Verified Reviews - IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Jurgn 2022-10-15

ADM: Langdon, Mikaela
September 22nd: Submission
October 5th: Rescinded, reason being the need for detailed explanation of each author's contribution
October 15th: AE not yet assigned

zhangzhang 2022-10-12

It has been over two months, and I still haven't been assigned an AE. Is it always this slow lately?

tifser 2022-10-11

Update:
2022.6.30 Major renovation completed
2022.10.11 Hired

ssqu0 2022-10-09

In early May, I submitted together with my senior fellow. My senior fellow's work has already undergone the second revision, while mine is still in the peer review stage. It's quite far from the ideal situation!

投投算了 2022-09-30

My reminder for submission is being ignored by everyone...

Dec 2022-09-24

The email has been reminded three times, and it has been reminded several times by foreigners as well. Anyway, it's just a few sentences repeated over and over again.

投投算了 2022-09-23

Is there no reminder for the manuscript? It has been over five months and the first review has not been completed yet, and there was even a change in the assistant editor in between...

Dec 2022-09-22

Replying to the question in the comments, AE is Batina Lejla.

yang1111 2022-09-21

May I ask who your AE is? It's been a long time for me too. I don't know if it's the same AE.

Dec 2022-09-20

Posted on January 4, 2022, and the first review result has not been released yet.
Incredibly slow!

zhangzhang 2022-09-15

I am also Langdon, Mikaela, and I submitted it on August 8th. There have been no changes so far.

zzrzzr 2022-09-11

9.9 submitted Unassigned AE

Iamhuxy 2022-09-02

Excuse me, isn't this journal only allowed to be revised once?

yg99992 2022-09-02

September 2nd: Received comments. Three reviewers: one requested major revisions, one accepted, and one rejected. Provided a lot of professional opinions to the reviewer who rejected. However, the editor still requested major revisions. Given one and a half months for modifications.

jxgsd 2022-08-31

This status is under internal review in the editorial department. If the editor approves it, the AE will be assigned, and then the external review will find reviewers to review it. If the editor does not approve it, it will be rejected directly.

zzrzzr 2022-08-30

Now it becomes In Peer Review, still not assigned to ae.

jxgsd 2022-08-30

I am also Langdon, this ADM Mikaela, it has been a month, and I am still drunk, still submitted. The ADM hasn't increased either, it's too slow.

zzrzzr 2022-08-29

ADM: Langdon, Mikaela
ADM: Demydenko, Michelle

Translation: ADM: Langdon, Mikaela
ADM: Demydenko, Michelle

jxgsd 2022-08-29

Hello friend, who is your first ADM?

yg99992 2022-08-26

June 4th: Submitting the paper again
June 15th: Assigning AE
August 26th: Awaiting AE Decision

lalalzz 2022-08-24

Allocate AE, enter external review.

zzrzzr 2022-08-19

It has been a month, and finally there is some change. An ADM has been added, and now there are two ADMs in the submission status. However, AE has still not been assigned, and it remains in the Submitted state.

可信 2022-08-18

In peer review, it usually takes about a month before the paper is assigned to an Associate Editor (AE) for further processing, such as the paper being sent for review.

可信 2022-08-18

January 29, 2022: Submitted for review.
Early March 2022: Peer review completed and assigned AE for further review.
April 19, 2022: Initial review and major revisions.
May 30, 2022: Revised.
July 12, 2022: Second review and major revisions.
August 18, 2022: Accepted.

lalalzz 2022-08-16

2022.8.16 submitted unassigned ae.

lalalzz 2022-08-02

I don't know, I'm also doing this for the first time.

WINJCS 2022-08-01

Will it be rejected if I am not assigned to AE for two months in peer review for one day?

lalalzz 2022-08-01

Unassigned AE, it has been 13 days in peer review. Should I be worried about it being rejected directly?

zzrzzr 2022-07-28

Did you pass the external audit?

zzrzzr 2022-07-28

Submitted on July 20th, but AE has not been assigned yet. It is still in the original submission status. It's too slow.

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started