西歪歪 2022-08-13

Lou Lou, may I ask if you have started the review process now? It has been two weeks and I still don't know whether I should send an email to ask the editor.

hehe2333323 2022-08-11

2022-08-09 moderate revision
2022-08-11 resubmitted (with editor)

hehe2333323 2022-08-05

2022-08-01 Required Reviews Completed

Relyyyyy 2022-08-01

May 23, 2022 submitted to journal
May 23, 2022 with editor
Jun 01, 2022 under review
July 06, 2022 required reviews completed
July 10, 2022 decision in process
July 16, 2022 major revision
August 01, 2022 revisions submitted to journal
August 01, 2022 with editor

Translation:
May 23, 2022 - Submitted to journal
May 23, 2022 - Under review by editor
Jun 01, 2022 - Under review
July 06, 2022 - Required reviews completed
July 10, 2022 - Decision in process
July 16, 2022 - Major revision requested
August 01, 2022 - Revisions submitted to journal
August 01, 2022 - Under review by editor

YongYuan 2022-07-28

It should be agreed that the number of reviewers has reached the minimum requirement. The next change in time should be the feedback of opinions.

椭圆三向箔 2022-07-27

Isn't it the fourth? Biochar, SBB, and international soil and water conservation research are all ahead of it.

hehe2333323 2022-07-21

2022-02-17: Submitted to journal
2022-02-18: With editor
2022-02-20: With editor
2022-02-24: Under review (Invited for review)
2022-02-25: Under review (Reviewer 1 reviewing)
2022-03-05: Under review (Reviewer 2 reviewing)
2022-03-16: Received feedback
2022-05-12: Reminder
2022-05-13: Editor Naoise Nunan messaged, received feedback from Reviewer 1, no feedback received from Reviewer 2 for over two months, plan to invite new reviewers
2022-05-14: Under review (Re-invited)
2022-05-18: Under review (Reviewer 3 reviewing)
2022-06-06: Completed
2022-06-09: Major revision
2022-07-06: Resubmitted
2022-07-07: With editor
2022-07-12: Under review
2022-07-20: Under review (Reviewer reviewing)
It's been tough. I hope everything goes smoothly from here on.

lovevast 2022-07-11

Changed three times with the editor, today it is under review. Does this mean it is being submitted for review or that the review has been accepted?

lovevast 2022-07-11

Changed three times with the editor, it is under review today. Will the review time still change according to the reviewer's agreement?

hehe2333323 2022-07-07

2022-02-17 submit to journal
2022-02-18 with editor
2022-02-20 with editor
2022-02-24 under review (inviting reviewers)
2022-02-25 under review (reviewer 1 agrees to review)
2022-03-05 under review (reviewer 2 agrees to review)
2022-03-16 prompted to return reviewer comments
2022-05-12 reminder
2022-05-13 Editor Naoise Nunan receives comments from reviewer 1, no feedback received from reviewer 2 for over two months, plan to invite new reviewers
2022-05-14 under review (inviting new reviewers)
2022-05-18 under review (reviewer 3 agrees to review)
2022-06-06 required reviews completed
2022-06-09 major revision
2022-07-06 resubmitted (with editor)

This is the current progress of my paper for reference.

YongYuan 2022-07-05

可能是审稿人接收或拒绝审稿 translates to "Possibly the reviewer accepts or rejects the review."

llxaky 2022-07-04

The text is already in English.

lovevast 2022-07-04

How many times did you update the time in between?

Xiaoxiaoguo 2022-07-02

Submitted on June 10th, still with editor.

RoisXx 2022-07-02

June 14th, until now with the editor's assistance, it has been a tough journey.

lovevast 2022-07-02

The text translates to: "Submitted on June 22 and have been with the editor all along. The deadline has changed three times. Does it mean it will be rejected? Seeking advice from experts."

lovevast 2022-07-02

Submitted on June 22, I have been in contact with the editor all along. The situation has changed three times. Will it be rejected? Can someone knowledgeable please advise?

llxaky 2022-06-29

I think SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH is not worse than Geoderma, but their impact factors are similar this year.

向南 2022-06-29

The newly released impact factor ranks the soil-related journal as number 2!

YongYuan 2022-06-28

Mar 23, 2022 Submitted to Journal
Mar 29, 2022 With Editor
Apr 03, 2022 Under Review
Apr 19, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Apr 21, 2022 Decision in Process
Apr 22, 2022 Major Revision
Jun 06, 2022 Revisions Submitted to Journal
Jun 06, 2022 With Editor
Jun 07, 2022 With Editor
Jun 10, 2022 With Editor
Jun 21, 2022 Decision in Process
Jun 22, 2022 Accept

hehe2333323 2022-06-08

2022.0606 Required Reviews Completed - This means that all the necessary reviews for the year 2022 have been finished.

hehe2333323 2022-06-03

On May 14th, we re-invited reviewers and are still waiting. Submitting manuscripts is not easy.

hehe2333323 2022-05-15

2022-05-14 under review translates to "2022-05-14 en revisión" in English.

hehe2333323 2022-05-14

The author does not need to click on the link, all can be submitted for review.

意意爸爸 2022-05-14

The first time I submitted to this journal, it's too slow. Do all authors have to click on the email link and agree to be reviewed before it is sent for review? Does anyone know? - From Yi Yi's Dad

hehe2333323 2022-05-13

Editor Naoise Nunan suddenly messaged me saying that they have received a review comment. The other reviewer, however, has not provided any feedback for over two months, despite a personal reminder being sent. If I do not receive a prompt response, I will seek other reviewers. Anxiously waiting.

意意爸爸 2022-05-02

Still editing in hand.

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-29

Apr 29, 2022 Under Review

Translated: Apr 29, 2022 Under Review

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-26

apr 15, 2022 under review - April 15, 2022 is currently being reviewed.
apr 24, 2022 under review - April 24, 2022 is currently being reviewed.

筷子辣椒德芙 2022-04-26

Apr 15, 2022 Under Review
Apr 24, 2022 Under Review

Translation:

Apr 15, 2022 Under Review
Apr 24, 2022 Under Review