levis_119 2022-05-21

Around 50 days later, I received the reviewer's comments. After going through two major revisions, it was finally accepted. The editor, Yong Liang, was very efficient and a very nice person.

异枝江蓠 2022-05-18

Okay, thank you, brother.

gougou360 2022-05-18

After the major renovation, this magazine is generally quite friendly. Good luck!

异枝江蓠 2022-05-18

I have spent five days on extensive revisions and editing, and now it is under review. I noticed that the status has not changed, so I am worried that the reviewer has not responded at all. Thank you, I understand.

gougou360 2022-05-18

During the first review, "Under Review" often changes. I haven't encountered any changes during the second review, and after a period of time, "Under Review" will yield results.

异枝江蓠 2022-05-17

When revising and re-examining, will there be time changes in the response from the reviewer?

pikachu819 2022-05-02

Feb 27, 2022 submitted to the journal
Feb 29, 2022 with editor
Mar 8 under review
Mar 23 under review
Apr 4 major revision
Apr 26 revision submitted to the journal
Apr 29 with editor
May 2 accept
The process was fast, and the reviewers' comments were very constructive. Each of the three reviewers provided around 20 suggestions.

gougou360 2022-04-27

Feb 24, 2022: Submitted to the journal
Feb 25, 2022: With editor
Feb 28, 2022: Under review
Mar 2, 2022: Under review
Mar 12, 2022: Required reviews completed (deadline Apr 28, 2022)
Mar 14, 2022: Major revision
Apr 14, 2022: Revision submitted to journal
Apr 16, 2022: With editor
Apr 17, 2022: Under review
Apr 27, 2022: Accepted

The review process has been as fast as usual. There were three reviewers, with two requesting major revisions and one requesting minor revisions. They provided around 50 comments, almost the length of another article. This is a good start to the year, and let's continue with the same level of effort.

5lll 2022-04-19

How long does the second review take after you return for repair?

君君发sci 2022-04-02

How do I collect the layout fee?

小萌妮 2022-03-16

New Year's Day submission, received first review comments in 24 days, delayed submission by a month due to the Lunar New Year, second review completed in half a month, accepted. The speed is very fast.

科研废物-小石 2022-03-16

Hello, I am also a proof on March 15th. I have filled in the invoice information, but I have not made the payment yet. Do you know how to make the payment for this journal?

Wu_Hao 2022-03-15

The given text "2022-3-15 proof" is already in English and does not require translation.

Wu_Hao 2022-03-14

2021-12-23 Submission
2022-02-17 Major revision
2022-03-10 Resubmission
2022-03-13 Acceptance

勤恳的傻子 2022-03-09

August 2021 submission, quickly assigned to an editor and sent for review under review.
December 20, 2021, reminder, editor Liu Guorui patiently explains.
February 11, 2022, major revision.
February 22, 2022, revised submission.
March 4, 2022, required review complete.
March 4, 2022, Accept, publish agreement.

文宝宝 2022-03-08

2022.03.08 Accepted translates to "Accepted on March 8, 2022" in English.

feiii 2022-03-06

12 13, 2021 under review - December 13, 2021, under review
12 15 2021 under review - December 15, 2021, under review
12.21 2021 under review - December 21, 2021, under review
1.10 2022 under review - January 10, 2022, under review
1.27 2022 under review - January 27, 2022, under review
2.7 2022 under review - February 7, 2022, under review
2.22 2022 Required Reviews Completed - February 22, 2022, Required Reviews Completed
2.23 minor revision - February 23, minor revision
2.28 Revision Submitted to Journal - February 28, Revision Submitted to Journal
2.28 with editor - February 28, with editor
3.1 accept - March 1, accept
3.2 proof - March 2, proof

levis_119 2022-02-23

After acceptance, you will be able to see the handing editor.

w222 2022-01-29

May I ask where to see the specific edits?

zll 2022-01-07

2021.10.04 submit - Submitted on October 4, 2021
2021.11.27 major editor - Major edits made on November 27, 2021
2021.12.10 submit - Submitted on December 10, 2021
2021.12.25 minor editor - Minor edits made on December 25, 2021
2021.1.1 submit - Submitted on January 1, 2021
2022. 1.3 accept - Accepted on January 3, 2022
Thank you very much to the reviewers and editor Chen Renji for their very fast processing speed.

Tideychao 2022-01-02

September 14, 2021 - submit the manuscript
September 16, 2021 - Manuscript Number Assigned
September 17, 2021 - with editor
September 24, 2021 - under review
October 19, 2021 - Interim Decision: Major revision
November 20, 2021 - resubmit the manuscript
November 23, 2021 - under review
December 14, 2021 - Interim Decision: Minor revision
December 21, 2021 - resubmit the manuscript
December 26, 2021 - under review
January 2, 2022 - Accept

This is my first submission to EES. Overall, I feel that the journal has strict requirements. The first round of comments required major revisions, and the reviewer's comments were very constructive, greatly improving the presentation of the article and figures. The second round of comments requested minor revisions, but focused on language modification (even though language editing had already been done once before), so it was sent for language editing again. After it came back, there was another round of under review, and finally, it was accepted.

文宝宝 2021-12-27

2021.12.27 Under review Major renovation for review.

文宝宝 2021-12-24

2021.12.24 Con Editor (With Editor)

文宝宝 2021-12-23

2021.12.23 Revision Submitted to Journal translates to: The revision for the date 2021.12.23 has been submitted to the journal.

LYJ搬砖 2021-12-20

20211219 under review... Why is it always under external review with no results coming back?

LYJ搬砖 2021-12-17

Submitted on November 14, 2021
With editor on November 16, 2021
Under review on November 17, 2021
Under review on November 26, 2021
As of today, December 17th, there have been no updates.

今天认真学习了吗 2021-12-14

2021.12.1 approving the revised version
2021.12.2 with editor
2021.12.8 under review
2021.12.14 accept
From submission to acceptance took three months, and the comments from the reviewers were very insightful. It took one and a half months to revise the paper and respond to the reviewers' questions. I wish the journal continued success!

小萌妮 2021-12-13

Is there an opportunity to become an upgraded version of District 1 in the past two years?

文宝宝 2021-12-10

2021.12.09 Major Revision

文宝宝 2021-12-09

2021.10.26 Submit the manuscripts
2021.10.27 Distribution of editing
2021.10.29 under review
2021.10.30 under review
2021.11.08 under review
2021.11.10 under review
2021.11.13 under review
2021.12.9 Required Reviews Completed

Translation:
2021.10.26 - Manuscripts submitted
2021.10.27 - Editing distribution
2021.10.29 - Under review
2021.10.30 - Under review
2021.11.08 - Under review
2021.11.10 - Under review
2021.11.13 - Under review
2021.12.9 - Required Reviews Completed