努力毕业的风痕 2023-04-13

Okay, thank you, as long as it doesn't affect anything, it's good.

科研汤 2023-04-12

Normal, rejection and resubmission will change.

科研汤 2023-04-12

Did you give him/her a second chance?

casiaa 2023-04-12

One reject, one minor, one major, ae reject.

casiaa 2023-04-12

4.11 拒 (jù) translates to "reject" in English.

努力毕业的风痕 2023-04-12

After rejecting and inviting to resubmit, how come the manuscript number has changed? Is this normal?

SJ 2023-04-10

4个审稿人哈

Translation: 4 reviewers haha

科研汤 2023-04-09

No need, I have won an article, I am not a member.

scikk 2023-04-09

Does this journal require authors to be IEEE members or something similar?

casiaa 2023-04-09

2023.2.26 submitted
2023.3.5 in peer review
2023.4.9 awaiting decision

算哪个小饼干 2023-04-08

Me too, it has been over three months for me now, and I still haven't received the first-instance opinion. I'm inexplicably nervous... sigh.

invincible123 2023-04-07

I made a mistake, actually, rejecting you for the first time is not a big deal...

invincible123 2023-04-07

It is a major repair, just submit it within the limited time.

果果 2023-04-07

In 2022, I made a mistake.

果果 2023-04-07

Submitted on October 8, 2021, and received the first-instance result on November 3. It took more than 4 months for major revisions, during which time was delayed due to the epidemic and the Chinese New Year.

invincible123 2023-04-07

How long did it take from the first peer review to the result being announced?

果果 2023-04-07

I submitted it on March 31st.

果果 2023-04-07

The first review encountered 5 reviewers who provided 26 comments, and the editor gave a rejection. According to the decision, if the first submission of your paper is rejected, you are allowed to submit a revised version of the manuscript with a point-by-point response to the reviewers. If the second submission is rejected, a third submission will not be accepted, and it will be immediately rejected.

After completing the point-by-point response to the reviewers, the paper has been resubmitted and is currently in the peer review process. I would like to ask the experts here, would this resubmission be considered a major revision, and will I receive another major revision?

科研汤 2023-04-06

I also became a peer review yesterday.

cutelad 2023-04-05

Just took a glance and finally became a peer reviewer. Maybe the email had an effect.

科研汤 2023-04-05

April 5, 2023. Currently still in the submitted status, it feels slow.

cutelad 2023-04-05

I also submitted on March 27th, and until today it is still submitted. I emailed the editor but haven't received any response...

科研汤 2023-03-30

The second article has been submitted on March 27, 2023.

Allen 2023-03-29

How many reviewers are there? It has been almost 3 months and the results of the first round have not been released yet.

jason2021 2023-03-29

Major was rejected, indicating that the review process has indeed become more stringent.

算哪个小饼干 2023-03-24

Then I think I might not have a chance either...

ZKL123 2023-03-23

Two months later, the minor revisions are still in peer review. I'm afraid they might be rejected as well.

ACC1 2023-03-23

Rejected. After nearly 10 months, undergoing a major revision in the first review, and being rejected in the second review (1 acceptance with concerns about the experiment). The resubmission was rejected (1 acceptance with the opinion that it lacks innovation).

算哪个小饼干 2023-03-22

Brother, what is your opinion?

SJ 2023-03-21

2022.12.26 submitted
2023.01.02 in peer review
2023.01.27 major
2023.03.01 submitted and in peer review
2023.03.21 awaiting recommendation
2023.03.21 awaiting decision
2023.03.21 accepted
Less than 3 months