西楼听雨客 2023-05-18

Submission process:
02-Apr-2023 Under Review
There is still no movement at present, and we do not know the outcome yet.

永恒的谜团 2023-05-17

ADM: Chauhan, Shivani
16-May-2023: CREATED
17-May-2023: SUBMITTED
17-May-2023: Under Review
14-Jul-2023: Awaiting Decision
14-Jul-2023: Minor Revision
19-Jul-2023: A revision has been submitted
19-Jul-2023: Awaiting Decision
19-Jul-2023: Under Review
27-Jul-2023: Awaiting Decision
27-Jul-2023: Accept

After months of record-keeping, the first paper has been finalized, and I am happy.

想快点跑路 2023-05-17

The whole OA is not as fast as him, it's outrageous.

lj0408 2023-05-17

17-Oct-2022 under review
23-Jan-2023 reject (revise and resubmit)
22-Mar-2023 under review
The second review has not been finalized until now. Should we consider reminding them?

鲸鱼打饱嗝儿 2023-05-17

Record it 5.15 submission, Under Review ADM: Chauhan Shivani

sky000 2023-05-17

I submitted it on March 17th, and there is still no progress now. It's worrying.

pessist 2023-05-16

Update,
5.10 submitted & Awaiting Decision
5.11 Under Review
5.12 Awaiting Decision
5.16 Accepted for Final Submission

哗啦啦123 2023-05-16

2023-5-11, Under Review
2023-6-30, Reject, Revise and Resubmit
2023-7-17, Resubmit
2023-8-8, Accept, Publish Unalerted

Translation:
2023-5-11, Under Review
2023-6-30, Reject, Revise and Resubmit
2023-7-17, Resubmit
2023-8-8, Accept, Publish Unalerted

SDXSACB 2023-05-16

The text "May-15 2023 accepted!" is already in English.

simon 2023-05-15

2023/5/10 under review
Waiting for the process to be completed.

mengzq 2023-05-15

Okay, thank you.

lionllla 2023-05-15

I don't know. I have also seen someone submit a minor repair and it took a month to get the result. I can only wait.

mengzq 2023-05-15

Why is my first day ad, second day ur, currently 10 days ur, I feel a bit slow.

百里凌涵 2023-05-15

No, you need to check it in your own mailbox, which is the email address you provided in the submission system.

百里凌涵 2023-05-15

25-Oct-2022 Under Review
07-Feb-2023 Reject (revise and resubmit)
01-Mar-2023 Under Review
Four reviewers, one rejection, one minor revision, two major revisions, hoping for acceptance!

-------------Separator-------------

01-Mar-2023 Under Review
19-Apr-2023 Reject (revise and resubmit) (19-Apr-2023)
23-Apr-2023 Under Review
Actually, there was only one reviewer for the minor revision, who asked some grammar and punctuation questions.
Hoping for acceptance!

-------------Separator-------------

15-May-2023 Awaiting Decision
Passed this afternoon.
Very happy, the six-month wait was worth it!
Wishing everyone good luck!
PS: It seems like the review time is usually half the time of the previous review, but this is just for reference. The first review is generally slow, ranging from one and a half months to almost four months. It is recommended to submit on Tuesdays or Wednesdays, it's a superstition (●'◡'●).

希望大家都中 2023-05-15

Can I see the editor's reply in the email correspondence on the submission system after sending a reminder for the manuscript? Thank you for your responses and I wish everyone success!

lionllla 2023-05-15

I am also a first review minor repair, returning the repair submission at the same time AD, UR on the second day, AD on the third day.

ljyw17 2023-05-15

I'm not a big shot, just added a bio in the end.

mengzq 2023-05-15

How long does it usually take for the second review process after minor revisions are made to the first review result?

macrosse 2023-05-14

There shouldn't be any problem with this speed.

laokaixinle98 2023-05-14

Posted on April 20, 2023.
Received feedback on May 10, 2023. Two reviewers, one major revision, one minor revision. The editor gave a reject and resubmit decision.

The speed is really super fast, receiving feedback in just three weeks, which far exceeds expectations. Originally expected to wait for three months.

lionllla 2023-05-13

Thank you for the host's explanation. It has been under review for two days and now it is awaiting a decision. I hope for a good outcome.

macrosse 2023-05-13

Changing it to "under review" should mean that it has been submitted for review. Maybe it still needs to be edited, let's have a look.

lionllla 2023-05-12

Hello, may I ask if "小修提交就是awaiting decision，一天后变成under review" means that it has been sent for external review? Thank you.

macrosse 2023-05-12

I feel that in this situation, it would be better to change the reviewer. You can send an email inquiry. The editor is good.

macrosse 2023-05-12

I feel it's time to change the reviewer. You can send an email to inquire about the situation.

茗泽92 2023-05-12

Reject (revise and resubmit), 二轮 Awaiting Decision需要等多久

Translation: Reject (revise and resubmit), 二轮 Awaiting Decision, how long does it take to wait?

追风er 2023-05-11

Congratulations, OP! I submitted an article on December 7th last year, which took two months. On February 15th this year, I received the reviewer's comments (reject and resubmit). It was rejected initially but with the opportunity for major revisions, the editor gave me a chance to make changes. I resubmitted on March 6th, but it is still under review until now. It feels a bit slow. Is there a good chance for acceptance in this case? Is it appropriate to follow up on the progress?

macrosse 2023-05-11

It is an impression of a very good journal.
2022-12-06 submit
2023-01-15 reject (revise and resubmit)
2023-01-27 resubmit
2023-03-27 reject (revise and resubmit) Here it becomes more complicated. The comments from the first review were not difficult to resolve, but after a major revision, one reviewer resigned. As a result, additional reviewers were added, leading to a review period of two months.
2023-04-03 resubmit
2023-05-03 minor revision (1 publish unaltered, 1 publish in minors) Acceptance with mandatory corrections mentioned in the email.
2023-05-10 resubmit at 3 PM, accepted the same evening.
Thanks to the anonymous reviewers and editor Chauhan Shivani.

Another sample: After one month of submission, it was rejected with the reason of not fitting the scope of the journal.

lionllla 2023-05-10

Hello, may I ask if Xiaoxiu will send the manuscript again for review?