submitted and is awaiting administrative processing.
2. On August 5, 2021, an AE (Associate Editor) was assigned, and it has been under review since then.
============= A long wait =============
3. On February 28, 2022, it was reconsidered and major revisions were requested (the feedback was constructive, without questioning the innovation, but rather addressing some issues that need clarification and suggesting additional content according to expert opinions).
4. On March 17, 2022, a revised version was submitted.
============= A long wait =============
5. On June 25, 2022, it was accepted as a paper.

NoobofAcademia 2022-06-27

The same year, after two major revisions, it was rejected. I don't understand how you agreed after the first revision and then added three more people... Anyway, it was only one reviewer who did not agree. What are you planning to do, OP? File an appeal?

NoobofAcademia 2022-06-27

Record it. Submitted on June 20, 2021, underwent two major revisions, and received a rejection letter on June 26, 2022, after my reminder. The review process was extremely slow, especially the first round, which took six months. Of course, I also blame myself for not having experience. I should have followed up after three months. This is the first journal I have ever submitted in my life, and it is also my first SCI. Although it took a year and still didn't get accepted, I feel a lot of frustration in my heart, but there is no way. Let's organize my emotions and submit again.

姬咕噜嘟 2022-06-27

The total duration is about 10 months, although it's a bit long, the outcome is good.

axida_letpub 2022-06-26

2021.12.14 Submission
2022.06.07 Rejection and resubmission
2022.06.19 Resubmission
2022.06.21 Under review

PaperSeeker 2022-06-15

The first review gave a major revision period of three months. There were three reviewers, and their suggestions were relatively easy to incorporate. The revisions were sent back within one month. The second review took one month to be accepted. It is rare to encounter such high efficiency this time, it's all luck.

yqshao 2022-06-15

Trash journal, the first review took more than 4 months, with 3 reviewers. After making revisions based on the comments of the initial 3 reviewers, none of them agreed to accept the revised version. Then, 3 additional reviewers were assigned. One didn't provide any comments, one had no objections, and one suggested rejecting the paper, citing lack of innovation. The associate editor requested major revisions, but even after completing the revisions, the same reviewer still disagreed, claiming lack of innovation. As a result, the paper was rejected, taking nearly a year. This is extremely unfair to the authors.

zlzlzlzzl 2022-06-08

Posted on June 1, 2022, currently under review.

雾里看花 2022-06-08

2022.04.30 submission, currently under review status.

炽热 2022-05-31

I have been waiting for 6 months, it has been under review all this time. I have sent reminders but haven't received any response. Does this mean it's over...

keyancaiji 2022-05-29

Excuse me, is the word limit for all IEEE journals 4500 at most? What is the maximum word limit for IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology? Why can't I find it?

alwaysyou 2022-05-29

The latest response from AE is that the previous reviewer has stopped responding to them, so they have found a new reviewer. It's really disappointing, after waiting for almost 5 months, they suddenly tell me that the reviewer is ignoring them... There's really no one else left...

bjjs 2022-05-03

Little Xiuxiu received the job offer notification 3 months and 5 days after returning.

Aptom 2022-05-03

I am also four months now.

alwaysyou 2022-04-30

Too slow, too slow, too slow. It's really too slow. It has been reviewed for 4 months and still no results. The first time I sent an email to urge, they said one reviewer's opinion hasn't come back yet. The second time I sent an email to urge, they said two reviewers' opinions haven't come back yet... Am I definitely in a time loop, right?

炽热 2022-04-24

Same, it has been 5 months and still no news under review.

bjjs 2022-04-19

It took about 3 months, I was doing an internship outside at that time.

超爱吃甜橙 2022-04-18

Have you been making significant changes for 4 months? Why does it take so long to make these changes...

bjjs 2022-04-18

Submitted in mid-January 2021, returned for major revisions in May, and submitted again in September. Accepted in January 2022 with minor revisions, and submitted by the end of January. It has been nearly 80 days since then, and it is still under review. Graduation is approaching, and at this pace... I dare not rush, nor do I know how to rush.

Zyric 2022-04-15

No results were achieved. Notify the secretary to withdraw and make changes elsewhere. It's too outrageous.

Ann029 2022-03-26

Hanging fellow should not be very slow.

压力机与电机 2022-03-25

Is it so slow?