太难 2022-06-28

Is the external review process for this journal lengthy? I have been waiting for almost half a month and still haven't received an invitation to review.

MJ-ID 2022-06-28

May I ask if there is no submission template for this journal, sir?

chongerfei 2022-06-27

The speed feels quite fast. From submission, revision, to acceptance, it takes a total of one hundred days. Students who are in a hurry can give it a try.

Walk_on_Water 2022-06-26

Just adding, submitted on 20th February 2022, manuscript number assigned on the same day.
On 16th March, reviewer's comments for revision, but it didn't specify if it was major or minor revision, only mentioned to reconsider it for publication. Two reviewers had 5 and 13 questions, respectively.
On 6th May, revised manuscript returned, took longer to make the revisions, but it was done diligently.
On 24th June, decision in process.
On 26th June, directly accepted.

Walk_on_Water 2022-06-26

Received at Editorial Office: 19 Feb 2022
Article revised: 6 May 2022
Article accepted for publication: 26 Jun 2022

I personally took a long time to revise the article, which caused some delays. There were more than 20 specific and detailed comments from the two reviewers, and it was important to respond seriously.

The process was fast, and the editor was responsible. They responded promptly to any questions.

Dan 2022-06-21

3.15 Submission on the same day, marked "With Editor" and currently "Under Review"
4.18 Revised and reconsidered, with 15 suggestions provided by two reviewers
6.9 Returned after modification
6.15 Decision in process
6.19 Accepted
6.21 Notified for proofreading
The journal is highly efficient, but the process took longer due to my own slow modifications.

chongerfei 2022-06-17

From applying to minor repairs to being hired, it took about a hundred days, which is quite fast.

cmc235 2022-06-14

The opinions of the first trial have been returned.

King SCI 2022-06-14

Wow, top-level efficiency!

沙雕外包放羊技校 2022-06-14

This journal has changed its Editor-in-Chief. The difficulty seems to have increased, and I received suggestions from 6 reviewers. Some of them did not understand and provided difficult-to-understand comments. Sigh.

mmonny 2022-06-14

3 months received,
3.11 submitted,
3.12 with editor,
3.12-4.5 under review,
5.8 returned,
5.9 with editor,
5.10-6.4 second review comments returned,
6.10 second revision returned,
6.12 accepted.

luoshiyong 2022-06-14

It has been nearly two months since the manuscript was submitted for review, but there is still no news. Everyone should take this as a lesson. Luckily, the luck was good in the previous half month when it returned.

太难 2022-06-11

Hello, is your status still "under reviewer"? Have you not received any feedback yet?

cmc235 2022-06-08

The first trial took more than a month.

turtle_dd 2022-06-08

May I ask how long has it been under review?

太难 2022-05-28

Generally, with an editor, it takes a few days.

太难 2022-05-28

26号投 - Submitted on the 26th
27号with editor 希望一切顺利 - With editor on the 27th, hoping everything goes smoothly
一般with editor - Generally, with editor

太难 2022-05-27

Is this journal fast with the editor?

luoshiyong 2022-05-27

It has been over a month under review, hoping for the results to be released soon.

turtle_dd 2022-05-20

Record the following:

2022.05.19 submitted
2022.05.20 Under Review
2022.07.16 Revise 4 reviewers 30 comments
2022.08.26 Under Review
2022.09.11 Revise 1 reviewer 4 comments
2022.09.13 Submitted
2022.09.15 Under Review
2022.09.27 Decision in process
2022.10.02 Accept

DanielWangow 2022-05-19

2022/4/12: submitted
2022/4/14: under review
2022/4/27: reconsider after revision (4 reviewers with 23 comments, and 2 reviewer positive feedback)
2022/5/14: resubmitted (5283 words in response letter)
2022/5/15: under review
2022/5/18: review complete (5 reviewers)
2022/5/19: completed - accept

The entire submission process took 37 days (relatively prompt revisions), with an impressively efficient journal, with an instant impact factor exceeding 6 if 4.589. The submission format is "your paper your way". Hoping for continued success!

cmc235 2022-05-03

Submitted: April 21, 2022
Under review: April 23, 2022

猎涉者 2022-05-01

4.26 refusal. It was directly rejected without being reviewed.

弓长先生 2022-04-27

On April 27th, Reject, without going through Under review, is really easy to get rejected, it's just that the waiting time is a bit long.
Everyone, let's work hard together.

Z12138 2022-04-27

2022.4.11 Submitted to Journal
2022.4.12 With Editor
2022.4.13 Decision in Process
2022.4.27 Reject
Reason for rejection: "Lack of sufficient novelty, we received many more papers than we can accept."

落子 2022-04-27

4.27 under review

Warriors996 2022-04-26

No change, just two days.

woeiks 2022-04-26

Hello, on the second day of submission, my article has also been in the "Decision in process" status early in the morning. May I ask how your article is doing now?

Warriors996 2022-04-26

Submission: April 25th
With editor: April 25th
Decision in Process: April 26th
No "Under Review" yet. May I ask how your paper is doing?

落子 2022-04-26

2022.4.25投稿 - Submitted on April 25, 2022.
2022.4.26与编辑 - With editor on April 26, 2022.