科研之路漫漫 2022-08-20

How long has the first review been? I have been waiting for 2 months and it is still being assigned to a reviewer.

ningch 2022-08-18

provisionally accepted for publication on 2022.8.18. There were two reviewers who had minor comments, and the Associate Editor and Editor-in-Chief gave a conditional acceptance. After a year, I finally see the light. The difficulty of getting published in TII is not a joke compared to regular issues.

LuoMR 2022-08-17

The day before yesterday, I was still waiting for reviews, and today it has become awaiting AE recommendation. There should be results soon.

一定能中的 2022-08-17

It has been more than two weeks since I submitted my major revision, and I am still waiting for reviews. What does this mean? Has your status changed recently?

ningch 2022-08-17

After the rejection, when resubmitting, a response to the reviewer's questions should be included. Regarding the page limit, it should be discussed in the email. In my case, for resubmission after rejection, the requested modifications cannot exceed 10 pages. For major revisions, the requested modifications cannot exceed 11 pages.

XWZRBY 2022-08-17

Yes, I initially controlled it within 10 pages, but then it was returned and I was told that the first submission must be limited to 8 pages, with a maximum of no more than 8 and a half pages. So, I reduced it to 8 and a half pages.

ZXNzxn1 2022-08-16

Hello, I would like to ask, for the first submission to TII, is it necessary to keep it within 8 pages?

XWZRBY 2022-08-16

Is the editor on vacation now? It's been almost a month and they're still assigning reviewers. Sigh!

有山鸟 2022-08-16

There is no page requirement for the response letter.

LuoMR 2022-08-16

Please add the response to the editorial comments in the attachment, with a maximum of twelve pages. There will be no additional charges for up to eight pages.

strive725 2022-08-16

Hello, my first-round opinion is to reject and resubmit. I would like to ask if it is necessary to include a reply to the reviewer's comments when resubmitting? Also, is it acceptable for the length of the article to exceed 8 pages but not exceed 10 pages when resubmitting? I am looking forward to your reply. Thank you!

strive725 2022-08-16

Hello, my first opinion is also to resubmit the rejected manuscript. I would like to ask if it is necessary to include a reply to the reviewer's comments when resubmitting? Also, can the length of the article exceed 8 pages but not exceed 10 pages when resubmitting? I am looking forward to your reply, thank you!

LuoMR 2022-08-15

2022.7.29 inviting reviewers
2022.8.15 waiting for reviews

Bayesian Slave 2022-08-14

Accepted on 2022/08/14.

Bayesian Slave 2022-08-14

2022/07/26 Major repair and return
2022/08/10 awaiting AE recommendation Only one reviewer, reviewed at lightning speed
2022/08/11 awaiting co-EIC decision Hoping for a positive outcome

ningch 2022-08-11

awaiting review scores 2022.8.4 - Waiting for the review scores on August 4th, 2022.
awaiting ae recommendation 2022.8.11 - Waiting for the AE (Associate Editor) recommendation on August 11th, 2022.

After resubmitting the rejected manuscript, it underwent major revisions and was submitted again. It only took a week for it to reach the AE. Is it common for the review process to be this fast? In this situation, is the likelihood of being rejected high or the likelihood of being accepted high? Can any experienced individuals passing by explain? Thank you very much, feeling anxious.

一定能中的 2022-08-09

How long does it take? Has your article been accepted?

伴你高飞 2022-08-09

The meaning has not reached the reviewers yet, the next step could be awaiting reviewer scores.

abelard 2022-08-08

Hello, after revising the rejected manuscript, respond to each comment carefully. There is a high probability of acceptance. Additionally, I would like to ask how long it usually takes for you to provide feedback on the review.

LK 2022-08-08

What is the likelihood of acceptance after resubmitting a rejection?

一定能中的 2022-08-08

What does "Waiting for Reviews" mean after the major repair returns?

Clark Mark 2022-08-04

2022/04/13 submitted, awaiting co-editor-in-chief assignment

2022/04/20 awaiting associate editor assignment

2022/04/26 assigning reviewers

2022/05/10 assign additional reviewers

2022/05/16 assigning reviewers

2022/05/20 assign additional reviewers

2022/05/28 awaiting review scores

2022/08/01 awaiting associate editor recommendation

2022/08/03 awaiting editor-in-chief decision

2022/08/03 major revision required

LuoMR 2022-08-02

submitted: 2022-2-20
reject&resubmit: 2022-4-4
resubmitted: 2022-6-3
major-revision: 2022-7-2
resubmit: 2022-7-29

Translation:
submitted: 2022-2-20
reject&resubmit: 2022-4-4
resubmitted: 2022-6-3
major-revision: 2022-7-2
resubmit: 2022-7-29

ningch 2022-08-02

Major revision: 2022.6.6
Resubmitted: 2022.8.2
The paper was resubmitted after revisions following the R&R (revise and resubmit) decision. It went to the Associate Editor (AE) on May 9th and entered the review process on May 16th. There were suspicions of arbitration. Fortunately, on June 6th, it was given a major revision, with 6 weeks to make the necessary changes. At this point, the three reviewers' comments on the innovation of the paper became irrelevant. The questions raised by the first and third reviewers were not very critical, while the second reviewer still had a lot of sharp questions and requested additional comparative experiments. However, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, it was not possible to conduct experiments at the university. An extension of 2 weeks was granted, and the revised paper was submitted today. The outcome is unknown, so I will provide an update later. This is my first submission to TII (Transaction on Industrial Informatics) and it feels much more challenging compared to its sister journal TIE (Transaction on Industrial Electronics).

DLBP_Liang 2022-07-30

What is the situation with my Awaiting AE Recommendation for the past few months?

sdx2199 2022-07-28

Hello, is it necessary to reply to the reviewer's comments only in the "your response" box in TII? Can I add additional replies to the reviewer's comments nearby? Looking forward to your response.

sdx2199 2022-07-28

Hello, author. Can we only reply to the reviewer's comments in the "your response" box in TII? Is it possible to also add additional comments to respond to the reviewer? Looking forward to your reply.

liangcang 2022-07-28

How long did the brothers review the manuscript?

sdx2199 2022-07-28

Hello, may I ask how you resolved it? Can attachments be submitted in the reply email?

sdx2199 2022-07-28

When submitting revised manuscripts and reply letters, may I ask if the main text is 12 pages and there is no specified page requirement for the reply letter?