walkingsnail 2021-04-01

You can wait a little longer as the status keeps changing, indicating that reviewers are continuously submitting their comments. The editor should still be waiting for reviewers who have not yet returned their feedback.

elyos 2021-04-01

Friend, may I ask what is the current status of your paper?

smilethu 2021-03-29

How long does it take for you to submit for review with the editor?

让人头秃 2021-03-29

There are no opinions of rejection. Most of them are minor revisions, which the editor ultimately provided for modification.

elyos 2021-03-29

Friend, may I trouble you to ask, I saw that you mentioned earlier that your paper has been revised. Could you please let me know if there were any rejections among the review comments? I am quite concerned that if one out of the five reviewers rejects it, then it might be in a difficult situation.

让人头秃 2021-03-29

It was also this editor who sent it to 5 reviewers. I saw others sharing that they even sent it to 6 reviewers.

elyos 2021-03-29

The journal editor is Pietro Bartocci.
Feb 25, 2021 Submitted to journal
Feb 26, 2021 With Editor
Feb 28, 2021 With Editor
Mar 10, 2021 Under Review
Mar 22, 2021 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 23, 2021 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 26, 2021 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 28, 2021 Required Reviews Completed

The date for "Required Reviews Completed" changed four times. Can someone please clarify if there were four or six reviewers who provided their opinions?

guxinlianyu 2021-03-26

Hello, is this a phone call?

alun 2021-03-25

After the last change, I didn't feel like there would be any more reviewers. After a few days, I asked customer service. It seems like I can ask customer service freely, and if it's just about the status, I can ask every few days.

蹲街守幸福 2021-03-24

Hello, how long was the gap between your current state and the time you asked through the live customer service?

alun 2021-03-23

I asked through customer service, and they said that the review has been completed and is now waiting for the editorial decision. After that, the customer service said they urged the editor, and the next day received the revision comments.
Chat URL: https://service.elsevier.com/app/chat/chat_launch/supporthub/publishing/#opennewwindow

蹲街守幸福 2021-03-22

2021.02.07 required reviews completed
2021.02.09 required reviews completed
2021.02.12 required reviews completed

Hello, my editor, Pietro Bartocci, the deadline for the review has been updated three times, and the status has remained unchanged from the 12th to today, the 22nd. Can I request an update on the progress?

alun 2021-03-19

Ask the customer service for assistance, it could be that the review is not yet complete.

wenxin009 2021-03-18

Initial Date Submitted, Oct 30, 2020
Under review, Nov 23, 2020
Revise, Dec 20, 2020
Revision Due, Jan 19, 2021
Extension revision request for 3 weeks
Revision submitted, Feb 9, 2021
Second revised, Feb 19, 2021
Revision submitted, Mar 4, 2021
Under review, Mar 05, 2021
Accepted, Mar 17, 2021
Thank you to Associate Editor Li Baoqing and Editor-in-Chief Huang Zuohua. Both teachers were very rigorous and responsible, and they processed the manuscript quickly. The reviewers were diligent and responsible, and their questions were very professional. We made careful revisions twice and returned the manuscript to the reviewers, and in the end, they agreed to accept it. I hope this experience is helpful to everyone.

蹲街守幸福 2021-03-18

2021.02.07 required reviews completed
2021.02.09 required reviews completed
2021.02.12 required reviews completed

Hello, my editor, Pietro Bartocci. The completion dates for the reviews have been updated three times, and the status has not changed since the 12th. Can I request an update on the review?

蹲街守幸福 2021-03-18

Hello, my editor is also Pietro Bartocci. The completion dates for the required reviews have been updated three times, but the status has not changed from the 12th until today. May I ask if I can urge for the manuscript?

让人头秃 2021-03-17

My repair has already been done. If there is no change in this one month, I feel like I can push for it. Anyway, I have pushed for it.

faSCI 2021-03-15

I am just like you, I also haven't updated my status now.

SCI好难 2021-03-15

The first SCI paper of my life has been accepted. Let me share the journey of this paper.

2020.12.22 - Submission
2020.12.25 - Under review
2021.1.15 - Required reviews completed
2021.1.18 - Revise
2021.2.16 - Revision submission
2021.2.19 - Under review
2021.3.13 - Required reviews completed
2021.3.13 - Accepted

The speed of reviewing the manuscript by Fuel is still acceptable. Thanks to Professor Li Baoqing and Editor-in-Chief Huang Zuohua! Wishing Fuel continued success!

SCI好难 2021-03-13

It is stated that three reviewers have provided their comments. If everything goes well, the email will be received within two to three days.

蹲街守幸福 2021-03-12

What does it mean that the date "Required Reviews Completed" has been updated three times?

让人头秃 2021-03-09

The reminder was sent on March 3rd, and the feedback was received the next day. There were a total of 5 reviewers, but one of them did not submit any review comments.

alun 2021-03-08

Hello, may I ask if there are any results yet?

Mex 2021-02-28

Received at Editorial Office 23 Jun 2020
Article revised 31 Jan 2021
Article accepted for publication 09 Feb 2021

Translated into English:
Received at Editorial Office on June 23, 2020
Article revised on January 31, 2021
Article accepted for publication on February 9, 2021

For reference

Yadoong 2021-02-25

A few days ago, I sent an email in the system asking about it. The reply email said that they are still waiting for another reviewer's decision before making a decision.

Yadoong 2021-02-25

Okay, Tongxun is my mentor, I didn't dare to ask him who was assigned to edit.

让人头秃 2021-02-25

You have been waiting for a longer time than me. You shouldn't be waiting for another reviewer, right? You can remind them now.

让人头秃 2021-02-25

The corresponding author will receive an email informing them which editor has been assigned to their article.

Yadoong 2021-02-25

I submitted it on January 2nd, 2021, and the required reviews were completed on January 29th. Until now, how do you know who the editor is? Will the corresponding author receive an email?

让人头秃 2021-02-23

2021.01.04 submit
2021.01.05 with editor
2021.01.27 under review
2021.02.01 required reviews completed
2021.02.04 required reviews completed
2021.02.07 required reviews completed
The editor is Pietro Bartocci from Italy, and this status has been ongoing for over 20 days, so I don't dare to rush...