kelisiya 2021-06-01

After submitting the manuscript in October, I received the first round of feedback in April. Two reviewers provided feedback, one requiring major revisions and the other requesting minor revisions. Ultimately, the final feedback also called for major revisions, which was disheartening at the time (although friends consoled me by saying the first round of major revisions was acceptable). I then responded to each reviewer's comments, doubling the length of the manuscript as per their suggestions. Eventually, the second reviewer also approved the revised version. Now, I need to continue striving for top conferences.

Guifeng 2021-05-19

2020.9.25 Submission
2020.9.29 Assigned to AE
2020.11.17 Awaiting AE Decision (usually takes about 10 days)
Major revision: 2020.11.28 (completed in two weeks)
Minor revision: 2021.2.22 (completed in three days)
Acceptance: 2021.4.28
I was very lucky to have my article accepted in TMM after 7 months of submission. The review process in TMM is very strict, with five reviewers providing major revisions - three minor revisions and two major revisions. The reviewers' comments were very detailed, and after making the necessary changes, the quality of the article improved significantly. During the minor revision stage, there were three reviewers. After submitting the minor revision, the editor sent it for peer review again. Usually, after the minor revision, the editor makes the decision directly, indicating the strictness of the review process. It took about 2 months for each peer review to yield results, which is a normal review cycle. I encourage everyone to submit their articles to TMM.

kk1 2021-04-08

Accepté avec révisions obligatoires

Dr.WW 2021-04-06

Brother, did you get the results?

Dr.WW 2021-04-06

Submitted on November 7th, 2020, there has been no first review result given until now. The review process is so slow.

kk1 2021-01-14

I applied on July 21st, 2020 but haven't received any results.

Daemon_Wang 2021-01-12

Hello, I submitted it on 2020.08.16, but I haven't received any results yet. Have you received the first-instance opinion now?