中科院岳麓山实验室院长 2021-08-17

No, I'm so anxious. School is starting soon.

墨云 2021-08-17

Is there any news at the moment?

中科院岳麓山实验室院长 2021-08-17

8.9投已结果未知 translates to "8.9 already voted, result unknown" in English.

墨云 2021-08-15

Previously, it always showed "under consideration". Will it really be sent for review if it is not rejected for 2 weeks?

龍在天 2021-08-12

Only the corresponding author should be able to see the status, other authors cannot see it anymore. Good luck!

龍在天 2021-08-12

The review process is fast, with the first review completed within 21 days and only requiring minor revisions. It has been returned for further revisions, and we are looking forward to favorable outcomes.

琉璃夜下 2021-08-11

Summary
Submitted on 20210517
Review comments received on 20210624, with major and minor revisions. The evaluation was particularly good. However, one rejection was received mainly due to the article being too long. The editor provided one month for major revisions.
Submitted review comments on 20210714
Accepted directly on 20210808, but it was a acceptance letter from another editor. It seems like the first editor was on vacation.
Overall, the review process was quite fast and the responses to the reviewers were confident and assertive.

rhylongbai 2021-08-10

According to the reviewer's suggestions, the experiment was supplemented and modified before being resubmitted. It took one month for the review process, but ultimately it was rejected. The reviewer repeatedly changed their opinion, raising suspicion of intentional delay due to the same field of study. All the questions were answered, but the reviewer fabricated new issues without any basis.

rhylongbai 2021-08-09

Upstairs, generally, you should take a look at the comments section more often in a week. There's no need to ask the same simple question multiple times.

Solar E 2021-08-09

Hello, may I ask how many days it takes to submit the application after completing it?

rhylongbai 2021-08-09

Retry for 1 month, no results obtained.

墨云 2021-08-08

I want to know what happened later, and I have been in this state for a week.

Solar E 2021-08-07

Hello, may I ask if there will be an email notification after submitting the contribution for review? It is my first time submitting, and I am seeking an answer.

Solar E 2021-08-07

After submitting your article, will you receive an email notification if it is sent for review?

小千 2021-08-05

This submission has been successful. Normally, if it takes a long time, it means it has been sent for review and is currently under review. If it hasn't been sent for review, the rejection speed by the editor is very fast. Best wishes.

柚柚柚柚子 2021-08-02

Already submitted, hoping for the review to be sent.

acs chemistry 2021-08-02

What is the result in the end?

小钟哥 2021-07-25

I would like to consult with senior colleagues about submitting a manuscript. Recently, I submitted a manuscript as the first author using my own account. During the submission process, I transferred the corresponding authorship to my supervisor. After that, all my information disappeared from the system. Even though my supervisor completed the submission later on, I cannot see anything in my system. What could be the reason for this situation?

小千 2021-07-23

7.23 Receive, submit supplementary data. The second review result will be out in 15 days, very soon, thumbs up!

小千 2021-07-22

How long did everyone wait after the return of the first trial? It's been 14 days for me, and I feel very anxious.

小千 2021-07-21

Only communication can receive emails. You can ask your supervisor, or if you have a teacher's account, you can log in to check the submission status.

爱因斯坦JJ 2021-07-19

Which editor is responsible for handling you?

琉璃夜下 2021-07-19

May I ask if the reviewers' comments are to be submitted, will the other authors besides the corresponding author receive an email?
I have already provided all the required materials to the supervisor, but it has been five days and I have not received any emails.

小千 2021-07-19

6.4 Submission
6.28 First review comments, 2 reviewers, both minor revisions. Editor requested major revisions, with 10 days given.
7.8 Submitted revised manuscript.
It has been 11 days now, waiting patiently for the results...

爱因斯坦JJ 2021-07-18

First review took 24 days, two reviewers, 1 acceptance, 1 major revision. The editor gave 10 days for revisions, and it has been sent back. Praying for good news!

zhangzju 2021-07-17

6.5 Submission
6.28 Received review comments, given ten days for major revisions (one reviewer had no issues, while the other requested additional experimental explanations regarding the mechanism)
7.7 Revised manuscript returned
7.16 Accepted
Overall, the process was very fast. Thank you, editor.

锥形量热仪 2021-07-08

Do any of you upstairs know the result?

金隅 2021-07-06

6.22 Submission Unknown

克罗地亚 2021-07-03

Received comments on the manuscript 25 days later. After making modifications, the outcome is unknown.

嘻哈一生 2021-06-30

May 26th, the results have been submitted but are unknown.