Verified Reviews - IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Derek 2022-12-22

2021.12.15 submit - Submitted on December 15, 2021.
2022.2.15 rr - Revise and resubmit by February 15, 2022.
2022.4.16 resubmit - Resubmitted on April 16, 2022.
2022.6.21 rr - Revise and resubmit by June 21, 2022.
2022.8.20 resubmit - Resubmitted on August 20, 2022.
2022.12.12 accept - Accepted on December 12, 2022.

There were a total of 8 reviewers, some of whom provided professional and objective evaluations, while others showed obvious biases. The Associate Editor (AE) was responsible and would seek other experts for re-evaluation if there were significant differences in opinions. Making serious revisions based on the comments will greatly improve the quality of the article. Finally, I wish everyone good results.

gdfzck 2022-12-21

March rr
May major
September rr
December 20 awaiting CO-EIC decision
Praying~~

sjdiNg 2022-12-20

Awaiting EIC Decision. It has been over a week. Wishing good luck.

尖尖一 2022-12-19

I have been waiting in this state for nearly half a month.

chu11 2022-12-06

May I ask if the number of pages for the initial submission should be limited to 8 pages?

小夏_0321 2022-12-05

Can you share your entire process in detail?

jack04220041 2022-12-03

Hi, may I ask what was the outcome of your submission to IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics?

ENDIT 2022-12-01

The status of awaiting AE assignment has been going on for half a month, isn't it too long?
How long has everyone been in this state?

TII_qq_Group主 2022-11-28

Prepare a double column, if you have any questions, click on my profile picture for detailed consultation.

Wannap 2022-11-28

Is the single-column file problem solved, OP? I am also facing the same confusion.

wefsdf 2022-11-18

The paper underwent three revisions with a total of three reviewers, requiring major revisions. After resubmitting the paper, it took 20 days for the status to change from "awaiting ae recommendation" to "awaiting review scores." Has anyone else encountered such a situation? I suspect it might be due to conflicting opinions among the reviewers, resulting in the addition of a new reviewer.

LX917 2022-11-15

Posted on May 8th.
Notice of major revision on August 19th, with two minor revisions and one rejection for resubmission. The submission was made to a journal that is an extension of CCF B. There were no major issues with the minor revisions, and the main concern for the rejection and resubmission was to clearly differentiate between the content that had been previously published in conference papers and the new content.
Resubmitted on September 19th, with an emphasis on distinguishing the comparison between the conference work and the submitted manuscript.
Accepted on November 8th.
The above is the sharing of submission information. There is also a question that needs consultation. In the final submission stage, does TII require a single-column source file? Is there a template available, or should one prepare it themselves? Is this document necessary, or can the submission be made with a double-column source file? The specific requirements for this document are as follows: Format the complete document (including text, figures, and tables) with single-column double-space using a 12-point font size. Save the document as TXT_TII-1x-xxxx.doc (if it is a Word file) or TXT_TII-1x-xxxx.tex (if it is a LaTeX project).

TII_qq_Group主 2022-11-15

Before being accepted, the author's information must not be revealed, for more details click on my profile to contact.

robot-NaN 2022-11-09

Requirement: Both the thesis and the response letter should not contain any information.

哈利路亚biubiubiu 2022-11-09

Original text: 楼主,问下,rr回来后,返回稿件时,作者信息啥的不用再隐了吧,可以都写上了吧?

Translation: OP, just asking, after rr comes back, when returning the manuscript, there's no need to hide the author's information, right? Can we include all of it?

云笙彡 2022-11-07

2022.10.12 awaiting ae assignment - This means that as of October 12, 2022, the paper is waiting to be assigned to an Associate Editor (AE).

2022.10.27 assigning reviewers - This indicates that on October 27, 2022, the paper is being assigned to reviewers.

2022.11.7 awaiting EIC decision - As of November 7, 2022, the paper is awaiting a decision from the Editor-in-Chief (EIC).

robot-NaN 2022-11-04

2021-10 Special Issue Submission
2022-01 Reject & Resubmit
2022-04 Major Revision
2022-05 Minor Revision
2022-07 Major Revision (Three additional reviewers added)
2022-09 Minor Revision
2022-10 Acceptance

TII_qq_Group主 2022-11-04

Click on my name, and I will share with you the review situation of TII.

Godvey 2022-11-03

Still assigning additional reviewers.

LZW555 2022-11-02

I am too, what now?

审稿人 2022-11-02

50 days, be rejected, don't think about it...

TII_qq_Group主 2022-11-01

Click on my name, I will share the specific situation with you.
My "awaiting ae recommendation" has also been over 30 days.

Clark Mark 2022-10-28

Update
2022/10/08 waiting for reviews (submit revised draft)
2022/10/12 awaiting review scores
2022/10/23 awaiting AE (Associate Editor) recommendation
2022/10/25 awaiting Co-EIC (Co-Editor-in-Chief) decision
2022/10/26 accepted

云笙彡 2022-10-28

2022.10.12 awaiting AE assignment translates to "Waiting for Associate Editor assignment on October 12, 2022."

2022.10.27 assigning reviewers translates to "Assigning reviewers on October 27, 2022."

Miro_ 2022-10-28

Reply to SCI comment expert: Yes, what information do you have?

伴你高飞 2022-10-26

I'm really drunk, is it because the editor-in-chief is intentionally messing with me...

SCI点评专家 2022-10-26

Is Luo Ren your EIC and Lisa your ADM for your manuscript?

Godvey 2022-10-24

It has been two months and it is still in the "Assign Additional Reviewers" stage. This is frustrating.

Miro_ 2022-10-24

rr→major→minor→?
rr→mayor→minor→?

Miro_ 2022-10-24

hh, I have been waiting for 17 months, and it has gone through four rounds of review. After submitting minor revisions, I have to add a reviewer. It has been five months and they are still selecting reviewers. I guess I will finally receive rejection. I wonder what is happening with this journal recently.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started