chengyufeng 2023-06-25

23.4.3 submission, up to now ur

lin jh 2023-06-25

How do I urge for a submission? Is there a template that I can refer to? Also, should I send the reminder email to the email address where the editorial comments were previously received?

lin jh 2023-06-25

May I ask how to push for a manuscript submission? Are there any templates available for reference? Also, should we send the reminders to the email address that is used to send the review comments each time?

kli 2023-06-21

Record the submission on 2022.10.24.
Received feedback on 2023.03.23.
One of the reviewers had only two or three questions, while the other had no major concerns and only requested an expansion of the discussion (not sure why such a small number of questions caused a delay of 5 months).
Revised on 2023.03.28.
Sent a reminder email to the ADM for the manuscript on 2023.06.15.
The article was accepted on 2023.06.16, with only one reviewer responding with no concerns.

Overall, everything went smoothly, except for the unexplained delay by the editorial department. After submission, the status remained as UR, regardless of capitalization, with no other updates, causing great anxiety.

f4x2 2023-06-15

Record the submission process, hoping for a good result.
March 4th, 2023 submission.
June 7th, 2023 major revision, requiring feedback within 21 days, two reviewers.
June 15th, 2023 revised.

Erin_Cloud 2023-06-13

On June 10th, I also submitted and it is currently undergoing review.

Lethub140 2023-06-12

6.12 Undergoing review.

Lethub140 2023-06-11

I would like to ask everyone how much is the layout fee for this journal.

manan1262 2023-06-06

5.12 provided modifications, 5.24 revised, currently there is no feedback yet.

卓木 2023-06-03

3D Point Cloud Related
Submission in December 2022
Rejection and resubmission given in March 2023
Submission in April 2023
Accepted in June 2023

呱呱呱 2023-05-30

Provide everyone with a reference time:

February 19, 2023 Submission
April 28, 2023 Major revision
May 7, 2023 Revised
May 23, 2023 Accepted

梦幻大野狼 2023-05-30

The first trial takes about two months.

铭泽 2023-05-29

May I ask when did you submit it? How long does it take for the first review to come back? It has been a month and a half for me already, is it still under review?

梦幻大野狼 2023-05-28

2023/5/27 accept

lymzbjdx 2023-05-21

May I ask whether this journal is considered major or minor? My suggestion is to return it for revision within 21 days.

wolfdarling 2023-05-14

The research group submitted the fifth article to this journal. The third article was accepted, while two were rejected. One was rejected after major revisions, and the other was rejected two months after review. It is obvious that the rejection rate has increased this year, and the number of reviewers has also changed from two to three. Last year, there were only two reviewers. The progress of the accepted third article is as follows:

2023.01.15 - Submitted
2023.03.15 - Major revisions
2023.03.31 - Revised
2023.04.14 - Rejected and resubmitted
2023.05.02 - Resubmitted
2023.05.10 - Accepted

The speed is acceptable, but the reviewers' comments were difficult to address. The final rejection and resubmission were due to one specific issue, which required an 8-page response. I do not plan to submit to this journal in the future. It's not the journal's fault, as five pages are too short and some issues cannot be explained clearly, making it easy to be rejected.

kli 2023-05-12

Does it take 5 months to review this journal now? It wasn't like this before, right?

manan1262 2023-05-10

Please improve the submission system and services.

manan1262 2023-05-10

Unable to follow up on the status of the manuscript review, there is no response to the reminders, and it is also impossible to withdraw the submission.

manan1262 2023-05-10

It has been three months since submission and it is still undergoing review.

梦幻大野狼 2023-05-09

2023.05.09 In Ur, too slow.

beehater 2023-05-08

Mine is also exactly 5 months old. I have sent two emails inquiring about the status of the manuscript but have not received any reply...

SunAndy 2023-05-04

This editor and submission system are very unfriendly to readers. Although it shows "undergoing review", it is possible that the editor has been leaving it there without processing it. How could the review process for foreign journals take five months now?

kli 2023-05-02

I am in the first round for a total of 5 months, and now I am in the second round, just one month.

Foster-1314 2023-05-01

My second appeal has been pending for over four months, and I have also sent reminders twice without receiving any response...

SunAndy 2023-04-28

It has been nearly five months since undergoing review. I have sent two reminders but received no response. The system also does not indicate any progress. Has anyone else sent a reminder letter in the meantime?

XDU-小学徒 2023-04-22

2022.11.1 Manuscript submitted
2023.1.30 Require-Revision Due in 21 Days
2023.2.20 Revision submitted
2023.4.19 Accepted

Translated:
2022.11.1 Manuscript submitted
2023.1.30 Revision Required, Due in 21 Days
2023.2.20 Revision submitted
2023.4.19 Accepted

RJM95 2023-04-19

2023.3.20 until now undergoing review.

f4x2 2023-04-10

Just submitted and it's in this state, not sure if it has been reviewed or not.

zkeivn 2023-04-06

Does undergoing review mean it has already been submitted for review?