小思 2023-05-13

2023.02.28 - Submitted to journal
2023.03.02 - With editor
2023.03.07 - With editor
2023.03.08 - Under review
2023.03.09 - Under review
2023.03.10 - Under review
2023.03.13 - Under review
2023.03.17 - Under review
2023.03.22 - Under review
2023.03.25 - Under review
2023.03.27 - Under review
2023.03.28 - Under review
2023.04.02 - Under review (First reviewer completed)
2023.04.04 - Under review (Invited second reviewer)
2023.04.27 - Major revision (Three reviewers, two revisions, one rejection)
2023.05.12 - Submitted to journal
2023.05.13 - With editor

风清扬 2023-05-12

This is too difficult to handle.

mattino 2023-05-12

The same experience, waited for half a month and received a decision directly. Prepared to be rejected, but then they gave another week for a decision. Whether this journal is submitted or not, it is too slow.

风清扬 2023-05-11

I hope it will be fast, the person waiting is anxious.

奔跑的科研小菜鸡 2023-05-11

2023.05.07 Submitted to journal
2023.05.10 With Editor
2023.05.17 With Editor (date changed)
2023.05.19 With Editor (date changed)
2023.05.26 Under Review (sent to 3 reviewers)
2023.06.01 Under Review (invitation accepted by 1 reviewer)
Wishing for good luck, hoping that the reviewers will be kind and provide me with some revisions!

weiwei1987 2023-05-10

A week should be fast.

小蔡博士 2023-05-10

2023.05.10 under review. 8 reviewers invited, 2 accepted the invitation, and 2 have completed the review.

风清扬 2023-05-10

Can only wait, there is no other way.

weiwei1987 2023-05-09

Same submission date as you, just wait.

风清扬 2023-05-09

2023.4.27 Submitted to Journal
2023.4.29 Submissions Sent Back to Author: Maximum one major category, 3-5 minor categories
2023.4.29 Submitted to Journal
2023.5.1 With Editor
2023.5.5 With Editor
And since then, there has been no progress.

小蔡博士 2023-05-09

2023.05.06 under review. 8 reviewers invited, 2 accepted the invitation, and 1 review has been completed.

赶路侠 2023-05-09

Hello, I would like to ask how you saw the first person's review end and invited the second reviewer.

赶路侠 2023-05-09

Hello, I would like to ask, how did you see how many reviewers there are?

yyyaccept 2023-05-09

2023 05 09 - Still under review.

小菜博 2023-05-08

2023.05.07 Under review - This phrase remains the same in English.

thfdiiii 2023-05-04

2023.05.03 Required Reviews Completed

小思 2023-05-03

2022.02.28 - Submitted to journal
2022.03.02 - With editor
2022.03.07 - With editor
2022.03.08 - Under review
2022.03.09 - Under review
2022.03.10 - Under review
2022.03.13 - Under review
2022.03.17 - Under review
2022.03.22 - Under review
2022.03.25 - Under review
2022.03.27 - Under review
2022.03.28 - Under review
2022.04.02 - Under review (First reviewer completed)
2022.04.04 - Under review (Second reviewer invited)
2022.04.27 - Major revision (Three reviewers, two revisions, one rejection)

7#77 2023-05-03

Does this journal check for plagiarism?

小菜博 2023-05-03

2023. 05. 03 with editor I don't know if the editor didn't even look at it, or if they couldn't find a reviewer.

letxxzpub 2023-05-02

After one month of being "under review," it has changed to "decision in process." What does this mean? Does it indicate a high probability of rejection? It has been two days already, and I am really worried about this status.

thfdiiii 2023-04-29

2023.04.28 under review

JOTARA 2023-04-28

2022.11.2 Submission
2023.1.6 Received first-round comments, accepted with revisions by two reviewers, rejected by one reviewer
2023.2.4 Submitted revised manuscript for second-round review
2023.4.10 Under review
2023.5.7 Accepted

是张张 2023-04-27

Excuse me, has there been any changes?

是张张 2023-04-27

Has there been any change in the progress?

油气终结者 2023-04-26

I have been going back and forth with the submission for half a month. The dates changed twice in the process with the editor. Instead of being sent for review, it went directly to "Decision in process," which means it was rejected. However, can they please send the rejection email quickly so that I can resubmit it sooner? It has already been delayed for over ten days. Is it really necessary to be so slow in rejecting a manuscript?

小菜博 2023-04-26

Did you submit it for review? Did you submit it on the same day as you?

科研GoGo 2023-04-26

4.13 submit - To be submitted on April 13th
4.16 with editor - To be reviewed by the editor on April 16th
4.23 with editor - To be reviewed by the editor on April 23rd

刘好念 2023-04-24

1.12 Submission
3.07 Receiving review comments. There are two reviewers, the first one provided detailed comments and suggested minor revisions. The second reviewer had fewer comments and recommended major revisions. The revision time is one month.
4.15 Receiving second round of review comments. This time, there was only an issue with the image format, which was fixed and submitted on the same day.
4.17 Accepted.

zhangc3862 2023-04-22

2022.11.03 submit - Submitted on November 3, 2022.
2023.02.28 major revision - Major revisions required by February 28, 2023.
2023.03.18 resubmit - Resubmitted on March 18, 2023.
2023.04.13 minor revision - Minor revisions required by April 13, 2023.
2023.04.19 resubmit - Resubmitted on April 19, 2023.
2023.04.20 accept - Accepted on April 20, 2023.

unlucky man 2023-04-22

2022.06 submitted
2022.11 major revised
2022.12 resubmitted
2022.12.15 under review
2023.03 under review
2023.04.22 under review
2023.04.24 accept

Translation:

2022.06: Submitted
2022.11: Major revised
2022.12: Resubmitted
2022.12.15: Under review
2023.03: Under review
2023.04.22: Under review
2023.04.24: Accept