MiMi李 2023-03-11

Thank you for your response, I appreciate it. I also wanted to ask, according to the author's guide, should I use the Word template they provided to upload the manuscript, or is it only necessary to use it if the manuscript is accepted for publication?

老木头 2023-03-11

Sure, just use the universal LaTeX template provided by Elsevier.

MiMi李 2023-03-10

I would like to ask if it is possible to upload a PDF version in Latex for the first submission of this journal, instead of uploading a Word document. Thank you for your response.

姜子图 2023-02-22

How much does the layout fee cost?

WXSYLW 2023-02-20

I don't want to comment too much, but I don't know where they found two reviewers. The article was not well-written, and their suggestions were unclear. This journal can be left for those big research groups in the country to play with. I have no chance in this lifetime. The above comments can be seen as my grumbling after rejecting the manuscript. You can judge for yourselves.

橙子很愤怒 2023-01-19

May I ask how long it takes from initial employment to obtaining a DOI number?

橙子很愤怒 2023-01-19

May I ask how long it takes for this journal from initial acceptance to the issuance of a DOI number?

MIM 2023-01-18

May I ask how much is the manuscript review fee?

风枫之 2023-01-09

The Journal of Aeronautics usually requires three review opinions. If one of them rejects the submission, it will be rejected. In your case, there were probably only two opinions, so the editor couldn't wait any longer and asked you to revise. However, during your revision process, the third reviewer responded.

马达加斯加 2023-01-09

3-month repair, two reviewers, opinions are okay, one suggested acceptance after modification, one raised some questions. For the second review, the editor invited a third reviewer who brought up some irrelevant issues based on the initial draft, resulting in rejection. How should I put it, it feels like this journal doesn't respect the authors.

副叫兽 2023-01-01

In the new year, there is no suspense that the impact factor will exceed 5.

小黑 2022-11-29

This is my submission process. The peer review process was faster than expected. I initially thought that domestic journals would be slower.

2022.09.25 Submitted to journal
2022.11.02 Major revision
2022.11.07 Submitted to journal & Under review
2022.11.22 Required revisions completed
2022.11.22 With editor & Decision in process & With editor
2022.11.28 Initial accept

老木头 2022-11-28

Maybe it's because the manuscripts have piled up too much. After submitting the revised manuscript, I haven't heard anything for almost two months. Then I sent an email to the editorial department to inquire, and shortly after, I was notified of its acceptance.

Fusica 2022-11-26

Hello, this is my first time submitting to this journal. I wanted to ask if this journal does not provide a manuscript number at the time of submission.

123222 2022-11-26

Why was the revised manuscript submitted in August not accepted until October?

123222 2022-11-24

Since November 21, the manuscript process has not been pushed forward, and the editorial department's phone is also not reachable. Has Haidian District been placed under home isolation? Can the editors of the Journal of Aerospace Engineering work from home?

太空挖矿 2022-11-23

Next door, AST has 7 or 8 reviewers.

小黑 2022-11-23

August revision, July receipt, hilarious, is this a done deal?

ZHAO J C 2022-11-22

I hope everyone has a good outcome. I am also very anxious. On the 7th, it showed "Required Reviews Completed", but I have not received any news until now. I am still waiting for another reviewer.

LawLight_L 2022-11-22

Thank you, I asked Elsevier and their response was similar to yours, but they mentioned that they do not have enough permissions to view the reviewer comments. Elsevier replied saying that out of the three reviewers, two have already provided their comments, but they are still waiting for the comments from one reviewer. However, when I submitted to other journals, it was the first time I encountered a situation where the status changed without receiving all the reviewer comments.

风枫之 2022-11-22

You can explain that two opinions have come back, and both opinions are okay. The editor wants to find a third opinion. If there are any negative opinions, they should be rejected directly without waiting anymore.

LawLight_L 2022-11-22

Hello, have you ever encountered a situation where it changed directly from "required reviews completed" to "under review"?

ZHAO J C 2022-11-14

November 7th under review; November 14th required reviews completed. Why was the review process so fast? Whether it's good or bad.

老木头 2022-11-08

22.05.19 Manuscript submitted to journal
22.05.23 Under review and review fee
22.07.11 Revision
22.07.22 Revision submitted to journal
22.08.12 Minor revision
22.08.16 Revision submitted to journal
22.10.30 Accepted

Translation:
22.05.19 Manuscript submitted to journal
22.05.23 Under review and review fee
22.07.11 Revision
22.07.22 Revision submitted to journal
22.08.12 Minor revision
22.08.16 Revision submitted to journal
22.10.30 Accepted

争做搬砖人 2022-11-04

It is done simultaneously, and generally no one will not submit it. Being "under review" first can also save time.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-04

Thank you for your answer, I wish you every success in your investments!

风枫之 2022-11-04

No, it becomes under review and reminds you to make payment at the same time. It's okay if someone else finishes reviewing before you make the payment.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-03

October 31 submission; October 31 with editor; November 1 with editor;

ZHAO J C 2022-11-03

Hello, may I ask if payment is required first before it is changed to "under review" in the system?

ZHAO J C 2022-11-03

Hello, is it necessary to inform and pay the fee first, and then the system will change to "under review"?