小小曹同学 2023-02-27

Congratulations! Your response is so fast, mine hasn't come back yet. I'm nervous.

niliu 2023-02-27

2023.2.27 Major Revision: The editor has given 14 days for revision. Both reviewers were very thorough and provided many excellent suggestions, but the amount of work required for the revisions is also significant. Feeling tense, praying, praying.

星岛 2023-02-26

It will take approximately 2 to 3 weeks, give or take.

小小曹同学 2023-02-26

Prove that you have done a good job, the editor has given you a chance to make modifications, and in general, they will also give a bonus. Congratulations!

星岛 2023-02-26

2022.11.30 Manuscript Submitted
2022.12.12 Under Review
2023.1.2 Major Revision (two reviewers, one minor revision, one rejection, editor provided a major revision with a 14-day revision period)
2023.1.16 Revised Manuscript Submitted
2023.1.16 Under Review
2023.1.26 Accept

星岛 2023-02-26

The level of the editorial team is very high!

小小曹同学 2023-02-26

2.26 is currently being reviewed.

**--** 2023-02-24

What's going on? It's been 15 days for me.

longzhihouzhe 2023-02-23

I don't know how long it will take to receive online.

小小曹同学 2023-02-21

2023.1.28 manuscript submitted
2023.1.30 with editor
2023.2.1 under review

Last time, it took only 14 days for the manuscript to go through the first review process. This time, it has been 21 days since the first review, and I haven't received any feedback yet. I wonder how long everyone else's review process is taking? Good luck to all!

niliu 2023-02-17

"Under review" does not send emails, please check the system directly~

Together001 2023-02-17

Good luck! Will I receive an email notification when the status changes to "Under review"?

疯狂比利 2023-02-15

It's really super fast, almost like lightning speed.

疯狂比利 2023-02-15

Too fast, simply lightning speed.

cyanine 2023-02-15

My goodness, it's already the 10th AFM. Tears of envy are left behind. The first one is still anxiously awaiting the results.

longzhihouzhe 2023-02-15

The editing process for the manuscript is very efficient.
2023-01.09 submitted to journal
2023-01-16 under review
2023-02-03 minor revision, both reviewers (TOP 15%) requested minor revisions, editor gave one week for revision.
2023.02.09 revised in the evening
2023.02.10 Accept
This is my first time submitting to AFM, and the speed of the submission process is astonishing. AFM's efficiency is truly high.

小小曹同学 2023-02-13

May I ask how long the first trial takes and how many reviewers there are? Thank you.

bisonghu 2023-02-13

Because of the epidemic and the Chinese New Year holiday, the editors have given an extension of three weeks (total of six weeks) for the major revisions. The editors and reviewers are very nice, so keep up the good work!!!

**--** 2023-02-13

How long have you been with the editor? It's been three days for me already. How can we determine if the editor is looking for a reviewer or deciding whether to submit it for review?

~接化发~ 2023-02-13

2022.12.2 Submission
2023.1.10 Minor revisions
2023.2.7 Accepted
The initial stage with the editor took two weeks, probably because it took some time to find reviewers. The three reviewers had respective percentages of 5%, 15%, and 15%. The editor requested minor revisions, and due to the Chinese New Year holiday, the revisions were completed in 7 days. The acceptance was received three weeks later.

小小曹同学 2023-02-13

The editor is deciding whether to submit for review, if it is submitted, the status will change. Please wait patiently.

**--** 2023-02-13

Is this the time to look for reviewers? Or did the editor not handle it?

小曹同学 2023-02-13

Please wait patiently for another two days. Usually, there will be new updates within a week. Best wishes.

**--** 2023-02-13

It has been three days since I submitted my work, and the status is still "with editor". It hasn't changed at all. What's going on?

**--** 2023-02-13

It's been three days already, and I've been with the editor this whole time. What's going on?

scu流川枫 2023-02-12

2022.11.1 Submission
2023.1.10 Minor revisions
2023.2.12 Acceptance
The reviewer is highly professional, providing very constructive suggestions, and the editor is also responsible in their editing. A top-tier journal with integrity.

niliu 2023-02-12

Submitted manuscript on 2023.2.2
With editor on 2023.2.6
Under review on 2023.2.7
Submitted a review article, very nervous, praying for good luck.

小曹同学 2023-02-08

xiaoyyyy, that means the review process is over and the editor will soon send an email to the author. Best wishes.

捷丰 2023-01-28

The editor of AFM, Mara Staffilani, is very responsible and reviews manuscripts quickly. The reviewers' comments greatly helped improve the content of the article!
2022-11-18 Submitted to Journal
2022-12-14 Required Reviews Completed
2022-12-22 Major Revision
2023-01-07 Revised Manuscript Submitted
2023-01-25 Accepted

xiaoyyyyyyy 2023-01-23

Will your date change upstairs? I submitted it on December 13, 2022, and the date has not changed until now. However, the status afterwards went through "with editor-under review" and now it shows "required reviews completed." Is this normal?