MJ-ID 2022-08-07

7.25 submit - Submitted on July 25th.
7.26 with editor - Under the editor's review since July 26th.
7.31 under review - Currently under review since July 31st.
It has been a week and I have sent out invitations to 2+ reviewers. Only one expert has accepted so far. How long does it usually take for someone to accept the invitation after being under review?

zzzzsss 2022-08-05

8.2 Submission
8.3 Under review by editor
8.5 Decision in process
It is estimated that the submission has been rejected. Waiting for feedback to see which part of the situation led to the rejection.

科研神兽 2022-07-29

Excuse me, the submission was returned to him, saying that there is a lack of data visualization materials. What does this mean? Does it mean that I need to package and upload all my pictures or data?

Walk_on_Water 2022-07-28

Just use single columns all the way, it will be edited into double columns when published.

落子 2022-07-26

Yes, the clean version cannot be submitted as a PDF, so I submitted a .tek file and then submitted the entire compressed LaTeX package.

galeilei 2022-07-25

Yes. One month.

Mengki 2022-07-25

The text translates to: "When an article is submitted for review, it is labeled as 'Under Review'. If the reviewers accept the review, it should be done quickly. I submitted an article a month ago and couldn't find any reviewers accepting it. So, I sent an email to remind them, and the 'Under Review' status changed once. I found two reviewers, and it took 15 days to receive the first review comments. You can check the details in the tracking section of the email or contact the official online customer service of Aisville. Provide the journal and article number for them to help you check."

是小小一呀 2022-07-24

Hello, may I ask if you have been under review for about a month?

galeilei 2022-07-24

5.22 with editor translates to: On May 22nd, the text is being reviewed by an editor.
5.23 under review translates to: On May 23rd, the text is currently being reviewed.
6.20 revise translates to: On June 20th, the text will be revised.
7.24 with editor translates to: On July 24th, the text is with an editor.

守候阳光 2022-07-24

Did you encounter any issues with being unable to submit a clean version when responding to the review comments this time?

落子 2022-07-22

The editor will review it soon, not more than two weeks. Just wait a little longer.

落子 2022-07-22

6.21 Return feedback
7.22 Resubmit after making modifications.

是小小一呀 2022-07-19

Hello, may I ask you some questions? Specifically, how many reviewers are there? And how many days does the review process take? (Can it be specified in terms of exact number of days?)

chongerfei 2022-07-19

I couldn't find where to reply one by one, so I'll reply collectively. I received the submission very quickly, but it took over a month for the external review comments to come back. Then I made changes for half a month and submitted them, and it took another half a month to receive the results. There was also a small issue that required another round of revisions. After that, I checked the formatting and finalized it. Regarding the template, I couldn't find a word template on the official website at that time. Because my previous submission was rejected by TMI, I directly used TMI's template and made some modifications based on the official website's format requirements.

是小小一呀 2022-07-17

Oh my, does that mean I will also need to take two months to get started? Could it be related to the change of editor-in-chief? I noticed that this journal changed its editor-in-chief this year. I feel like there has been an increase in the number of submissions for many journals this year, and many journals' impact factors have also increased significantly. I wonder if it is related to this.

turtle_dd 2022-07-15

2022.07.15 Required Reviews Complete External audit took two months.

luoshiyong 2022-07-14

I have been under review for three months.

是小小一呀 2022-07-14

Ah, then your article should be quite popular, huh? Mine has been under review for a month now. There are more than 2 reviewers, I don't know if it's a good thing or a bad thing. Sigh, I'll just continue to wait.

turtle_dd 2022-07-14

May I ask how long have you been conducting an external audit? I have been under review for almost two months.

turtle_dd 2022-07-14

2022.07.14 under review. It's been almost two months, and still no news.

turtle_dd 2022-07-14

I have been under review for two months.

yun233 2022-07-13

It has been a month, under review, and the time changed twice.

是小小一呀 2022-07-11

2022.6.07: Submission
2022.6.09: Under Review
2022.07.11: Under Review

There are a total of 2 reviewers.

It has been under review for a month now, today is 2022.07.11, and it is still in the Under Review status.

I want to ask everyone if this speed is good or bad. I see that most people receive feedback or rejection within about 15-25 days, so why is mine taking so long?

是小小一呀 2022-07-11

My review process is also very slow. It has been under review for a month, from June 9th to today, July 11th, and it is still in the "under review" status.

水天一色 2022-07-10

Is it possible for the revised version submitted to still be a single-column Word document for the first submission?

水天一色 2022-07-10

Is it possible for the revised version to be submitted as a single-column Word document for the first submission?

谈何不易 2022-07-10

How is the current status? How long did you use the editor for?

谈何不易 2022-07-10

How is the current status? How long did you use with the editor? Is it two weeks or with the editor?

是小小一呀 2022-07-10

Ah, I overlooked the speed of rating column, which caused the submission to fail repeatedly. I'm sorry, what I said earlier was incorrect.
Let me reorganize my thoughts. I would like to consult with you. Has it been too long for the "Under Review" process? I see that other classmates receive reviewer comments within 15-25 days, either rejection or major revisions. It has been a month for me, and I haven't received any communication yet. I'm a bit worried. Should I remind the reviewer or should I remind the editor?

是小小一呀 2022-07-10

May I ask if this "Under Review" status has been ongoing for one month already, is this normal? Should I remind the reviewer?
By the way, this evaluation system is a bit redundant. It requires me to rate the paper even though it's already submitted but unknown. The key issue is that if I choose "submitted but unknown" as the result, the review speed can only be selected as "unknown" as well, and in the end, I can't even submit a comment.