Verified Reviews - ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND POLLUTION RESEARCH
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

AAABBC 2023-02-17

Six months...

Paperbeging 2023-02-16

Nov. 24 submitted to journal

This phrase is already in English.

wulawulawula-- 2023-02-16

Six months, return for the first opinion, submit in the middle of August of the 22nd year, receive the first opinion from foreign reviewers in the middle of February of the 23rd year.

520爱 2023-02-16

After the reminder, the status changed to "editor invited".

芒果大仙 2023-02-16

What does "编辑有什么表示吗?你的状态有变化吗?" mean? Is there any meaning in editing? Has your status changed?

obiesoul 2023-02-15

Submitted on November 3rd,
Around November 20th, it was under review.
Then came the long period of being under review.
On January 23rd, a reminder was sent, and a reply was received stating that one reviewer's comments had been received and they were still looking for a second reviewer.
As of February 15th, it is still under review.
Considering withdrawing the submission and opting for open access,
Otherwise, it won't meet the qualification review in April and I will have to extend my graduation.
This article, which I put so much effort into during my doctoral studies, has ended up like this.
I can't afford to care about anything else for the sake of graduation.

no626 2023-02-15

Congratulations, my No. 12 has finally rrc'd.

KneeYu 2023-02-14

2.14 accept in English means to agree to or approve something.

KneeYu 2023-02-14

Yes, only the corresponding author can see it.

叫什么都无所谓了 2023-02-14

Excuse me, does anyone know if the second author cannot view the progress in the submission system for this journal?

吃核桃补个脑 2023-02-13

Hello, may I ask what format should be used for referencing ESPR? It says my format is incorrect and has been returned.

no626 2023-02-13

1月18 under review - Under review on January 18th.
2月12 RRC - RRC on February 12th.

pytorch 2023-02-12

@naive97 The corresponding author has received the acceptance notification email.

pytorch 2023-02-12

@KneeYu I don't remember seeing rrc.

KneeYu 2023-02-12

The second minor revision is finally finished. The external audit has been completed. Feb 12, 2023. Required reviews completed.

naive97 2023-02-12

The reviewers will only provide their comments after the revised version is under review.

naive97 2023-02-12

Hello, I would like to inquire whether your environmental science and pollution research system has received any email after accepting.

naive97 2023-02-12

22.10.31 - First submitted
22.12.20 - Major revision
23.01.12 - Revision submitted to journal
23.02.10 - Accept

KneeYu 2023-02-12

Hello, may I ask if after you submit the second minor revision, does it show "required reviews completed" when the external review is finished? Mine has been showing "under review" all this time.

520爱 2023-02-10

It's urgent, the editor replied.

bi321 2023-02-10

How long does it take for this journal to be available online after proofing? And approximately how long does it take to retrieve it?

pytorch 2023-02-10

The above is for your reference, wishing all of you a successful outcome with just one attempt!

pytorch 2023-02-10

21.12. - First submitted
22.11. - Major
22.12 - Revision submitted to journal
23.01 - Minor
23.01 - Revision submitted to journal
23.02.09 - AC

芒果大仙 2023-02-09

If there is a reply, please let me know. I will go and look for the template.

no626 2023-02-09

Your speed is really fast. After my "under review" status changed once, it has been 22 days and there is still no change.

tao 2023-02-09

When proofreading, you will be asked to choose.

KneeYu 2023-02-09

Feb 08, 2023 Under Review

KneeYu 2023-02-08

Feb 07, 2023 With Editor

520爱 2023-02-07

Just go online and find a template for a reminder letter and write according to it. I just did it.

芒果大仙 2023-02-07

Not written yet, don't know how to urge, also worried that urging will cause resentment.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started