会思考的苇草 2021-10-27

Has your status changed? Mine has always been "ADM under review" too. What's the situation? Will it always be like this?

yanyang 2021-10-22

May I ask, did it take you one month for the initial review? When did you submit the manuscript?

Windy 2021-10-21

Which floor's minor repair was rejected? This kind of situation generally should not occur, right?

cluo 2021-10-21

I have seen this journal. After minor revisions, it was still rejected.

Windy 2021-10-20

The review process is quite fast. After submitting minor revisions, the status changes to "awaiting decision," but a day later, it changes to "under review" again. Does this mean it has been sent for external review? I see that many people have their papers accepted within a day or two after making minor revisions, so it seems like the editors themselves make the decision.

Windy 2021-10-20

After submitting the minor revision, the status directly changes to "awaiting decision," and after a day, it changes to "under review." Did yours also change to "under review"? Does it mean it is being externally reviewed again?

cluo 2021-10-20

Now, there are usually several reviewers.

Geniusheng 2021-10-20

I submitted four manuscripts at different times, and the editor was still very diligent and responsible.

1) 29-Apr-2019 -> Minor Revision (27-May-2019), 15-Jun-2019 -> Accept (11-Jul-2019)
2) 26-Jun-2020 -> Reject (revise and resubmit) (25-Jul-2020), 20-Aug-2020 -> Minor Revision (04-Oct-2020), 22-Oct-2020 -> Accept (24-Oct-2020)
3) 24-Apr-2018 -> Reject (revise and resubmit) (02-Jun-2018), 30-Jul-2018 -> Accept (08-Sep-2018)
4) 11-Sep-2019 -> Reject (revise and resubmit) (22-Dec-2019), 19-Feb-2020 -> Accept (14-Mar-2020)

cluo 2021-10-20

I suppose the reviewer did not reply.

lsd123456780 2021-10-19

Hello, I applied on the same day as you and my application has been under review by ADM until now. Will the status remain the same until it changes to "awaiting decision"?

时间以南慕城北 2021-10-19

August 11th, Submit, Under review
August 29th, Awaiting Decision
August 30th, Under review
September 2nd, Awaiting Decision
September 3rd, reject (revision and resubmit)
September 21st, Resubmit, Under review
October 9th, Awaiting Decision
October 9th, Minor revision
October 19th, Submit, Awaiting Decision
October 19th, Accept

tyj95 2021-10-18

6.9 Submission
7.10 Initial review feedback (rejection and resubmission)
9.9 Resubmission
10.16 Accept
Very prompt, each step was completed without delay. Just follow the reviewer's comments and there won't be any issues.

pegn 2021-10-17

Sometimes luck plays a role in a cycle.

s6hao666 2021-10-16

The second paper on sensors took much longer than the first one. It required two major revisions and one minor revision. It felt like the editor didn't even show the last minor revision to the reviewers before accepting it.

Submission Date: 23-Mar-2021
Rejection (with a request for revision and resubmission): 20-Jul-2021
Resubmission Date: 05-Aug-2021
Rejection (with a request for revision and resubmission): 01-Sep-2021
Resubmission Date: 02-Sep-2021
Minor Revision: 29-Sep-2021
Resubmission Date: 01-Oct-2021
Acceptance: 08-Oct-2021

It took half a year, and it wasn't easy at all. The additional workload could have been used to write another paper, haha.

破晓 2021-10-04

Under review (05-Apr-2021) - The manuscript is currently being evaluated.

Reject (revise and resubmit) (24-May-2021) - The manuscript has been rejected but may be revised and resubmitted.

Minor Revision (30-Aug-2021) - The manuscript requires minor revisions.

Accept (02-Sep-2021) - The manuscript has been accepted.

QQstone 2021-09-27

It has been over three months, no response...

yanyang 2021-09-26

When did you submit your contribution? Has there been any response now?

资深柚子 2021-09-24

The status will always be "under review", and if there is no change for a long time and no rejection, it should mean that it has been submitted for review.

QQstone 2021-09-23

The translation of the given text is: "My status has been showing as ADM, undereview. Does it mean that an editor has not been assigned yet?"

Victor 2021-09-22

Does the current journal require all authors' email addresses to be institutional email addresses?

资深柚子 2021-09-17

I have published two articles, both within about a month. The editorial handling was very fast, but the reviewers were very professional and raised critical questions. The journal overall seems to focus more on the potential practical value of the research, while also requiring a solid foundation of basic principles and reasonable explanations.

It's not easy to find a suitable journal, but it is necessary to choose one that aligns with the nature of the work. Otherwise, it would be a waste of one's own time.

Cethy 2021-09-16

I would like to ask if it is possible to recommend a reviewer for my submission?

govenda 2021-09-12

2021.4.26: Submit initial draft
2021.5.28: First external review result (rejected, resubmit)
2021.7.3: Resubmit
2021.8.3: Minor revisions
2021.8.6: Submit revised draft
2021.8.14: Accepted

QQstone 2021-09-09

I have been waiting for more than 2 months for the review, but there has been no progress. I thought this journal would be quicker, but it feels like I am being kept hanging on. o(╥﹏╥)o

涵哥 2021-09-09

It has been two months since the repair, and there is still no response. I really feel upset.

xwei 2021-09-01

06-07-2021 Under Review
23-08-2021 Reminder (Because it has been showing "under review" since the online submission, I am sending an email to ask about the situation.)
25-08-2021 Received editor's reply, waiting for the reviewer's comments
26-08-2021 Awaiting Decision (If I wait patiently for two more days, I won't have to disturb the editor by sending another email.)
28-08-2021 Accept, Subject to Mandatory Corrections (There are two incorrect words and a grammar error in one sentence.)
29-08-2021 Submitted revised manuscript and replied
31-08-2021 Accepted
Overall, this was a very pleasant submission experience.

Levi820 2021-08-30

19-Jul-2021 submit;
7-Aug-2021 awaiting decisions;
21-Aug-2021 minor revision;
26-Aug-2021 submit;
29-Aug-2021 accept;

4 reviewers. The review process was very fast, concluding Under Review in 20 days, but then it took another half a month for Awaiting Decision, which confused me a bit.

景仰 2021-08-26

03.12 First submission
03.18 Under review
04.23 Awaiting decision
04.24 Rejection, can resubmit

6.23 Submission
6.24 Under review
8.10 Minor revisions

8.18 Resubmitted, accepted the same day.

后撤不走步 2021-08-25

I remember it was under review all along until it finally became awaiting decision.

加油啊 2021-08-25

Hello, may I ask if the submission will always be "under review" after it is submitted? Or will it change during the review process?