Verified Reviews - Engineering Failure Analysis
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

wogting 2023-02-18

The articles with the same volume have already been indexed by SCI, why hasn't mine been indexed yet? Could it be that this journal does not index SCI?

千山山 2023-02-15

2023.2.15 under review. It has been nearly 4 months since the first review, and there is still no response. I feel it is quite slow.

liziyang365 2023-02-14

Dec 05, 2022 Submitted
Dec 29, 2022 Reject

单行街 2023-01-06

The journal efficiency is very high, and there is a link where you can see the specific status of the review, with two reviewers.
20221118 Submission
20221119 Under review
20221203 Revision (revision deadline is 20 days)
20221221 Revised manuscript submitted
20221222 Under review
20221228 Accepted

米糖咖啡 2022-12-27

12.9 Revise: To make revisions or changes.
12.26 Revision submit: To submit the revised version.
12.27 Accept: To approve or agree to.

米糖咖啡 2022-12-09

I am too, a thought it was interesting, gave a few formatting suggestions, b is not innovative enough directly.

奇了怪 2022-11-28

Has anyone encountered the situation where their submission was rejected by the system, and then after making modifications and resubmitting, it was rejected again? The article is a mechanical analysis with an accident as the background. I kindly ask for guidance from experienced individuals who have submitted before. Thank you!

奇了怪 2022-11-28

Has anyone ever encountered a situation where their submission was rejected by the system, and after making modifications and resubmitting, it was rejected again? The article is a mechanistic analysis with the background of an accident. I kindly request guidance from all the experienced experts who have submitted before.

米糖咖啡 2022-11-24

We have been waiting for a month. Under review. We couldn't find a reviewer. If waiting any longer doesn't work, we will withdraw the submission.

lhqxxwb 2022-11-23

This efficiency is too low, wasting two weeks of time. It's better to reject it quickly. Sigh.

安静 2022-11-22

A week ago, the editor suggested transferring to other journals and recommended two journals.

lhqxxwb 2022-11-22

What efficiency is this if there hasn't been any change for over ten days? How is it now?

lhqxxwb 2022-11-22

Has your status changed? Mine has been in "Decision in Process" for several days too.

千山山 2022-11-19

2022 10 22 submitted to journal
2022 10 22 with editor
2022 10 29 under review
Recently checked (three weeks) and still no reviewer has agreed to review. Has anyone encountered this before?

wk_hnust 2022-11-16

On average, it takes a few days for the decision-making process, and currently, it hasn't moved.

wk_hnust 2022-11-16

I submitted my work and it was "Decision in Process" within two hours. It has been seven to eight days now. Should I remind the editor or just withdraw it directly? I feel like I'm wasting time.

安静 2022-11-15

2022 11 13 transfer → Transfer on November 13, 2022.

小12345 2022-11-13

2022.10.09 submitted to journal
2022.11.11 Under review

Geery 2022-11-12

May I ask if "decision in process" means rejection?

Geery 2022-11-12

May I ask if "decision in process" means it has been rejected?

安静 2022-11-11

2022 10 28 Submitted to Journal
2022 10 30 With Editor
2022 10 30 Decision in Process
2022 11 11 No changes, if you want to reject it, do it quickly.

susu98 2022-10-21

22.8.2 under review
22.915 revise
22.10.5 accept

Translated:
22.8.2 is under review
22.915 needs revision
22.10.5 is accepted

米糖咖啡 2022-10-19

After the communication author receives an email saying that it has entered the peer review stage, a URL will be provided, where they can see the status.

windskysnow 2022-10-15

May I ask how to check if the reviewer has been found?

米糖咖啡 2022-10-13

10.10 under review. The manuscript tracking system shows that no one has accepted the review yet.

米糖咖啡 2022-10-02

10.2 Under Review

susu98 2022-10-02

Can I ask if the revised version needs to be submitted with red highlights or in track changes mode?

米糖咖啡 2022-09-30

Submit at 6:30 PM, under review at 10 PM. No "with editor" status appeared. Not sure why, hope it won't be rejected.

大红配黑 2022-09-27

Submitted a case study, submitted on July 13th, revised on August 3rd, with one major revision and one minor revision. Worked on the revisions for nearly 20 days. Accepted on September 15th and published within a week. The process was relatively fast. The reviewers' comments were professional, targeting crucial points and using appropriate language. Overall, it feels good.

123aq 2022-09-23

Mine too, it has been two days since I submitted it and the decision is still in process. I feel really sad.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More