Verified Reviews - AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST METEOROLOGY
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

录用录用 2022-05-23

Thank you, thank you for your comment, very helpful. Good luck!

录用录用 2022-05-23

May 22, 2022 Submitted to Journal
May 24, 2022 With Editor

Oh, I hope for good luck and I am grateful.

qian binxiang 2022-05-11

Submission (Submit Manuscript): 2021.11.28;
Editorial Review (With Editor): 2021.11.30;
First Review (Under Review): 2021.12.06;
Major Revision: 2022.02.26;
Revision Submitted: 2022.03.20;
Editorial Review (With Editor): 2022.03.21;
Second Review (Under Review): 2022.03.27;
Review Process Completed: 2022.04.25;
Minor Revision: 2022.05.01;
Revision Submitted: 2022.05.02;
Editorial Review (With Editor): 2022.05.04;
Accepted: 2022.05.08.
Formatting: 2022.05.10.

qian binxiang 2022-05-11

I submitted the article at the end of November in 2021. A few days ago, I was lucky to receive an acceptance email from the editor. The content of the article is about creating a chlorophyll-sensitive vegetation index and conducting accuracy verification. It has some innovation and requires a lot of work. The submission process took 5 months and 1 week. I wrote the time points of submission clearly, hoping it will be helpful for everyone.

小池塘 2022-05-08

Posted on April 25, 2022, reviewed on May 7, looking forward to it.

ww-geo 2021-10-26

submit 2021.3.7
accept 2021.10.17
After undergoing two major revisions and one minor revision, it greatly helped to improve the article. I am still very happy to have my first article ranked top in Section 1.

SIFresearcher 2021-10-18

After consulting via email on 2021.10.15, a response was received on 10.17, stating that the reviewers have been found and the manuscript is now in the "under review" status.

SIFresearcher 2021-10-15

2021.9.3 Submitting
2021.9.7 with editor
It has been over a month and it is still with the editor.....

wanglu37 2021-08-25

2021.1.23 Submission
2021.7.23 Acceptance
Three reviewers were sought, one rejected, and two expressed support.
After major and minor revisions, it was finally accepted.
It is the first article in the top-tier category, and I am happy.

Aj2020 2021-08-23

The submission was rejected without being reviewed after more than 20 days. I have been editing it all along, feeling dizzy.

求是学子 2021-08-23

Hello, may I ask what research direction you are studying? Is the acceptance rate of this journal high? What aspects are mainly valued? Thank you.

雪天儿 2021-08-20

投稿时期为去年12月初,投稿后4天获得编号,大约2个月后返回进行大修(两位审稿人都要求大修)。大修完成后,经过1个半月的修改,再次提交。3天后进行外部审稿,2个月后外部审稿返回进行小修。小修完成后,再过半月进行最终接收。该期刊是农林科学领域的顶级期刊,被该领域的专家认可程度较高。然而,新的影响因子低于预期,希望明年的影响因子能够提高。审稿人都非常严谨,文章经过大修后得到了显著的提升。

liuxin007556 2021-08-05

There is no time limit for this, but it's better to do it as soon as possible. Don't take too long, otherwise the editors will forget about your paper.

liuxin007556 2021-08-05

Hahaha, congratulations, congratulations!

Ushuaia 2021-07-27

It will take about one month to submit for review and then we will receive feedback from three experts.

ww-geo 2021-07-18

Hello, how long will it take for you to review and return with a response?

Ushuaia 2021-06-17

Among the teachers in the academy, it is highly regarded to have the first top-tier journal publication during the doctoral period, which is something to be very happy about.

BEZJ 2021-05-12

Hello, may I ask which editor you chose at that time?

ww-geo 2021-04-19

Hello, how long does your first round of review take?

ww-geo 2021-03-30

The efficiency is so slow. It has been a month with the editor, but there has been no review or rejection. May I ask how long it usually takes for "with editor" to transition to "under review"?

梅西的小胡子 2021-03-07

May I ask if there is a time limit for resubmission after this journal is rejected but recommended for resubmission?

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started