拯救地球好累 2023-07-17

The status inside Research Square will be more detailed than the submission system. Both indicate that your manuscript has been accepted for review. However, the status in Research Square often behaves erratically, and not all statuses are displayed every time.

老默的鱼 2023-07-17

2023.6.3 submitted
2023.6.7 sent back, saying that I have a missing form number
2023.6.7 submitted
2023.6.11 sent back, saying that I didn't include a star next to the corresponding author
2023.6.11 submitted
2023.6.16 with editor
2023.7.15 unknown, still no news
Funny thing is, on July 14th, 2023, this journal sent a review notification to my advisor's email, with a later number than mine. I saw that we were colleagues, so I gave a minor revision without causing any trouble. However, my article is still "with editor". Helpless, I sent a reminder to Carmeila, but the response was very polite, saying that they are preparing to wait a bit longer. If it's not reviewed or rejected soon, I'm ready to withdraw the manuscript.

zsxzsx@ 2023-07-16

The translation of the given text is: "The status of my research at Research Square is 'reviews agreed,' but in the submission system, it still shows 'under review.' What does this mean? Seeking an answer from the experts!"

拯救地球好累 2023-07-16

Final acceptance on Jul 14, 2023.
A total of nine and a half months.

嘟噜噜 2023-07-16

So slow, if it were up to me, I would have withdrawn the submission directly. It has been three months and it still hasn't been reviewed.

Xiaopi Ding 2023-07-14

Has there been any change in my with editor for 10 days?

Xiaopi Ding 2023-07-14

Has your progress been made?

sanjinabc 2023-07-14

Ah, but I saw that a senior sister submitted an ESPR (Extended Student Project Report), and it was accepted and published in less than a month. It's too difficult.

Baozhi 2023-07-13

7.12 Required Reviews Completed

no626 2023-07-12

I have been waiting for 2 months, but still haven't received any search results. I feel like I have to wait for at least another month.

凡仔发发发ssci 2023-07-11

7/10 with editor translates to "seven out of ten with editor" in English.

Baozhi 2023-07-11

7.8 Required Reviews Completed.

sanjinabc 2023-07-10

How long does it usually take to receive and be able to search for it?

凡仔发发发ssci 2023-07-10

Return after modification on 2023/06/29.
Editor invited on 2023/07/03.
It has been in this state until now.

How long will the "editor invited" status last? It feels like it's lasting a bit long this time.

stroingenergy混渣王 2023-07-06

Must urge, I submitted one in late January this year, and it stayed "with editor" until early June. I have been reminding them every month. Last time I urged, I directly requested to change the editor, and on the same day it was changed to the editor, Philip. Then they sent it for external review. If there is no change after one month, I have to start urging. There are several editors in this journal who are particularly irresponsible, they keep it without rejecting or sending it for review.

胡三天 2023-07-05

July 4th submission
Take note.

Kevin Wu 2023-07-05

The translation of the text is: The review has been postponed four times. I submitted it in February, and it is still under review.

luyuan1994 2023-07-04

2023/02/03 First submission
2023/02/07 Returned (requested to indicate in the cover letter whether it was submitted to a photocopy)
2023/02/07 Resubmitted
2023/02/10 With editor
Editorial invitation in between
2023/03/20 Under review
2023/04/19 Major revision (both reviewers were positive, mostly addressing writing issues)
2023/05/13 Revised submission
2023/05/16 Editor invitation
2023/05/18 Under review
2023/07/04 Accept
2023/07/06 Signing publication instructions
2023/07/07 Proofreading
2023/07/11 Online
Thank you very much, Prof. Zhihong Xu.
The second article took a whole five months from submission to acceptance. I submitted my manuscript in early February and it was assigned a number in the 2100s. However, another person who submitted in early March received a number in the 4000s directly. So, everyone must be patient, as this journal receives a high volume of submissions and the editorial processing speed is limited. Finally, I wish everyone a happy life and successful research.

get it alright 2023-07-03

6.28,2023 主要修订

6.28,2023 major revision

郑小北 2023-07-03

Special issue with a rating of 4.8. During this period, the editor invited changes on 6.24 to collaborate with the editor. Should I now remind them to submit the manuscript? Dear friends, what do you think?

卡尔 2023-07-02

No, if the author requests to withdraw the manuscript, adjustments cannot be made. Indeed, the policy of ESPR is to not allow any addition/removal of author or any change in order list. You have now two choices:
* - You may go back to the original authorship and the process will continue for your manuscript
* - You may refuse to go back to the original authorship and the manuscript will not be published in ESPR.

jianli zhou 2023-07-01

May I ask if there is any possibility to change the first author?

爱祖国 2023-06-30

May I ask which formats have been modified and returned for revision?

Baozhi 2023-06-30

6.19 submitted
6.21 returned for format modifications
6.22 submitted
6.26 with editor
6.28 under review

芒果大仙 2023-06-30

@Bobo, my UR has been nearly 3 months.

波波公子 2023-06-30

May I ask how long your UR time is? It has been a month since I submitted my UR, but I haven't received any feedback yet. Has it been rejected?

T想发top 2023-06-30

I have about half a month left.

Eco-Env 2023-06-29

The processing efficiency of the editorial department is too low. After submission, it takes one month for external review, and the external review process lasts for one month. After the external review comments are returned to the editorial department, it takes another month to receive the feedback. In total, it takes three months to finally get the external review comments, and the result is rejection...

芒果大仙 2023-06-29

May 29th, the review was returned with major revisions. There were a total of 2 reviewers with a combined 12 comments.
June 25th, the revised draft was returned.
June 28th, accepted.
June 30th, proofreading.

待星辰归来 2023-06-28

The request to change the order of the second and third projects was also rejected.