linda0621 2021-04-20

Same question, the under review date has changed three times, but the status remains the same. What is the situation?

SHBING 2021-04-18

May I ask how long will it take for you to decide whether to accept or not after receiving it?

wangwz 2021-04-17

May I ask how long it took to receive the manuscript after it was submitted? Thank you.

oolili 2021-04-17

It has been almost 2 months with the editor, and I thought there was no hope. I was ready to write a letter to withdraw the submission, but unexpectedly, it was sent for review today. Oh my goodness, I am pleasantly surprised! Without saying much, I hope for good luck and please let the reviewer be lenient. Also, if you are in a hurry to have the article, please be cautious when submitting it!

帅帅子 2021-04-16

Hello, may I ask if the selection is made during the submission or after acceptance?

萧萧崽崽 2021-04-16

I used to come here often during the submission or review stage to read everyone's comments and received a lot of valuable information. Now I am also sharing my submission information with everyone.
2020.12.23 Submitted to Journal
2020.12.26 With Editor
2020.12.31 Editor Invited
2021.1.3 With Editor
2021.1.7 Under Review
2021.2.3 Required Reviews Completed
2021.2.12 Major Revision
2021.3.1 Revision Submitted to Journal
2021.3.3 Editor Invited
2021.3.3 Under Review
2021.3.8 Required Reviews Completed
2021.3.14 Accept

Leezy 2021-04-14

Is there a result?

wangwz 2021-04-13

Have you finished proofreading your manuscript? It has been 20 days and I still haven't proofread it.

sunnday 2021-04-13

After the submission for review, one month will be given for major revisions. If I want to request an extension to submit revised comments, how should I apply for it?

tumuge13 2021-04-13

Translated text: "Minor revisions took four months, with two reviewers. It was a bit slow, but fortunately it was accepted for publication."

Michael len 2021-04-11

A management science paper in my hand was rejected after being submitted for external review by a Chinese journal. I am now prepared to submit it to an English journal. I found this journal through a selection website. Could you please let me know how this journal is for publishing management science papers?

wangwz 2021-04-07

Hello, how often do you send me the proofreading email?

wangwz 2021-04-07

May I ask how long it takes for you to proofread after accepting it?

wangwz 2021-04-07

I also want to ask, how long does it take to receive the revised manuscript? I have been waiting for 12 days without any updates.

wangwz 2021-04-07

May I ask how long it will take for you to proofread after receiving it? Thank you.

Leezy 2021-04-07

May I ask what is the situation when the under review date has changed three times?

SHBING 2021-04-07

2020.12.16 submitted
2021.1.24 major revision
2021.2.22 resubmitted
2021.2.25 under review
2021.3.23 required reviews completed
2021.3.23 under review
2021.3.28 minor revision
2021.4.6 editor invited

Translation:
2020.12.16 submitted
2021.1.24 major revision
2021.2.22 resubmitted
2021.2.25 under review
2021.3.23 required reviews completed
2021.3.23 under review
2021.3.28 minor revision
2021.4.6 editor invited

tomorrow-lh 2021-04-06

12 Jan 2021 Initial Date Submitted
14 Jan 2021 With editor
22 Jan 2021 Under Review
12 Feb 2021 Required Reviews Completed
14 Feb 2021 Major Revision
13 Mar 2021 Revision Submitted to Journal
02 Apr 2021 Required Reviews Completed
02 Apr 2021 Accept

Leo He 2021-04-05

My paper has been with the editor for two months now, and I sent a reminder email a month ago, but still no response. If it weren't for the journal's impact factor of 3, I really wouldn't want to submit to it.

保顺毕 2021-04-02

2020.11.25 initial date submitted
2021.1.5 under review
2021.2.9 major revise
2021.3.1 submit revised
2021.3.24 minor
2021.3.31 submit revised
2021.4.1 accept

Translated:
2020.11.25 initial date submitted
2021.1.5 under review
2021.2.9 major revision
2021.3.1 submit revised
2021.3.24 minor
2021.3.31 submit revised
2021.4.1 accept

清岚 2021-04-02

Several reviewers have different opinions, so new reviewers have been added. Now we will see what the new reviewers' opinions are. The situation can be either good or bad. Don't worry, this journal has an extremely long "under review" status, but once accepted, the efficiency is exceptionally fast.

SHBING 2021-03-25

2020.12.16 submitted
2021.1.24 major review
2021.2.22 resubmitted
2021.2.25 under review
2021.3.23 Required Reviews Completed
2021.3.23 under review

Translated:
2020.12.16 submitted
2021.1.24 major review
2021.2.22 resubmitted
2021.2.25 under review
2021.3.23 Required Reviews Completed
2021.3.23 under review

沙漠希望 2021-03-25

Posted on July 11, 2020
Sent for review on July 19, 2020
Major revision on December 24, 2020 (two reviewers, very strict)
Returned for revisions on February 16, 2020 (due to excessive modifications, requested a one-month extension for submission)
Accepted on March 24, 2020
During this period, I have sent several emails to the editor and received replies, but the review process has never been expedited. Once you submit the article, forget about its existence unless the editor notifies you of any updates via email. Other forms of communication are essentially ineffective.
Characteristic: Slow, very slow, extremely slow, really slow!

SHBING 2021-03-24

Why did my article change to "required review complete" after one month of the second review, and then change back to "under review" after one hour? Does anyone know what is going on?

FUY.Y. 2021-03-24

I haven't received any proofreading emails since one month after being hired. I would like to ask whether the proofreading emails are sent to every author or just to the corresponding author?

环烷汀 2021-03-19

It should be "Under review" on the same day after the editor is invited. If you don't check it in time, you won't be able to see the "editor invited" status (I replied to the wrong comment...)

环烷汀 2021-03-19

It should be "Under review" on the same day after being invited by the editor. If you don't check it in time, you won't be able to see the "editor invited" node.

zeaplot 2021-03-09

Only the corresponding author can see the specific status. I only know the time of these few major milestones.

醋醋西瓜 2021-03-08

Could you please tell me if the submission process for your article goes through "Editor Invited" after "with editor," or does it go directly to "Under review"? If it goes to "Editor Invited," could you please provide the specific time? Thank you.

zeaplot 2021-03-07

11.26 Submission, with editor for over half a month;
01.12 Major revisions;
02.23 Minor revisions;
03.04 Acceptance. Overall speed is acceptable, but the time spent with the editor was a bit long.