Verified Reviews - IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

lalalzz 2022-07-24

2022.6.27 Submission
2022.7.19 In peer review, AE not assigned.

lalalzz 2022-07-22

It has been about five days, and the results are expected to be available soon.

WINJCS 2022-07-21

Is the status still in peer review? How many days has it been going on for?

chczzz 2022-07-21

2022.07.01 Submission
2022.07.21 Status changed to In Peer Review, AE not assigned
2022.07.26 Status changed back to Submitted, AE not assigned
2022.07.30 AE assigned
2022.10.19 Awaiting AE Decision
2022.10.23 Rejected

c 2022-07-20

I also encountered this problem before. The AE assigned later, I think it should be the chief editor reviewing your article. If the chief editor approves, they will assign a deputy editor AE after some time.

lalalzz 2022-07-20

Does anyone know what this situation means? AE: not assigned, but the status has changed to in peer review.

lalalzz 2022-07-20

It has been 24 days and I still haven't been assigned an Account Executive...

WINJCS 2022-07-19

After submission, it shows "submitted". Now one and a half months have passed, and it is still in this state. What should I do? Has anyone encountered this before?

Dan_ 2022-07-05

I just sent it out a couple of days ago, hoping for a chance to get a major overhaul! Eagerly awaiting. .jpg

lalalzz 2022-06-27

Just sent it out today, hoping for a chance for a major renovation.

hip-hop 2022-06-07

From submission to acceptance, it took a total of 4.5 months.
2022.01.21 Manuscript Submitted
2022.02.08 AE Assignment
2022.04.06 Decision to ACCEPT WITH MANDATORY MINOR REVISIONS (AQ)
2022.04.25 Revised Manuscript Submitted
2022.06.07 Decision to ACCEPT (A)

yg99992 2022-06-04

2022.05.18 Submission
2022.06.03 Informed about exceeding pages

It was only informed about exceeding pages two weeks after submission, and it was required to reduce it to within 13 pages. The efficiency of the editor is also too low. Why couldn't they notify earlier for such a simple issue?

zxl1 2022-05-30

Does the email not mention how long the review process will take?

小屁孩 2022-05-13

I remember submitting it at that time, stating that the reviewers would be given six weeks to review it.

tifser 2022-05-12

2022.03.04 Submission
2022.03.25 Assign AE
2022.06.09 Awaiting AE decision
2022.06.12 Major revision
The email stated that AE would take one week to find reviewers, and the first round of review would take four weeks. In reality, it seems that the review process is not as fast as expected.

旧城以西 2022-04-24

2022.04.20 Submission
2022.05.07 CRedit sent back, detailed contributions required for each author
2022.05.11 In Peer Review
2022.12.10 Still in peer review after seven months
2023.05.05 It has been one year since submission, haven't even received the first review, better avoid this journal
2023.08.02 Rejected. Two reviewers, one suggested major revisions, while the other found the paper worthless. There is a significant difference in the reviewers' opinions on the novelty of the paper. The journal has a high level of reviewer discrepancy and low efficiency. Urging them for a decision did not help, so I do not recommend submitting to this journal.

Pangw 2022-03-30

September 19, 2021 Post
December 20, 2021 Major Repair
January 25, 2022 Return
March 8, 2022 Minor Repair
March 25, 2022 Acceptance

8247 2022-03-10

2022.2.9 Submission, unknown review speed.

Cindy-Zhu 2022-03-10

January 2022 submission

Cindy-Zhu 2022-03-10

2021.12.20 Submission
2022.2.6 Received review comments, two reviewers

Judy9OPP 2022-03-10

Translation: Submitted in December 2021. Received review comments on February 28, 2022, from two reviewers.

LuC88 2022-03-10

The speed of review can be two reviewers.

En_dy 2022-03-10

There is no context provided for the text "IF 7.178." Therefore, it is not possible to accurately translate it into English.

Nitty 2022-03-10

This journal is the top-tier journal in information hiding, digital watermarking technology, and anti-counterfeiting authentication.

Ritalin 2022-03-10

One district top journal

vva 2022-03-10

No news received after one month of submission.

TracyCuiq 2022-03-10

The reviewer's suggestions are completely different from the actual situation, probably because they didn't examine it carefully.

be your personal best 2022-03-08

Submitted on September 28, 2021
Received reviewer comments on December 28, 2021 from two reviewers.

TheShine 2021-09-26

How long will AE: Not Assigned last?

letsgopaper 2021-08-21

Hello, may I ask in which section can I find the mandatory 5-week review period?

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now