大鱼 2021-07-25

Fellow upstairs, our situation is the same, not knowing when we can find out if it can be submitted for review. How many days approximately?

Ly 2021-07-25

2021.7.21 提交给期刊
2021.7.24 与编辑交流

哦哦哦好吧 2021-07-23

Submitted on July 8th, with editor on July 10th, and it has been half a month now, but the status has not changed. What's going on?

Xiao 2021-07-23

2021.06.30 submit to journal - Submitted to the journal on June 30, 2021.
2021.07.03 with editor - Under consideration by the editor on July 3, 2021.
2021.07.06 under review - Under review by reviewers on July 6, 2021.
2021.07.08 under review - Still under review by reviewers on July 8, 2021.
2021.07.13 under review - Still under review by reviewers on July 13, 2021.
under review updated 3 times, should have been assigned 3 reviewers.

小陈陈1111 2021-07-23

You have improved a lot, what materials did you use?

sunxiaodui 2021-07-23

My 8-day schedule has been edited.

sunxiaodui 2021-07-23

My 8 days have started to be under review, and I received an email reminder.

sunxiaodui 2021-07-23

8 days allocated for editing under review.

sunxiaodui 2021-07-23

under review has been 20 days

小陈陈1111 2021-07-23

Maybe, we can only wait.

zzh12345 2021-07-22

I submitted on the 11th, with the editor on the 13th. The date changed on the 14th, and it is still with the editor until now. Is it because there have been many recent submissions in the materials field?

小陈陈1111 2021-07-22

I have been working on it for 12 days, still in the editing phase. Have you submitted it for review?

勇敢牛牛 2021-07-22

I have also been 6 days.

勇敢牛牛 2021-07-22

I have been with my editor for 1 week, feeling sad.

小七tju 2021-07-22

Don't worry, the editor might be busy as there is a large amount of submissions recently.

小叶子12345 2021-07-21

6.17 Submission
6.22 Under review
7.21 Rejected
There were a total of four reviewers, with two recommending major revisions and two rejecting the submission. Sad~

hytjp 2021-07-21

Received at Editorial Office 1 Jun 2021: The article was received by the editorial office on June 1, 2021.
Article revised 12 Jul 2021: The article was revised on July 12, 2021.
Article accepted for publication 14 Jul 2021: The article was accepted for publication on July 14, 2021.

强 2021-07-21

Five reviewers,
First reviewer requested revisions on sections 2, 3, 4, and 5, and rejected section 1;
Second reviewer accepted sections 1, 3, 4, and 5, and rejected section 2. They focused on one specific issue and deleting it didn't affect the article much.
For the third review, if they reject it again, does that mean it's game over? It feels like the editor isn't even reading it and just puts it under review every time...
It's really tough.

123456789112 2021-07-21

Respond to the comments on the manuscript and strive for a reasonable argument. The editor only rejects the manuscript when the reviewers reject it again or request major revisions, not for minor revisions. Even if it is rejected, you can still argue if the reviewers' reasons are unreasonable.

xiaoxiao 2021-07-21

It has been ten days since the submission, and there is still no news. It is still pending review now.

zzh12345 2021-07-20

It has been 6 days with the editor. Seeing others share their work for review so quickly, it seems like mine might not make the cut.

研磨 2021-07-20

Reply [So what]: The editor does not give a second chance for revision. Original text attached.

研磨 2021-07-20

06 May 2021 Submitted to Journal
09 May 2021 With Editor
10 May 2021 With Editor
16 May 2021 Under Review
12 Jun 2021 Major Revision
01 Jul 2021 Revision Submitted to Journal
02 Jul 2021 Under Review
07 Jul 2021 Required Reviews Completed
08 Jul 2021 Accept
08 Jul 2021 Completed-Accept
15 Jul 2021 Available Online
All three reviewers' comments were very positive.

123456789112 2021-07-20

There is a common saying: Depending on the changes you make, it may be necessary to send the paper for review by at least one more reviewer.

蜗壳 2021-07-19

My article was submitted for review by my editor two weeks later, but the review process was fast. No need to panic, just be patient and wait.

举头望明粤 2021-07-19

@Difficult person, continually with editor, no possibility of being under review.

那又怎样 2021-07-17

May I ask, when the major renovation was being carried out, did the editor mention in the letter that it needed to be reviewed again?

Oliver 2021-07-17

08 Jul 2021, Initial Date Submitted
14 Jul 2021, Under Review
Follow-up will continue.

123456789112 2021-07-17

4.20 submitted to journal
4.26 with editor
5.01 under review
6.16 major revision (three reviewers, two minor revisions, one rejection, editor gave one month for revisions)
7.07 resubmitted
7.09 with editor (no change in status, editor likely accepted without further review)
7.13 accepted
It seems like I encountered someone familiar, one of the reviewers was quite difficult, asking irrelevant questions, criticizing the innovation and performance, and even comparing it to their own article (despite their own poor performance). Some people in certain fields tend to set up barriers and prevent newcomers from entering. There are many areas where these old-timers are resistant to change and self-proclaimed experts.

难人 2021-07-17

Excuse me, is it under review now?