Verified Reviews - IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Cruise_sun 2023-02-06

2023.2.6 Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision

Translation: February 6, 2023 - Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision

shaoyx 2023-02-05

Thank you, it's embarrassing, I didn't highlight my revised draft, I just made some annotations.

I noticed in the resubmission file instructions that there was a sentence, so I didn't dare to highlight. Your manuscript cannot include colored or highlighted text. Annotated revisions can be included as a summary of changes.

人在皮天在看 2023-02-05

Both the revised draft and the response should be marked with highlights. In the response, it is necessary to specify the page and line numbers where the modifications were made in the original text. The final proof should be submitted without any highlighted sections.

shaoyx 2023-02-04

How do I indicate the modified content when requesting a revision? I saw on the website that it is not allowed to use color or highlight.

清晨看露 2023-02-02

2023.1.18 submit, await admin check list
2023.2.3 under review
2023.2.9 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.3.10 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation
2023.3.11 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.3.23 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation
2023.3.24 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.4.16 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation
2023.4.17 Awaiting Reviewer Scores; Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision
2023.4.28 reject

Translation:
2023.1.18 - Submitted, awaiting administrative check list
2023.2.3 - Under review
2023.2.9 - Awaiting reviewer scores
2023.3.10 - Awaiting associate editor recommendation
2023.3.11 - Awaiting reviewer scores
2023.3.23 - Awaiting associate editor recommendation
2023.3.24 - Awaiting reviewer scores
2023.4.16 - Awaiting associate editor recommendation
2023.4.17 - Awaiting reviewer scores; Awaiting reviewing editor decision
2023.4.28 - Rejected

人在皮天在看 2023-01-27

It took a year, went through four rounds of revisions, and finally got accepted. I am grateful for the careful guidance of my supervisor. Here is my timeline:

2022.1.12 Submitted
2022.3.20 Revise and Resubmit (21 comments from three reviewers, three comments from the editor-in-chief, three comments from the associate editor)
2022.8.6 a resubmission has been submitted
2022.9.30 Revise and Resubmit (one comment from the editor-in-chief, several minor comments from the associate editor)
2022.11.5 a resubmission has been submitted
2022.12.2 Conditionally Accept (one comment from the editor-in-chief, four minor comments from the associate editor)
2022.12.6 a revision has been submitted
2022.12.28 Conditionally Accept (one comment from the editor-in-chief)
2023.1.2 a revision has been submitted
2023.1.25 Accept

The journal values practical examples or experiments, application scenarios of methods, and details of parameter settings.

Cruise_sun 2023-01-26

2022.11.15 Submit - This means that a submission is required on November 15th, 2022.

2023.1.16 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation - This indicates that a decision is pending and the submission is currently waiting for a recommendation from the Associate Editor. The deadline for the recommendation is January 16th, 2023.

清华吴彦祖 2022-12-28

22-12-21 submit
22-12-22 Awaiting Admin Checklist
23-1-14 Under Review
23-1-21 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
23-2-25 Awaiting AE Recommendation
23-3-27 Revise and Resubmit
23-4-16 resubmit
23-4-19 Under Review
23-5-1 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
23-5-9 Awaiting AE Recommendation
23-5-14 Under Review, add reviewer
23-5-31 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
23-6-19 Awaiting AE Recommendation
23-7-5 Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision
23-7-19 Conditionally Accept
23-7-27 resubmit
23-7-31 Under Review

johnson Lin 2022-12-14

The translation of "2022.12.9 reject" into English is "2022 December 9th rejection".

chikit 2022-12-10

The text "12.06 under view" does not have a clear meaning in English. It could be a phrase or a sentence fragment without proper context. Can you provide more information or clarify the intended meaning?

johnson Lin 2022-12-07

2022.12.7 Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision

Translation: We are waiting for a decision from the reviewing editor on December 7, 2022.

sdx2199 2022-12-06

Hi, may I ask if you have any updates here?

chikit 2022-12-05

2022.11.20 Submission
2022.12.4 Awaiting Associate Editor Assignment

凛若弦 2022-12-03

This journal is too much. They haven't reviewed it for 14 days. Can I withdraw my submission?

爱梳头的胖子 2022-12-01

The first review had a conditional acceptance, but the second review took more than 4 months, too slow.

年纪大了 2022-11-30

It has been 10 days since awaiting admin checklist, I couldn't resist and have already urged for the submission, hoping it can be smoothly reviewed.

年纪大了 2022-11-28

I also submitted on November 20th, and I am still awaiting admin checklist. It has been a week.

清晨看露 2022-11-24

Looking for a new reviewer, and this reviewer is changing. You will have a different reviewer every time you resubmit. Good luck to you.

清晨看露 2022-11-24

So slow, waited for a week.

小牛哥 2022-11-24

After awaiting the associate editor recommendation, it becomes "awaiting reviewer scores." What is the situation?

凛若弦 2022-11-24

2022.11.20 Submitting Awaiting Admin Checklist

johnson Lin 2022-11-23

2022.11.23 in attesa della raccomandazione dell'editor associato.

johnson Lin 2022-11-23

2022.11.23 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation

This text is already in English.

橙1 2022-11-09

This is a voluntary donation, not mandatory. You can choose not to.

拉普拉斯啦 2022-10-28

Hello, I would like to ask you if the revised draft of TASE needs to have the modified content marked in color.

拉普拉斯啦 2022-10-28

Hello, may I ask if the revised draft of TASE needs to have the modified content marked with colors?

johnson Lin 2022-10-23

2022.10.22 Awaiting Reviewer Scores

This phrase translates to English as: "2022.10.22 Awaiting Reviewer Scores."

johnson Lin 2022-10-16

2022.10.5投出 - Submitted on October 5th, 2022.
2022.10.16 under review - Under review since October 16th, 2022.

学界啄木鸟 2022-10-08

May I ask if this journal charges for the first 12 pages as well?

学界啄木鸟 2022-10-08

Help the Great God, submitting a paper has a requirement: "If accepted, do you agree to pay $175 per page for each page over the first 12 pages for Regular papers?" Does this mean that there is a charge for each page after page 12, or is it $175 for each page, including the first 12 pages? This is also a mandatory option.

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript

Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.

Search