wlboy 2021-04-26

It's the fifth day of submission, and there is still no assigned editor. Has the original poster assigned an editor yet?

想中啊 2021-04-26

I am too. I have been submitting for three days, but haven't been assigned an editor yet. I'm worried.

脚踏实地做科研 2021-04-25

Share the experience of submitting an article:
2021.01.26 submit
2021.01.28 under review
2021.03.01 major revision
2021.03.30 resubmit
2021.04.08 under review
The first review was quite fast, but there is currently no news after the second review. Hopefully, there will be a good outcome.

Cadi 2021-04-23

Brother, any progress?

Right 2021-04-20

Excuse me, is the editor Jinwoon Lee?

小郎君 2021-04-19

Is this how CEJ is now? The review process seems to be quite fast as it went from "Required Reviews Completed" to 20 days, but then there hasn't been any change for 3 or 4 days. Other journals usually determine acceptance or rejection within half a day.

yizhibieryi 2021-04-16

Thank you to editor Hrvoje Kusic, who is very professional and efficient. The invited reviewers are also very professional and their opinions are very fair, greatly improving the article. I wish the journal continued success! Although there were many reviewers, their comments greatly improved the article.
1.6 Submitted to journal
1.9 With editor
1.11 Under review
2.8 Major revision
4.7 Revision submitted to journal (delayed for a month)
4.15 Accept
It took three months, and although the process was difficult, the outcome is good.

神奇猛 2021-04-15

4.1 submitted to journal
4.3 submitted to journal (Editor informed that the format does not comply)
4.6 with editor
4.8 under review
There has been no update after under review, hoping for a positive outcome.

songsing 2021-04-14

How long after everyone received it did you proofread it?
Also, 1ninini, could you post the DOI number of the paper for us to see, so that we can learn from it and also see which impressive research group has cultivated such a "remarkable" role like yours!

xmf123 2021-04-14

Thank you to editor Dionysios Dionysiou for being very professional and efficient. The invited reviewers were also very professional, and their comments were very fair. They greatly improved the article. Wishing the journal continued success!

1.23 Submitted to journal
1.27 With editor
2.03 Under review
2.25 Major revision
3.23 Revision submitted to journal
4.04 Minor revision
4.11 Revision submitted to journal
4.14 Accepted

Cadi 2021-04-13

The required reviewer has completed two weeks already...

小虾米 2021-04-13

It has been 5 days since submission, and no editor has been assigned yet!

xiaoqiye123 2021-04-10

2020 12 21: Submission
2021 2 22: Under review
2021 3 6: Required reviews completed
2021 3 7: Mini revision
2021 3 19: Submit
2021 3 26: Under review
2021 4 7: Accept

mmtj 2021-04-09

Hello, who is your editor? What is your field of expertise? Could you please disclose it? I am also planning to submit to CEJ, and my article is purely computational as well.

吉祥渝 2021-04-09

You are so lucky, congratulations.

123456@qq.com 2021-04-09

Why are you guys so cute, haha

范特霍夫 2021-04-09

15 people liked you, one person disliked you, hahaha, I guess it was that 1mimi who disliked you.

cyzw 2021-04-09

The results will be available in about three weeks. There will be major revisions, and you will be given one month to make the necessary changes.

NicoleZ 2021-04-09

The speed of journal peer review and editorial processing is very fast, but the proofreading and publishing process is too slow. May I ask how long it takes for everyone to receive proofreading after acceptance? It has been two months since I accepted in early February and I still haven't received any proofreading. Other magazines in Aisville aren't this slow, right?

一壶乌龙茶 2021-04-08

Today is exactly one month, and there is still no news.

庭叶 2021-04-07

New Year's Eve submission,
Return for major revisions on the fifteenth, with a total of eight questions from two reviewers.
Submit the revisions after one month.
Acceptance one week later, the editing process is extremely fast.

小颖er 2021-04-07

Stephen Allen

fzdxhc 2021-04-07

It should be changing the peer reviewer. May I ask which editor you chose?

钓叟 2021-04-07

This 1ninini looks like a bookworm who has gone mad from reading. Wake up quickly, this is not Zhihu.

小颖er 2021-04-07

2021.3.1 Submission
2021.3.5 With editor
2021.3.13 Under review
2021.3.25 Under review
2021.4.5 Under review
Unknown result
What does it mean that the "under review" status changed three times? Can someone knowledgeable please explain?

lyp1108 2021-04-07

Already employed, as I mentioned before, it takes about 20 days for one round of review, and the editing is very objective.
There were six reviewers. After major revisions, four agreed, one did not oppose, and one strongly opposed. The editor asked for major revisions again. After the revisions, all five agreed. One reviewer was still unsure about the previous responses, but the editor accepted it, luckily! The result is good. It's my first graduate student paper to be accepted, so I am very happy!
Submitted on January 11th, accepted on April 5th, very fast! Thanks to the editor.

a a a 2021-04-07

Excuse me, did the final result come out? How long did it take?

zhouwen92 2021-04-06

Bro, may I ask if the results are out now? I just sent it for repair today, and I'm anxious. I don't know when the results usually come out.

一壶乌龙茶 2021-04-03

Two reviewers, on March 8th, provided revision comments. It is now April 3rd, and the manuscript is still under review. Does it take this long for the second round of review?

咋总重名 2021-03-31

This 1ninini, I have already cursed you. Don't think that everything will be fine after your shameless words. Your foul mouth has spread to another dimension through quantum mechanics. Your life will be full of toil and frustration, forever disliked by everyone.