LiYF 2022-10-28

Submitted in mid-April, accepted at the end of October, lasting 6 months, too slow, in the end, didn't catch up with anything.

rr2013y 2022-10-27

It has been one week with the editor.

w222 2022-10-26

Three days have passed, and the status is still "Submitted to Journal".

Jiuhong Chen 2022-10-23

10.1 submit - October 1st submission
10.6 with editor - October 6th with editor
10.12 under review - October 12th under review
10.21 under review - October 21st under review

星皇皮皮 2022-10-20

6.30 Submit
7.5 Under review
8.4 Major Review
8.29 Revision submitted to journal
8.30 Under Review
9.14 Major Review
9.21 Submit
9.28 Under Review
10.5 Accept
10.10 Online

The journal's processing efficiency is very high, and the reviewers are very professional. They have provided many valuable comments that are targeted to the article, which has been of great help. Thank you to the reviewers, thank you to the editor, Liang!

kingsir 2022-10-08

The article has been received for reference.
Received on May 6, 2022;
Received in revised form on August 11, 2022;
Accepted on August 31, 2022.
One major revision and one minor revision.

永不空军 2022-10-06

10.6 Under review.

永不空军 2022-09-30

9.15 submit
9.16 with editor
9.20 interim decision
9.30 revision submitted to journal

Feedback includes: Limit of 6 figures; Limit of references to 40-45; Figures should be in black and white, and some other suggestions. It seems like these restrictions were not mentioned in the submission guidelines. Sigh, let's make the changes as he suggested.

小雨 2022-09-22

I am in day 10 with the editor, under review.

DCDD 2022-09-21

I want to ask how to check the peer review status?

just11 2022-09-20

Reviewed for nearly 4 months, isn't it a bit too long???

LeiChen000 2022-09-19

Is it normal for an external audit to take two months?

永不空军 2022-09-16

$2700 USD, already invested, the progress is not fast. I hope to finish it within 2-3 months to graduate successfully.

奔跑的骏马 2022-09-13

Still 2600 US dollars.

白二苟 2022-09-12

I submitted my manuscript at the end of July, but I still haven't found any reviewers yet... There hasn't been any acceptance for review either... I'm so frustrated.

小菜菜菜 2022-09-12

We are about the same. I am the first to submit for review, but until now, no one has accepted the manuscript.

xiaohuan2 2022-09-12

First time submitting to this magazine, submitted on August 23rd, sent for review on September 2nd. It has been over a week and the Peer review status still shows 0 accepted reviews. It seems that none of the 5 reviewers I recommended were chosen, and the editor found some particularly slow reviewers themselves, which is really time-consuming.

A 文 2022-09-07

Did USD2600 become USD2700?

是金子总会被我花光 2022-09-06

Only when the first feedback is received will you see which editor it is.

是金子总会被我花光 2022-09-06

From submission to acceptance, it took a full three months, including minor revisions.

a654292103 2022-09-05

It should be faster now. Each time it changes, it means the reviewer has made progress. With six or seven changes, the results should be coming soon.

白二苟 2022-09-04

Who can I see who edited the paper? I want to write a reminder letter...

just11 2022-08-30

How long did everyone receive their results? I started submitting in May, and the "under review" date keeps changing. It has happened six or seven times. What is going on?

白二苟 2022-08-18

It has been 20 days and still haven't found a reviewer, what should I do? I am so worried.

是金子总会被我花光 2022-08-02

It has been two months already and two reviewers have completed their feedback. However, I still haven't received any email and I don't know when to find the third reviewer. The second reviewer completed their feedback on July 22nd. I am anxiously waiting.

酸奶山楂 2022-07-22

It has been 10 days with Editor, is the speed normal?

静等花开 2022-07-20

March 12th - Submitted
April 6th - Interim Decision
April 23rd - Revise and resubmit
May 7th - Accepted
May 10th - Proof
May 10th - Available online
You can remit the payment later, as the page fee is expensive, $2600.
My editor is Professor Yong Liang. This is for reference only. When you submit your manuscript, you can choose an editor, but it does not necessarily mean you will be assigned the one you selected. Good luck to everyone.

y-c-yu 2022-07-19

With an editor for 20 days, please submit for external review.

LiYF 2022-07-17

Three months of reviewing, four changes, still no results.

kingsir 2022-07-16

It has been 2 months and 10 days since the external audit started. During this period, the status has changed 4-5 times. I don't know what the situation is. Can experienced professionals share their insights?