BerenChou 2023-02-01

Second Paper
2023.1.22 Submit
2023.1.23 With Editor

慧 2023-01-26

2023.1.25 submitted to journal - This means that a document or article was submitted to a journal on January 25, 2023.

2023.1.26 with editor - This suggests that the submitted document is currently being reviewed or edited by the editor on January 26, 2023.

gundamks 2023-01-04

Hello! May I ask if you have received the email from the publisher after your paper was accepted? How many days did it take? Thank you!

楠 2023-01-03

9.20 Submission
9.20 with editor
10.8 under review
10.31 revised
11.17 with editor (returned after modification)
11.18 under review
11.25 revised
12.8 with editor (returned after second revision)
12.9 under review
12.31 accepted

gundamks 2022-12-29

Thank you for your reply. I just asked my supervisor, and he also hasn't received any email from the publisher. We can only wait and see.

xx........ 2022-12-29

I received the production department's proof email on the third day after acceptance. It could be sent to the corresponding author. You can ask your boss about it.

xx........ 2022-12-29

It is not necessary. The supplementary materials with this animation style can be omitted.

gundamks 2022-12-29

Hello, may I ask if you have received an email from the publisher after your paper was accepted? Mine was confirmed as accepted on December 19th, but I have not received any email from the publisher until now.

allenem 2022-12-27

Submitted for more than 20 days for feedback, and accepted after about 2 months. Surprisingly, they were still working 2 days after Christmas, and I received it. I originally thought I would have to wait until after the New Year.

Status Date Current Status
Oct 19, 2022 Submitted
Oct 20, 2022 With Editor
Oct 21, 2022 Under Review
Nov 11, 2022 Revise (2 reviewers, one with 7 comments, the other with 12 comments, all relatively fair comments, no request for additional experiments)

Dec 11, 2022 Submitted After Revision
Dec 11, 2022 With Editor
Dec 12, 2022 Under Review
Dec 13, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Dec 18, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Dec 21, 2022 Decision in Process
Dec 27, 2022 Accept

AAAAA 2022-12-22

Congratulations, I would like to ask about the requirements in the journal. It asks to include interactive data visualizations in your publication and allow your readers to interact and engage more closely with your research. Please follow the instructions provided at https://www.elsevier.com/authors/author-services/data-visualization to learn about the available data visualization options and how to include them in your article. What does this mean? How can it be modified? Thank you for your help.

AAAAA 2022-12-22

I would like to ask about the requirements in the journal, which state to include interactive data visualizations in your publication and allow your readers to interact and engage more closely with your research. Please follow the instructions provided at this link: https://www.elsevier.com/authors/author-services/data-visualization to learn about the available data visualization options and how to include them in your article. What does this mean? How can I make modifications? If you can answer, thank you.

xx........ 2022-12-20

2022.10.23 Submitted
2022.10.23 With Editor
2022.10.30 Under review
2022.11.26 Will be published if revised (minor revisions? Two reviewers, eight comments that are neither significant nor insignificant)
2022.11.30 Revised
2022.11.30 With Editor
2022.12.04 Under Review
2022.12.11 Decision in Process
2022.12.20 Accepted

太难 2022-12-11

I'm really struggling, my paper has entered the third review and the outcome is uncertain. The first and second reviews have been rejected by the same reviewer. I want to ask, do I have to satisfy all the reviewers?

佛系投稿 2022-12-11

2022.5.31 submit to journal
6.1 with editor
6.1 under review Change dates 7.07 7.16 8.03
9.12 required reviews completed
9.14 under review
9.24 revise 【reconsider after revision】 5 reviewers, 26 comments
11.1 with editor
11.4 under review
11.7 required reviews completed
11.10 revise 【will publish if revised】 2 comments remaining
11.15 with editor
11.17 decision in process
11.23 accept

eric1105 2022-12-11

May I ask why the communication author did not immediately receive a rejection letter when the article was found rejected on the system today? Or will it take some time before a letter is sent to the communication author?

monroe_w 2022-12-10

11.30 Submission
12.01 Editing
12.07 Decision
A song "Coolness" to myself, crying to death.

sw976834142 2022-12-08

I changed my state on the sixth day.

sw976834142 2022-12-08

The speed of reviewing is said to be slow, please be patient if you are in a hurry.

Smile_Honest 2022-12-08

I would like to ask, where can I see whether the reviewers have given rejection or acceptance? I can only see their review comments.

292725651 2022-12-06

I feel like cursing my mother when I see this.

太难 2022-12-04

It took six hours, and there was one reviewer who rejected it. Will the editor reject it because of this?

太难 2022-12-04

Brother, our situations are really very similar. Do we really need to satisfy all the reviewers? It's so frustrating.

太难 2022-12-04

Brother, is it really necessary for all the judges to be satisfied with our very similar situations? I want to cry.

太难 2022-12-04

The translation of the text into English is: "Our situation is very similar, brother. Do we really need to satisfy all the judges?"

太难 2022-12-04

Did the brothers ultimately get rejected?

太难 2022-12-04

Did you still get rejected in the end?

太难 2022-12-04

I have also been with the editor for four days.

eric1105 2022-12-02

Update the progress:
2022.11.28 Submitted
2022.12.03 With Editor

eric1105 2022-12-02

The text translates to: "Submitted successfully, but it has been four days with the editor. Could it be bad news?"

太难 2022-11-30

Hello, have you received the results?