ohuo 2021-11-22

Submission: 2021-08-18
Major revision: 2021-09-22
Revised submission: 2021-10-20
Acceptance: 2021-11-04

TerryZ 2021-11-18

Submission: 29.04.2021
Major Revision: 28.07.2021
Revised Manuscript Returned: 16.08.2021
Accepted: 05.11.2021

The reviewer is very professional and provides constructive feedback, but the speed is a bit slow.

Kelly250230225 2021-11-17

How long does it take for you to return after the first trial?

WanwanY 2021-11-05

May I ask how long it took you for the initial review?

WanwanY 2021-11-05

May I ask how long ago you were born?

WanwanY 2021-11-05

The result is unknown after being submitted, hoping everything goes smoothly.

一个跻身科研大浪的小白 2021-11-01

All three reviewers were very strict, and their questions were very constructive. Surprisingly, the paper was accepted for publication one month after major revisions were made.

皮皮怪小b 2021-10-22

The speed is quite slow, from submission to acceptance, it took 7 months, and it's about 6 months for other classmates in the laboratory as well.

geminipp 2021-10-18

I am doing ground penetrating radar work, and it has been 3 months already...

科研小白 2021-10-14

The first review took a little over a month, and it required major revisions. There were two reviewers. After the revisions were made, it took another two months to get accepted.

学术小奋青 2021-10-07

Mine is the same. I started investing from July 30th, and I still haven't received any news.

be positive！ 2021-10-07

Mine too, it has been two months, always in this state.

想发sci的小菜鸡 2021-09-29

Mine is like this.

geminipp 2021-09-28

I have not received any news after submitting my work for two months. It has been constantly undergoing review, and I have not received any response from the journal when I contacted them. Are there any fellow students in the same situation?

ZRJZRJ 2021-09-26

I have been waiting for 4 months already ???, now I don't know whether to continue waiting or withdraw the submission.

魔与竭 2021-09-14

Post for a month and a half with no response, isn't promotion supposed to be reviewed within 28 days?

sapphire999 2021-08-22

Hello, may I ask about the current situation of your thesis? I am in a similar situation, having returned after minor revisions, and it has been a month now with no news.

Jamesxin 2021-08-04

In total, it takes four months from beginning to end. The initial review takes two months, followed by two weeks for minor adjustments and two weeks for notification of acceptance.

老王 2021-07-27

My paper was accepted in October 2020, published online at the end of October, and appeared in the journal in January of this year. However, it has not been indexed by SCI until now. Does anyone know why? In 2021, this journal published over 500 papers, out of which more than 400 were indexed.

简白 2021-07-19

Is the editor not replying? I also want to remind them.

ZRJZRJ 2021-07-16

I wrote a letter to the editor, but he didn't reply to me.

简白 2021-07-16

Same, so slow. Have you asked the editor?

ZRJZRJ 2021-07-15

2021-04-02 Submission
2021-04-22 Rejected but encouraged to resubmit (although the submission system status shows reject)
2021-05-22 Resubmitted after serious revisions based on the comments of two reviewers (assigned a new manuscript number)
2021-07-15 Status is still undergoing review
It has been almost two months waiting this time, and there is no news at all. I'm getting anxious waiting.
I hope to receive the review comments soon, as my graduation depends on this article.

简白 2021-07-08

So slow, what's going on? Still no news.

xixi同学 2021-06-10

Original text: 楼主，请问undergoing review多久呀？

Translation: Original poster, may I ask how long does undergoing review take?

xixi同学 2021-06-10

Why am I undergoing review for so long... Three months have passed.

卡文迪许 2021-06-08

Encountered a terrible reviewer. One reviewer suggested major revisions in the first round, and after submission, more major revisions were required. Another reviewer's comments were very pretentious, giving the impression that he is the most knowledgeable person in the industry. His attitude was extremely poor, and judging from the time taken for modifications, it was clear that he didn't actually spend much time reviewing the paper. He only submitted his comments right before the deadline. In the first round, major revisions were requested, followed by major revisions in the second round. In the third round, the paper was outright rejected. I addressed the issues raised by the first and second reviewers, and found many mistakes in the comments of the second reviewer. It was complete pretentiousness. Giving major revisions in the first and second rounds and then claiming lack of innovation in the third round - does this person even have any sense? The experience of submitting this paper was extremely poor. This kind of reviewer should be removed immediately.

pysq 2021-06-08

2021-01-20 Submission: Submitted the manuscript before going home for the Lunar New Year and anxiously waited for the results.
2021-03-23 Major Revision: The reviewer's comments were very pertinent and helpful; they provided comments and suggestions from different perspectives.
2021-04-19 Revised: Although there weren't many comments, I carefully analyzed and made revisions to each one, and submitted the revised version the day before the deadline.
2021-05-27 Minor Revision: I was confident that it would be accepted directly, but as the waiting time grew longer, I became more anxious. Fortunately, there were very few suggestions for minor revisions, and they were mostly regarding details.
2021-06-04 Revised: I took the comments seriously and shared the entire manuscript with my colleagues and classmates for feedback before submitting it.
2021-06-04 Accepted: It was accepted on the same day, the speed was so fast that I couldn't believe it.

The whole process took about 4 months, including one month and one week for major and minor revisions. The journal left a very good impression on me, from the editor-in-chief, associate editors, to the reviewers, all were responsible and friendly. I hope it continues to improve!

简白 2021-05-21

How long does it take for you to undergo review?

简白 2021-05-21

How long does the review process generally take? Do any experienced classmates have any insights to share?