Magnolia 2022-03-04

Posted on February 28, 2022.

呆头呆脑 2022-01-07

Hello, I would like to ask how long it takes for the manuscript to be sent for review with the editor, and approximately how long does the review process take?

Hank 2022-01-07

Posted on June 11th.
First review took five months, with three reviewers. Two agreed to accept, one rejected. The editor requested major revisions.
Second review took half a month, detailed responses were provided to each comment made by the previous rejecting reviewer. Minor revisions were made.
Accepted on January 7th.

As long as you respond to the reviewers' comments seriously, seriously, and seriously, there is a chance. They will see your efforts and give you extra points.
Good luck to everyone.

呆头呆脑 2021-12-13

Hello, I would like to ask everyone, how long does it usually take for a submission to be reviewed after using an editor? It has been a week and I haven't received any updates.

呆头呆脑 2021-12-08

How long did it take for your manuscript to be reviewed after the with editor stage?

呆头呆脑 2021-12-08

Has your paper been submitted for review? How long after "with editor" will it be submitted for review?

huihui111111 2021-11-30

How long have you used With Editor? We have been waiting for nearly half a month and still have not received any review. Does this mean that it has most likely been rejected?

alivio 2021-11-29

21.06.20 submitted - Submitted on June 21, 2020
21.07.20 with editor - With editor on July 21, 2020
21.07.20 under review - Under review on July 21, 2020
21.10.16 major revision - Major revision on October 16, 2021
21.11.05 resubmitted - Resubmitted on November 5, 2021
21.11.28 minor revision - Minor revision on November 28, 2021
21.11.29 resubmitted & with editor & accept - Resubmitted and accepted with editor on November 29, 2021

The initial assignment of article ID was slow, taking a month. On July 20, I sent an email to inquire about the situation, and on the same day, the editor was assigned and the reviewing process began. After that, the speed was very fast. The second review was accepted within 2 hours of submission, and I'm not sure if the initial email reminder played a role.

There were three reviewers, and the first reviewer had many comments, over 30. It greatly helped improve the quality of the paper, and we responded to each comment.

Overall, the journal is very rigorous. This year, the Impact Factor is over 5, but I don't feel that the difficulty is too high.

alivio 2021-11-28

Normal, my monthly allocation of articles.

pxj 2021-11-26

Hello, I would like to ask, how long does it take to assign an article number?

pxj 2021-11-26

What is the status after submission and waiting for co-authors to confirm? I have forgotten... It's been half a month and there is no article number. Does it have anything to do with co-author confirmation?

alivio 2021-11-20

Has your result come out?

darby 2021-11-13

I don't know if it is possible to catch up with the March deadline for submission now.

shinec 2021-11-10

Is there any minor repair after the major renovation is completed?

shinec 2021-11-10

Does this journal offer the revised manuscript to the original reviewers? Is the rejection rate high for the revised manuscript?

九漏鱼 2021-10-27

I hope to be able to rank high in the second area of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

csjwsc 2021-10-23

Why is the review speed of this journal so slow? It has been a month and it is still in the "submit to the journal" status.

tcrystal 2021-09-07

How many reviewers did the magazine invite?

dlxiaolizi 2021-08-31

Hello, may I ask if there is a Word template for this journal? I noticed that the submission requirement states "your paper your way." I previously submitted but was instantly rejected, so I'm not sure if it was due to incorrect formatting.

foyo 2021-08-25

A total of 10 months.

foyo 2021-08-25

First review: major revisions for 3 and a half months.
Second review: minor revisions for 3 months.
Acceptance of minor revisions for half a month.
The reviewer's comments are pertinent and of a high level.

shinec 2021-08-24

May I ask if anyone has encountered the situation of resubmitting a rejected manuscript?

Is there a good chance of acceptance for this?

Will it be sent back to the original reviewer?

shinec 2021-08-23

Did everyone get hired in the end?

shinec 2021-08-22

How long have you been submitting contributions?

shinec 2021-08-04

Has the change in the date under review occurred because a different reviewer was assigned? Or did a new review comment come back?

桐笑 2021-07-20

After submission, the article will be assigned a number by the editor.

shinec 2021-07-19

Has the OP submitted for review?

shinec 2021-07-19

Does the speed of reviewing also depend on the direction?

shinec 2021-07-19

What experiences have you been through, OP? I have not seen "with editor".

桐笑 2021-07-19

Thank you, it's really slow now.