geottm 2022-08-27

Hello senior brother, I would like to ask if this journal charges any page fees or other fees.

oolili 2022-08-20

ER
7.7 submitted to journal
7.8 with editor
7.10 with editor
7.10 under review, invited 3 or more reviewers
7.13 under review, no reviewers, invited reviewers again
7.17 under review, no reviewers, invited again. Finally, one reviewer agreed to review on the second day, and another reviewer agreed on the third day, but the date did not change.
7.31 Tracking interface shows Reviews completed: 1
8.9 Learned from customer service that the system triggered a reminder email to the reviewers who have not completed the review
8.20 Review invitations accepted changed from 2 to 1 person. I don't know what happened, the reviewers who originally agreed to review have now declined? Goodness me...

Lucerne 2022-08-16

Just got a paper accepted and wanted to share the process with you all (it went pretty smoothly)!
7.3 submitted
7.4 with editor
7.5 with editor
7.8 under review
7.9 under review
7.10 under review
7.26 decision in process
7.27 revise
8.6 revise submitted
8.8 with editor
8.10 with editor
8.11 under review
8.12 required reviews completed
8.14 decision in process
8.15 accepted!
Thank you to the reviewers and kind editors!

森大影 2022-08-13

Received today, finally got the three small essays required for graduation, so excited. I'm here to share the timeline for reference.

September 26, 2021 - Submitted
September 30, 2021 - Under review
The status date changed multiple times at the beginning, but the status remained the same.
May 9, 2022 - R1 revise
May 19, 2022 - Submitted
May 25, 2022 - Under review
July 9, 2022 - R2 revise
July 13, 2022 - Submitted
August 13, 2022 - Accepted

During this period, I urged for revisions 5 times (I was brave), thanks to the editor's patience, especially to the editor-in-chief Jose L. Domingo, PhD, and his keen eye.

This journal is not fast, and I was really anxious to graduate. After reading other students' sharing, I felt that articles related to materials and methods might be faster. It was a big challenge for my mentality in the past year, but luckily, the result is good. Today is a good day, happy~

lrjie 2022-07-26

Received, hehe. Thank you, ER. Thank you to every expert!

鲍文风 2022-06-27

Due to the limit of 500 characters for comments, I can only express my gratitude here to the four experts who reviewed and the valuable suggestions from associate editor Robert Letcher. I also wish the best of luck to my fellow contributors for their submissions to be accepted soon.

鲍文风 2022-06-27

Shidi's ER (Emergency Room) Timeline:
Mar 06, 2022: Submitted
Mar 07, 2022: With Editor
Mar 09, 2022: Under Review
Mar 14, 2022: Under Review
Mar 16, 2022: Under Review
Mar 29, 2022: Under Review
Mar 29, 2022: Required Reviews Completed
Apr 01, 2022: Required Reviews Completed
Apr 03, 2022: Major revision (one minor revision and three major revisions)
May 30, 2022: Submitted
Jun 03, 2022: Under Review
Jun 19, 2022: Required Reviews Completed
Jun 20, 2022: Minor revision (one acceptance and one provided some minor suggestions)
Jun 22, 2022: Submitted
Jun 23, 2022: With Editor
Jun 24, 2022: Accept

lrjie 2022-06-07

Did he have a holiday? ? Please take a look at the children.

lrjie 2022-06-05

Erxiu has returned, hoping for good results! The editor will take a look at the poor child!

鲨鱼辣椒0 2022-06-01

I am too. I invested yesterday, and today it dipped. I feel like it's probably not looking good.

xiaonana 2022-05-29

I submitted my work and it became "decision in process" in just one day. I don't know if it will be rejected or not.

我要睡觉 2022-05-22

Did Decision in Process appear shortly after you submitted your manuscript? In my case, it appeared two days after I submitted it.

拼命发sci的科研狗 2022-05-16

Thank you for your response. This journal is too slow and tedious. I won't wait any longer and will switch my submission.

拼命发sci的科研狗 2022-05-14

After submission, it quickly entered the "Decision in Process" stage. It has been in this status for a while now. Is it going to be rejected? Why is the rejection taking so long? Does anyone know the situation?

purfreyct 2022-05-07

2021.10.21 Post
2021.11 Review
2021.12.13 Minor revisions, returned the next day
2022.01.16 Accepted
The speed is quite fast, and there are very few minor revisions, mainly focusing on formatting adjustments.

秃头少女L博士 2022-05-06

Posted on May 5, 2022, I hope the review of everyone's comments is not slow and that there will be a good outcome.

阿呆斯基 2022-03-16

How are the reviewers selected?

Miss_WangCC 2022-02-27

2021.12.4 submitted to Journal
2021.12.6 with editor
2021.12.7 with editor
2021.12.9 under review
2022.1.12 revise
2022.2.19 revision submitted to Journal
2022.2.20 with editor
2022.2.24 under review
2022.2.25 decision in process
2022.2.26 accept

Translation:

2021.12.4 submitted to Journal
2021.12.6 with editor
2021.12.7 with editor
2021.12.9 under review
2022.1.12 revise
2022.2.19 revision submitted to Journal
2022.2.20 with editor
2022.2.24 under review
2022.2.25 decision in process
2022.2.26 accept

hohaiweiwei 2022-02-13

The reviewing process is fast, the reviewing suggestions are pertinent, and the journal is excellent.

一学习就变不可爱 2022-02-06

May I ask which specific field you are researching? Will articles on architectural landscape be accepted?

一学习就变不可爱 2022-02-04

May I ask if you are researching the built environment and health? I would like to know if this journal is appropriate for submitting papers related to architectural planning background. Thank you very much!!! Also, good luck!

阳光岛 2022-01-28

Overall, the ER is okay. Submitted on December 7, 2021; Under review on December 7, 2021; Minor revisions on December 20, 2021; Revisions completed on January 26, 2022, and accepted on the same day. Editor-in-Chief Aijie Wang is very good.

不搞科研了 2022-01-22

How are you doing now?

wanglin555 2022-01-09

The text translates to: "The submission made on October 10 has been with the editor for 20 days for review. The decision will be made by January 8, and there is still no news. It is estimated that it will be within these two days. I hope for a good outcome!"

胡 2022-01-05

8.1 Submission - Major revision on October 20, return on November 1 - Minor revision on December 10, returned on the 15th - Still under review, it's been the sixth month and still no news.

取什么名好呢 2021-12-22

In a few days, I am ready to invest in this. Let's go for it and keep pushing!

浒 2021-12-22

Expected to submit this article next time, always pay attention to your review information.

maomao116 2021-12-15

Just invested at 12.15, hope everyone can achieve good performance before the end of the year.

lrjie 2021-11-17

Direction: Environment and Health. Submitted on October 11, 2021, under review as of October 20, 2021. Time updated on November 10, 2021, and the status is still under review... waiting!!! I hope dear editors and reviewers can show me some mercy!!! Hehe!

福雨流风远 2021-11-08

Which editor did you choose? When submitting to this journal, do we need a graphical abstract?