算哪个小饼干 2022-05-01

Is the speed so fast? It took just over ten days to hire, may I ask how long the peer review process took?

Allen 2022-04-28

How do you appeal the law? Is it by writing a cover letter? I feel that this review and acceptance process is the fastest I have ever seen.

xiaomujiang 2022-04-28

I appealed at the time and did not receive any encouragement. The reviewer did not mention any lack of innovation.

Allen 2022-04-27

Hello! Congratulations on being hired by TCSVT! May I ask if you were invited to reapply when you rejected the offer initially? Also, did the reviewers mention any issues regarding the lack of innovation in your submission?

xiaomujiang 2022-04-27

2022-03-05 submitted
2022-03-23 reject
2022-04-12 resubmitted
2022-04-26 accept as transactions paper
Three reviewers provided very professional comments, which greatly improved the paper. The main issue with the language and descriptive analysis of the article was significant. Perhaps the editor found it difficult to make the necessary changes, resulting in rejection. However, it has been proven that diligent revisions can lead to acceptance!

Davor HW 2022-04-08

Is your conclusion written separately? I haven't encountered this situation before. The editor's intention may be to move the equations and similar icons to another part of the manuscript.

xiaomujiang 2022-04-07

Hello, when you resubmit, do you include the cover letter and individually respond to the reviewer's comments together? Thank you!

wjp 2022-04-06

Congratulations! I submitted my manuscript and it was returned the next day. The reason given was that the conclusion should flow continuously. Please remove any figures, text, tables, and equations from the conclusion and place them elsewhere in the manuscript or submit them as an appendix in a separate document.

After completing this request, please resubmit your manuscript by going to your author dashboard. Click on the "unsubmitted and manuscripts in draft" link, then click on the "continue" link to resubmit your manuscript.

May I ask if, in addition to the PDF generated by LaTeX, I need to upload any other files? Thank you, thank you.

wjp 2022-04-06

Congratulations, congratulations. My submission was rejected the day after it was submitted, with the reason given as:

--CONCLUSION

The Conclusion should flow continuously, please remove the Figures/Text/Tables/Equations and place them elsewhere in the manuscript, or submit them as an Appendix in a separate document.

Please resubmit your manuscript after you have completed our request, by going to your Author Dashboard and clicking on the Unsubmitted and Manuscripts in Draft link, then click on the Continue link to resubmit your manuscript.

May I ask if, apart from the PDF generated by LaTeX, any other files need to be uploaded? Thank you.

Davor HW 2022-04-04

Forgot to mention, both the Editor-in-Chief and the AE have provided constructive suggestions. In the end, the opinions of the Editor-in-Chief, AE, and 3 reviewers need to be addressed. After a month of careful revisions, it was accepted. Overall, both the editor and reviewers were responsible experts in the field.

Davor HW 2022-04-04

2021-12-22, submitted
2021-12-22, in peer review
2022-02-21, Major Revision
2022-03-21, a revision has been submitted
2022-04-02, Accept as Transactions Paper

Three reviewers provided professional feedback and suggested significant improvements to the article. After addressing their comments and making necessary revisions, the article was accepted for publication.

CN_JLiu666 2022-03-25

Hello, regarding your message of "awaiting decision," may I ask if there is a result now?

lbj23 2022-03-23

Submitted (03-Mar-2021)
Reject and Invite to Resubmit (15-May-2021)
Major Revision (24-Oct-2021)
Minor Revision (17-Dec-2021)
Accept as Transactions Paper (09-Jan-2022)

First round with three reviewers
Second round with five reviewers (seems to be controversial, switching between "Awaiting Decision" and "Awaiting Recommendation" three times, indicating that two additional Associate Editors were added as reviewers, as mentioned by the first two reviewers in the new comments)
Third round with only two reviewers for minor revisions

Overall, the review process is relatively strict, depending on luck. I previously submitted an article that was immediately rejected, probably indicating that they did not want further submissions. Fortunately, this journal has a relatively fast turnaround time, with review results coming back within three months. The normal process includes three reviewers for the first review, but if you're lucky, it may be reduced to two reviewers who recommend acceptance.

lucky pig 2022-03-17

Classmate, I am resubmitting after rejection. The appeal I mentioned is the cover letter I wrote when resubmitting.

爱笑的小飞鱼 2022-03-16

Supplementing the above, as of March 16, 2022, we are still awaiting the lottery draw.

一定要中呀 2022-03-15

If the deputy editor says to invite a resubmission of the draft, then simply resubmit it without appealing. When resubmitting, include a new version of the cover letter and a response to the reviewer's comments.

simonchance 2022-03-05

Hello, I was also rejected today, but the journal allows us to respond to the reviewers' comments and submit again. Is this the same situation for you? May I ask what was the reason for your appeal and how did you go about it? Also, if we are rejected and submit again, will it be the same reviewers as before?

xiaomujiang 2022-03-02

How can you appeal after you reject?

green1 2022-02-27

Hello, may I ask if your submission on 2021-10-12 was rejected? Is this a rejection for resubmission or a rejection, but according to the journal's policy, allows one resubmission?

lucky pig 2022-02-25

2021-7-9 submitted
2021-10-12 Reject
2021-11-10 submitted
2021-12-12 awaiting decision
2021-12-13 Major Revision
2022-1-15 revised version submitted, in peer review
2022-1-28 awaiting decision
2022-1-30 Minor Revision
2022-2-11 revised version submitted, in peer review
2022-2-22 awaiting decision
2022-2-23 Accept as Transactions Paper

I'm really excited. After being rejected and resubmitted, the second paper has finally been accepted after a series of difficult revisions. After the second round of revisions, there were a total of three reviewers in the first review (minor revision, major revision, minor revision), and it became two reviewers in the second review. The quality of the reviews was very high and thorough, and the editorial handling and review process were very fast. I am extremely grateful for the recognition from the editor and reviewers, as their suggestions greatly improved the quality of the manuscript.

爱笑的小飞鱼 2022-02-23

2022-01-12, submitted
2022-01-15, in peer review
2022-02-14, awaiting recommendation
2022-02-17, awaiting decision
2022-02-19, major revision
2022-02-23, revised version submitted, in peer review

conquerboy 2022-02-08

May I ask how many reviewers there are? Did the number of reviewers increase this year?

conquerboy 2022-02-08

May I ask how many reviewers are there?

conquerboy 2022-02-08

May I ask how many reviewers are there for your paper? Thank you.

喜欢吃糖 2022-02-02

I submitted in November, and in January it went from "awaiting recommendation" to "in peer review" again. My heart is so tired. Has anyone else experienced a similar situation? Let's share.
Now it has been accepted, thanks to all my friends for sharing.
It took me a total of six months, which is not too bad. There was one major revision in between, and after the revision, it was directly accepted.

爱笑的小飞鱼 2022-01-15

2022-01-12提交，submitted
2022-01-15进入审稿，in peer review

Translation:
Submitted on 2022-01-12
In peer review since 2022-01-15

yangyang 2022-01-12

Why did my submission go directly from "submit" to "in peer review"?

lambett2 2022-01-08

Excuse me, has the result been announced now?

paisson 2022-01-04

2021.12.8: Submit;
2021.12.31: Awaiting Recommendation;
2022.1.4: Awaiting Decision.

paisson 2022-01-04

Currently, it is "awaiting decision," and I am so nervous. I can't concentrate on anything.