baoyang 2023-06-25

Congratulations, good luck!

Bin 2023-06-25

It can be determined from the reviewers' responses that it is not a special issue.
The reason given by the AE is that there is insufficient innovation.

yang1111 2023-06-25

Did the original poster submit for a special issue? Without knowing the specific outcome, it seems like they are unaware of the details regarding major or minor revisions.

invincible123 2023-06-25

This situation is probably because AE or the editor-in-chief did not approve of the paper...

RyanLaw 2023-06-25

2 minor repairs and 1 major repair have been rejected, which is quite discouraging.

green1 2023-06-25

How to determine whether the reviewer's comments require major or minor revisions, as my individual reviewer did not clearly state the final decision.

菜鸟啊 2023-06-25

Can't I vote again now?

RICARD 2023-06-24

I'm afraid of accidents, but I'll still borrow your good wishes.

RyanLaw 2023-06-24

2023.06.24 Awaiting Decision

xhy 2023-06-23

The comments from the junior reviewer are all good, and it seems like you shouldn't have any major issues. They probably won't add additional reviewers without restarting the peer review process, so just wait a little longer. It is likely that there is a large volume of manuscripts.

LSKS 2023-06-23

Two submissions, the first one was rejected with encouragement to resubmit. After resubmission, it was rejected again after a month and a half. The Associate Editor (AE) and three reviewers provided major revisions, but ultimately the Editor-in-Chief still rejected it.

RICARD 2023-06-22

The first review consisted of four revisions, two minor and two major. Ultimately, it was rejected. After resubmission, one reviewer requested minor revisions, and the other reviewers had no further comments. Indeed, the revisions suggested by others were completed quickly, usually within a month. It seems that there has been an increase in submissions recently, causing some backlog.

xhy 2023-06-22

Originally, were there 4 reviewers? I have already added 2 reviewers for the second review, but other people's minor revisions are done quickly.

RICARD 2023-06-21

In general, when "awaiting recommendation" appears, it means that the reviewer's comments have all been received and it is waiting for the editor's processing. During the editor's processing, it will then change to "awaiting decision."

RICARD 2023-06-21

I hope all my brothers can win!!!

RICARD 2023-06-21

My minor revision mainly involves a reviewer asking for changes to one figure, two tables, and formatting issues, as well as issues with the wording of a paragraph. The other three reviewers had no objections, and I feel that there isn't any major problem. However, it has been over a month since it changed back to "awaiting recommendation" and there has been no progress. I suspect that the reviewer who requested the changes is not satisfied and the editor has sought another reviewer.

xhy 2023-06-21

You are very quick, I just went back to make minor revisions and it has been in peer review for over ten days. I hope for good luck.

RICARD 2023-06-21

I don't know why it changed from "awaiting decision" to "awaiting recommendation", and it has been "awaiting recommendation" for over a month already. It seems that others who applied for the same position were accepted within a month after submitting their applications. It's a bit difficult to handle, hoping for good luck.

RICARD 2023-06-21

2023.05.20 major revision

RyanLaw 2023-06-20

I want to know whether the external review comments of "awaiting recommendation" have been received. Why do some people get stuck at this step for more than 20 days?

RyanLaw 2023-06-20

So, does "awaiting recommendation" mean that the first review comments have already come back and we are waiting for the editor's decision?

invincible123 2023-06-20

It seems that recently rejected submissions cannot be resubmitted. However, previously rejected ones can still be resubmitted.

Bin 2023-06-19

Doesn't it say on the homepage that if there is a rejection, you cannot submit it anymore?

卡卡飞尔洛 2023-06-19

My second draft has already been revised, and the status has changed to "awaiting recommendation" for over 20 days. I have never encountered this situation before. How long should I wait before asking?

cherry_123 2023-06-19

May I ask what is the situation after waiting for two weeks for a recommendation? Mine is also pending. Could it be that the associate editor forgot about it? How long did it take for you to receive the first review?

努力划水毕业 2023-06-19

Until now, there is still no result. It has been over two months. Give me a satisfactory outcome.

Bin 2023-06-19

What is the final result?

努力划水毕业 2023-06-19

The rejection was given in March and it was resubmitted. The one submitted in April should also have received a rejection and resubmission.

ghbj 2023-06-18

Now they won't allow reapplication, right?

ghbj 2023-06-18

Three manuscripts were rejected positively, why can they be resubmitted in April but not now?