胖達 2022-12-12

It seems that my experience is similar to several other forum moderators. I have already gone through three reviews, and except for the first one which required major revisions, the rest were just minor suggestions for wording changes. However, the editor still doesn't accept it and wants to review it again. Could it be the same editor (Kak____kas)?

小脉mo 2022-12-11

2022.12.10 under review, the date changes again!

多发论文哦 2022-12-10

It has been almost a week and there has been no progress on the required reviews. Is this editor really this slow in terms of efficiency?

小脉mo 2022-12-10

Third review, from 10.25 until now, the under review date has been changing, with the latest date being 12.1. Hoping for good news!

bioshepherd 2022-12-08

12.4 Submitted to Journal
12.5 With Editor
12.6 Submitted to Journal
12.7 Under review

Translation:
12.4 Submitted to Journal
12.5 With Editor
12.6 Submitted to Journal
12.7 Under review

棒棒糖大仙 2022-12-06

Do we have to pay for page charges for this journal? Isn't it non-OA now?

舟舟0624 2022-12-06

I submitted my work in the same month as you did, and I also had a new reviewer. The revised version for the second review was sent back on October 17th. Now it is in the third review, but the reviewer has not uploaded any comments yet.

小脉mo 2022-12-04

2022.12.1 under review.

jqq1234 2022-11-30

How many reviewers do you have, please?

Lay's 2022-11-29

5.20 Submission
7.29 Initial review comments returned
8.12 Returned for first round of revisions
10.28 Second review comments returned
10.31 Returned for second round of revisions
11.23 Accepted for publication

lanqijun 2022-11-29

2022-11-12 rrc - Not enough context to provide an accurate translation.

2022-11-13 revise - This means that a revision is required.

2022-11-21 resubmitted - This means that something has been submitted again.

2022-11-22 with editor - This means that something is currently being reviewed by an editor.

2022-11-23 accepted - This means that something has been approved or agreed upon.

Jessica灬Cheng 2022-11-29

Hello, may I ask what are the requirements for the format when submitting to this journal? I tried opening the "Guide for authors" on the journal's official website, but it couldn't be accessed and showed a "not found" error. I wanted to ask you how you usually modify the formatting of your articles when submitting.

wangpeijia 2022-11-28

Posted on May 14th, 2022, accepted in October 2022. It went through four revisions in between, with the first review taking about one and a half months, and the second review taking almost half a month. The main delay was caused by myself.

阿众 2022-11-25

Unable to find reviewers for four months and being rejected, we share the same fate.

518518 2022-11-21

What direction is your article about?

518518 2022-11-21

Is it normal for a manuscript submitted on 2022,11,17 to still be in the "with editor" status today?

小脉mo 2022-11-19

2022.11.17 under review, the date changes again.

93秦先生 2022-11-18

My opinion is similar to yours. The first review yielded two opinions. The second reviewer praised it and provided three suggestions: improve image quality, increase discussion content, and adhere to the text standards required by the journal. I thought everything was fine, but upon return, the second reviewer still hasn't reviewed it and it has been resubmitted. Darn it!

小脉mo 2022-11-17

2022.11.16 under review, date change

zzmt 2022-11-17

How long does the first trial usually last?

小脉mo 2022-11-15

It feels like the repeated review might have been caused by the author's changes during the process. I noticed that other submissions were accepted directly after the second revision with editing. It was troublesome for me to change the author in both the first and second revisions. I suggest discussing the author with the supervisor in advance before submitting.

小脉mo 2022-11-15

Specific dates were forgotten, not communication, approximately as follows:
April 2022: Submission
July 2022: Revision
August 2022: Returned for modifications, under review for a few days
A new reviewer was sought in between, the original reviewer accepted, and suggested major revisions
Early October 2022: Revision
Late October 2022: Returned, under review for a few days
November 11, 2022: Required reviews completed, thought there would be a result
November 12, 2022: Under review, anxious, was it arbitrated? Were more reviewers added?
Currently waiting.

ma12345 2022-11-12

Two reviewers provided very professional and precise opinions. After making significant revisions, the paper was accepted.

WZR_BNU 2022-11-10

Just a simple record, hoping it can be accepted~
Submission: Oct 29, 2022
Under review: Nov 10, 2022

roleon 2022-11-09

May 24, 2022 Submission
Nov 02, 2022 Reject
We regret to inform you that we were unable to find the necessary number of reviewers to evaluate your manuscript. We do not want to further delay the process for you.
I have submitted the manuscript for five months, and it has been under review status the entire time. During the third and fourth month, I sent emails to inquire about the status of the manuscript, but did not receive any reply. After five months, I was notified that the manuscript was rejected due to the inability to find reviewers. This is outrageous!!!

hkwhkwhkw 2022-11-02

May I ask how long it will take for your school to go online after the closure?

wmt368 2022-10-27

I also started reviewing on September 7th. Today is already October 27th, and it's still not finished. Is it because the reviewers don't think highly of single-authored articles?

wmt368 2022-10-27

You are so fast. I have been reviewing for 2 months and it's still not finished.

hkwhkwhkw 2022-10-26

I also have four suggestions as a reviewer. May I ask if you have re-assigned other reviewers after your revision, or did the editor accept it directly?

whc 2022-10-26

No, upon return, the editor received it directly.