三柳学渣 2021-11-16

2020.12.6 Submission
2021.2.7 AE allocation
2021.6.17 First review returned, two reviewers, probably major revision and minor revision
Early July 2021 returned
2021.10.4 Accept

找零 2021-09-02

After applying for an extension, the revised draft was submitted on July 13, 2021.
On August 31, 2021, four comments were received in the second review, and AE (Associate Editor) provided an acceptance.

mjfwxr123 2021-08-14

Has it been received now?

Aliex 2021-08-06

2020-09-02: Submitted initial draft.
2021-02-16: Preliminary review comments, major revision (2 major revisions).
2021-04-01: After applying for an extension, submitted revised draft.
2021-06-01: Second review comments, minor revision (2 accepted, one minor revision, added one reviewer).
2021-06-17: Second submission.
2021-06-30: Third review comments, minor revision (all reviewers accepted, editor provided some suggestions).
2021-07-14: Third submission.
2021-07-21: Fourth review comments, minor revision (editor provided suggestions for language adjustments).
2021-08-05: Fourth submission.
2021-08-05: Final acceptance.
Final comments: Although there were some difficulties, the outcome is satisfying. TIP values language expression highly, so make sure to pay attention to language and don't go through as many rounds of minor revisions as I did.

doitlikenever 2021-06-25

This should not waste the author's time. It would have been done if it wasn't for the delay in reviewing. Why reject it with such reasons after dragging it for so long? It's so irresponsible!

GeXianyu 2021-06-18

I had previously submitted an application that was directly rejected. The initial draft was submitted on August 18, 2020, and the initial review lasted until February 6, 2021, a total of 5 months and 19 days.

The one mentioned above lasted from October 6, 2020, to March 24, 2021, a total of 5 months and 18 days. It feels like the duration is not too long but also not short. This is just my personal experience and is for reference only.

liuyuzzz 2021-06-18

How long does the initial review process usually take?

GeXianyu 2021-06-18

2020-10-06: Submit initial draft
2021-03-24: Initial review comments, Major revision (3RQ, 1AQ)
2021-05-04: Submit revised draft
2021-06-07: Second review comments, Accept with mandatory minor revisions (3AQ, 1A)
2021-06-10: Submit revised draft

找零 2021-05-24

2021.1.28 Submit initial draft
2021.4.6 Assign AE
2021.5.20 Receive initial review comments, 4 reviewers, 2 AQ, 2 RQ, AE gave to RQ

冬后晴 2021-04-11

Submitted the first draft on January 20, 2020.
Received initial review comments from three reviewers on June 18, 2020. One recommended major revisions, one recommended minor revisions, and one recommended rejection. The editor suggested major revisions.
Submitted the revised version on July 1, 2020.
Received second review comments from three reviewers on April 8, 2021. One recommended minor revisions, and two recommended rejection. The editor decided to reject.
The reason is that TIP does not accept survey articles and prefers to receive works with novelty.

jisuchaoyue 2021-04-08

2020-8-31 submitted, no AE assigned;
2020-12-1 inquired, then AE assigned, review started;
2021-1-24, major revision;
2021-3-3, submitted;
2021-4-5, accepted

I feel lucky this time, the actual review and revision time was only 4 months.

duters 2021-04-02

TIP is really slow. I submitted two articles. One of them took a year and a half to be rejected, and it has already been a year for the other one without any news.
In addition, for the first article, three reviewers agreed on acceptance, but the editor still rejected it. So, unfortunately, I had to resubmit it.
I hope for better luck in the future.

hmmmm 2021-03-30

Excuse me, have you assigned AE?

hmmmm 2021-03-30

Excuse me, has AE been assigned? I submitted it in early February and haven't been assigned an AE yet.

大坏狐狸 2021-03-23

On March 23, 2121, it was sunny, and the verdict for the first trial has not been announced after 6 months!

kjkjkjkj 2021-03-17

Posted on January 23rd, currently AE: Not Assigned
Very anxious!

Peter_海 2021-03-17

20.8.6投出 - Submitted on August 6, 2020
20.12.6大修 - Major revision on December 6, 2020
21.1.23投出 - Submitted on January 23, 2021
目前In Peer Review - Currently in peer review

Feeling a bit slow, envious of comrades who handle things quickly.

Ray 2021-03-16

Hello, may I ask if your article was first reviewed for preliminary results before being assigned to an AE?

zhezhe95 2021-03-02

Excuse me, has the moderator obtained any results?

roc-ng 2021-02-22

2020-06-11: submitted
2020-10-22: RQ
2020-11-30: resubmitted
2021-01-18: AQ
2021-01-25: resubmitted
2021-02-16: ACCEPT
Total duration of 8 months, the review process was very timely, and the reviewers were also very professional.

嗷嗷 2021-02-03

I submitted the manuscript on July 8, 2020. It's been 7 months already, why haven't I received the first review result yet?

请喊我小可可 2021-01-24

Brother, how does the author add it? Do all the authors need to register for this journal?

doitlikenever 2021-01-13

In recent years, it has changed somewhat and the quality is not as good as in previous years.