云与海 2021-05-24

21.2.17 Submission
21.3.15 Rejection
21.3.31 Appeal and resubmission
21.5.11 Direct acceptance

笨蜗牛 2021-05-23

Hello, have you received any updates about your manuscript?

5555555 2021-05-20

Not as fast as expected, it has been 10 days since submission, still with the editor.

WRT6666 2021-05-16

Speed is one of the top priorities in colloidal interface-related journals, and the language requirement is not very high. Articles should have a certain level of innovation and mechanism analysis.

不良人 2021-05-12

11.3 Submission, 12.9 Received revision comments, 12.25 Submitted revised draft, 12.29 Accepted, 1.12 Provided online.

不良人 2021-05-12

Posted on 3.28, revised on 4.17, returned after modification on 4.25, accepted on 4.28, and available online on 5.8.

GHXFM 2021-05-12

Excuse me, may I ask if your article has been published online and proofread? It has been over a month since I submitted mine and it hasn't been published yet.

GHXFM 2021-05-12

January 28th submission
February 21st received reviewer's comments, minor revisions, requested response by March 15th, but due to the pandemic, unable to return to study. Requesting a one-month extension.
April 2nd submitted revised manuscript.
April 8th accepted.
Today is May 12th, still haven't received online publication, nor proof. I'm also unsure of the situation and feeling a bit anxious.

newton996370 2021-05-09

2020.12.17 Submission
Around 2021.01.14 Reviewer's comments
Due to personal reasons, I voluntarily requested two extensions to reply to the reviewer's comments.
2021.03.25 Reply to reviewer's comments
Accepted on 20210429.

举风 2021-04-28

Very fast
2021.3.10 submit
2021.3.12 under review
2021.4.5 required revisions completed
2021.4.8 First review results, one major and one minor revision required for publication
2021.4.22 resubmit
2021.4.28 accept

河山大好 2021-03-12

The second trial took 4 months, probably due to the COVID-19, but the result is good!

Hely 2021-02-18

Submitted revised manuscript on December 29, 2020. After being under review, the status changed to "Required reviews completed" on January 14, 2021. The status has not changed since then. What's going on? I'm really anxious.

清风明月伴我心 2021-02-18

Translated text:
Submitted on March 27th, reviewed on March 29th. Received major revisions based on the feedback from three reviewers on April 19th. Submitted the revised manuscript on May 9th. Accepted on May 16th. Proofreading was done on May 19th. Overall, it was quite fast.

六言 2021-01-25

2020.12.16: Submitted
2021.01.13: Received revision comments from two reviewers
2021.01.20: Submitted revised version
2021.01.24: Received email confirmation
Overall, the process was very fast. The editor was satisfied with the revised version and accepted it quickly.

∫ 四仰化三铁 2021-01-21

cej to col sur, this span is a bit large.

∫ 四仰化三铁 2021-01-21

Posted in mid-November 2020, it took 3 days to reach the editor's hands, and then it took another two days for review.
The review process took about 20 days, with three reviewers providing over twenty comments. One reviewer suggested minor revisions, while the other two did not express their opinions. The editor's attitude was unclear, only stating that they would consider revisions and providing a 21-day revision period. After that, I conducted additional experiments and included 5 additional data points in the revised manuscript. The second round of review had no issues according to two reviewers, but one reviewer insisted on an explanation of the specific mechanism. The editor granted another 21 days, and I supplemented two additional comparative experiments to further support my findings. Finally, the manuscript was accepted directly.
Overall, the quality has improved after the revisions. If the supplementary experiments are included in the main text, there is a good chance for publication in a top-tier journal. However, my previous submissions to three top journals were rejected, which delayed my progress for nearly half a year. Therefore, I chose to submit to Col sur A out of urgency to graduate. I express my gratitude to Editor Xuehai Yan for their high efficiency.
This is my first SCI paper as a master's student, and it is unlikely that I will have another SCI publication in my life. I wish everyone smooth submissions and the continued success of Col sur A!

寻找一个合适的期刊 2021-01-21

It should have been invested in mid-March, and sold in early April.

寻找一个合适的期刊 2021-01-21

My first experimental paper in my life was submitted multiple times. Finally, I submitted it to CEJ for review and was criticized heavily by the second reviewer. There were three reviewers, and after revision, the other two requested publication, but the second reviewer raised 28 additional questions. In short, it wasn't good enough. The CEJ editor requested a resubmission, but later, they forgot and rejected my paper!!! My advisor asked me to write an appeal letter explaining the situation and the highlights of the paper, but I was too tired. It took over a year from writing to submitting, revising, and resubmitting this paper. I wanted to graduate quickly, so I encountered my lucky journal and submitted it directly (during this time, my advisor also suggested trying other journals, but I refused because I wanted to graduate. After three years, I finally stood my ground). Overall, the paper was reviewed the day after submission and took less than 20 days for revision. Later, due to the pandemic, I couldn't address some of the reviewer's questions (in general, the workload was not small), but the editor still accepted it. The entire process took about 2 months. It took 21 days for review, over 17 days for revision, and then waited for a little over a week.

Allen Brook 2021-01-19

It has also been more than 10 days waiting, and the review is completed.

小白du 2021-01-08

It has been more than ten days since the status of "Required Reviews Completed," but there has been no change. What is the situation?