WIND~~ 2022-10-05

9.20 submission
9.21 assigned to editor
10.2 suggested re-submission, saying that the amount of submissions is too large, and maybe the innovation is not prominent enough, it will be promoted to Zone 2 immediately.
In conclusion, the speed is still very fast.

翻滚的肉丸丸 2022-09-23

Hello, may I ask if you have chosen open access?

松鼠小俊 2022-09-19

Hello, have you found the template? According to the author's guide on the official website, it says that any form of template can be used. As part of the Your Paper Your Way service, you have the option to submit your manuscript as a single file for the refereeing process. This file can be in PDF or Word format, with any layout or format that referees can use to evaluate your manuscript. The file should include figures of sufficient quality for refereeing.

shuaifly 2022-09-18

May I ask if there is a LaTeX template for this journal? If so, could you provide a download link? Thank you very much.

落子 2022-09-18

Please update again.
4.25 Submitted.
4.26 With editor.
4.27 Under review.
6.21 Revise.
7.22 With editor.
7.24 Under review.
8.6 Revise.
8.18 With editor.
9.10 Decision in process.
9.18 Accepted.

蓝星星 2022-09-13

Posted on May 8th
First review completed on June 7th with 2 reviewers and 17 comments, all comments were very positive.
Revised and submitted for publication on August 14th.
Accepted on September 10th with 3 reviewers.

The review process was fast, but I had other things to do during that time, so my own revisions were a bit slow.

zw 2022-09-12

Hello, can I ask if you encountered a situation where there was no response after filling out the information and clicking "continue" when registering an account for submission?

沙雕外包放羊技校 2022-09-11

The first review took over two months, with major revisions and approximately six reviewers providing multiple opinions. Perhaps there were more submissions, which resulted in slower processing and slightly higher demands.

zzzzsss 2022-09-10

Unified response, starting from the decision, received a clear rejection letter after 15 days.

gdsyiceman 2022-09-05

Brother, I am also in a similar situation. How long did it take for you to receive the rejection letter after your "decision in process"? Thank you.

gdsyiceman 2022-09-05

Brother, how long did it take for you to receive the rejection letter after the decision was in process? Thank you.

糖包是只猫 2022-09-04

You can upload a clean version in latex.

自由飞翔1993 2022-09-03

I have a question for everyone. Which file should be submitted for the Revised manuscript (clean)? I used LaTeX for formatting, and the Revised manuscript (clean) cannot be submitted as a PDF. Please guide me. Thank you very much.

归零0905 2022-08-30

Submission experience:
4.26 submitted
4.28 under review
6.17 revise (major revision, 27 comments from 7 reviewers)
7.23 with editor
7.29 under review
8.8 decision in process
8.13 accept

Turbocc 2022-08-28

Record for reference:

5.15 submitted
5.16 with editor
5.17 under review
6.23 revise (major revision, reconsider if revised, four reviewers, a total of 21 comments, given two and a half months for revision)
8.7 with editor (submitted revised manuscript, as additional experiments took time)
8.8 under review
8.22 decision in process
8.28 accepted

The processing speed was very fast, and each reviewer's comments were taken seriously and responded to appropriately. The entire submission and revision process was done using the Word version, with no specific formatting requirements, and not using LaTeX had no impact.

MJ-ID 2022-08-24

Hello, may I ask if the revised manuscript needs to be submitted in the following format: one PDF file highlighting the modified sections, one PDF file without any changes, and one modified LaTeX file?

galeilei 2022-08-18

Revised update:
5.22 with editor
5.23 under review
6.20 revise (major revision, resubmit for reconsideration)
7.24 with editor (modified for a month, delayed a few days due to clean submission in LaTeX)
7.27 under review
8.6 decision in process
8.13 accept

The review process is fast, and the journal impact factor has increased to 6.698. Hopefully, the journal's ranking will also improve.

Jingjun Zhou 2022-08-18

Me too, it's also because of this reason. Is it because the number of submissions is too high?

叕 2022-08-18

Please refer to the following content for the rejection letter: We regret to inform you that your manuscript has not been found suitable for publication in our journal. Feel free to use it as a reference.

是小小一呀 2022-08-17

Emmm, I have received 30 comments from my three reviewers.

zzzzsss 2022-08-16

Since the decision, there hasn't been any progress. Sigh, if they were going to reject it, they should have done it earlier. I need to quickly submit to other places. Graduation waits for no one.

lindu1995 2022-08-16

Excuse me, how long has it been since your decision is in process? It has been almost a week for me and I still haven't received any response.

叕 2022-08-15

The amount of submissions for this magazine is huge, the editors may not even have time to handle them. With editor3 making a decision directly after 3 weeks, the entire process takes less than a month (looking at it this way, the magazine's cycle is indeed very short, haha). I submitted because I saw on the magazine's homepage that the submission cycle was short, but now I feel like I wasted my own time.

galeilei 2022-08-15

Hello, may I ask if all the authors will receive an email after acceptance?

守候阳光 2022-08-14

Very good journal, strict review process, lasted for half a year, submitted on February 25th, three rounds of review, accepted on August 13th.

Jingjun Zhou 2022-08-14

May I ask what the reason is for you? Me too, sigh.

wang2 2022-08-12

Could you please tell me how long the rejection will take? I have been in this state for three weeks, in theory.

编辑和审稿人的舔狗 2022-08-12

What should I do if no reviewers accept the invitation for review... about to cry...

MJ-ID 2022-08-08

There is a link inside an email.

gundamks 2022-08-07

Hello, may I ask where can I check the progress of the review invitation? I have been in the "under review" status for 2 months now. The date has changed 5 times, but the status remains "under review."