RERzeng 2023-05-19

Are you the first reviewer or the second reviewer? The first review is fast, but the second review is still in the external review state.

M_A 2023-05-19

Has the original poster got any results now? How many days does it usually take with AE?

M_A 2023-05-18

Did the original poster get any results now? I checked today and it suddenly changed to "With AE". How long does this status usually last? Feeling a bit anxious.

彭于晏001 2023-05-17

submitted 26-Mar-2022
Reject and Resubmit 02-Oct-2022
A resubmission has been submitted 23-Oct-2022
Accepted with Minor Revisions as a Paper 13-Mar-2023
A revision has been submitted 15-Mar-2023
Accepted as a Paper 15-May-2023
Too slow, it's the slowest journal I've ever seen. They only start processing after my advisor (IEEE Fellow) sends an email, and they won't even respond if you email the associate editor yourself.

Zzl-hit 2023-05-17

May I ask when everyone will be urging for the manuscript? The first review has already been three months.

RERzeng 2023-05-16

Currently with Associate Editor for 20 days, results unknown.

shidace 2023-05-12

Record the timeline:
2023-03-03 submitted
2023-03-04 editor assignment
2023-03-07 under review
2023-04-29 With Associate Editor
The current result is unknown, waiting.

Michael928 2023-05-02

Make a timeline record, the current result is unknown, hoping for good luck.
2023-03-02 Submitted
2023-03-06 Editor assignment
2023-03-10 Under review
2023-04-29 With associate editor
2023-05-02 Awaiting editor review

蓝色的风18 2023-05-01

May I ask if this journal requires experiments? Do you accept letters?

味道 2023-04-26

Same. Now it's under review, or is it with AE? The second review with AE has been four months already.

小黑驴 2023-04-26

Today I received a reply from the editor after sending an email. They said that one of the reviewers' opinions has not been received yet.

PEPHD发发发 2023-04-24

Electronic and Electrical Direction
Submitted on September 20, 2022.
First major revision on March 11, 2023 (5 reminders sent during this period, editor mentioned difficulties in finding reviewers).
Revised on April 4, 2023.
Within one day, it changed to "Under review."
The current outcome is unknown, please urge the reviewers to be faster. Time waits for no one.

PEPHD发发发 2023-04-24

The first trial took 5 months, and when asked about the progress of the second trial, there was no response to the email.

charity_123 2023-04-20

Hello, may I ask what does it mean when the status changes from "二审with associate editor" (second review with associate editor) to "under review" after almost two months?

裴英杰 2023-04-14

First review: 6 months, three reviewers, accepted after major revisions, constructive and to the point comments.

小黑驴 2023-04-14

The first review took two months to return with revision suggestions, and it has been five months since the second review. The request for the revised manuscript has not been responded to via email. What should I do?

xiaobochine 2023-03-28

No problem, communication and the whole text are not closely related.

爱新可新 2023-03-28

From submission to acceptance, it took a total of over 6 months, which is not bad luck. I sent an email to the editor and the type of acceptance has been changed.

一言难诉 2023-03-23

In the second review, it is normal for the status to change between "under review" and "with associate editor". In my case, it changed three times because I had three reviewers. I speculate that it is related to the reviewers' feedback.

爱新可新 2023-03-20

I would like to ask everyone for advice. My article was accepted as a short paper, but it was actually meant to be a long paper. The teacher made a mistake in the classification during submission. How can I resolve this situation? Can I contact the editor?

zhanghnu 2023-03-17

Hello, I have encountered the same situation as upstairs. Has your current status changed? Will you accept it?

zhanghnu 2023-03-17

Hello, may I ask? After my major revision, it was under review for more than ten days and then changed to "with associate editor". After one day, it changed back to "under review". What is this situation? Is this normal?

一言难诉 2023-03-14

Addendum: Overall, this journal is not very fast. If you are in a hurry to graduate, it is advisable to think carefully before submitting. It is recommended to allow for at least a year and a half of psychological preparation.

一言难诉 2023-03-14

Car positioning partition for submission, the process is as follows:
2022-06-28 submit
2022-06-29 with editor assignment
2022-06-29 under review
2023-01-28 Reconsider, major revision
----------------------------------- Resubmit
2023-02-05 under review
2023-02-20 with associate editor
2023-03-13 Awaiting Editor Review
2023-03-14 Accept
The first review took seven months, and it remained in the "under review" state until one day when the result suddenly came out, and it required major revisions, although there were very few comments. I made the revisions for a few days and resubmitted it. The second review was a back and forth between the "under review" and "with associate editor" states throughout the month of February. When the status changed to "Awaiting Editor Review," it should have been the final opinions. I received the email in the early morning.

avd 2023-03-13

The first review took approximately 3 months and resulted in a rejection with the option to resubmit. The feedback was actually quite good. After making the necessary revisions, the revised manuscript was returned for review again after about 3 months, this time as a major revision. Currently, it has been 10 days since the revised manuscript was returned and it is still under review (likely still with the Associate Editor and has not been sent out yet).

失败的科研人 2023-03-06

Posted on February 5th, 2023, it is still under review. It has been over a month.

XLH12 2023-03-05

Posted on 2022-9-21, still under review.
There is still no news, but the next-door neighbor has already been accepted.

jianwell 2023-03-03

The article is finally accepted, feeling exhausted, wish everyone good luck.

cwang22 2023-03-02

I have also just submitted two days ago and it shows "under review". I haven't received any emails since then, and it has been a month without any changes. It should still be under review, I suppose.

西门吹风 2023-03-01

With ae, the editor has just started working on the manuscript.