Verified Reviews - Chemical Engineering Journal
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

vvv 2023-06-09

The text "建议我转投了诶" translates to "They suggested that I switch teams."

Qiangting 2023-06-09

Have you added page numbers?

如此彻底 2023-06-09

It should be the technical review of the editorial department. If you don't see any page requirements, please add them.

Qiangting 2023-06-08

I don't know, my boss said that it seems likely to be reviewed, so he will let you add something. Because in the past, we didn't add anything to the CEJ submissions, but they were rejected without being reviewed. I hope this time it can be reviewed. Continuous updates to follow.

祝福时光 2023-06-08

It should not have reached the hands of the editor yet. The addition of page numbers will be done before giving it to the editor, right?

znlllll 2023-06-08

May I ask about the status of your manuscript?

Ace-mxd 2023-06-08

I asked customer service, and today it was decided. I estimate that it will be rejected.

Qiangting 2023-06-07

Do I need to add page numbers when submitting to CEJ? I submitted on the 5th, and today they asked me to add page numbers and include the corresponding author's email on the manuscript's first page. Did everyone add these when submitting? Also, what does "However, before we can proceed with the review process we ask you to make the following changes to your submission" mean? Does it mean they are requesting changes before reviewing? Can someone expert interpret this for me?

科研乐 2023-06-07

Insert an eye, may Buddha bless.
6.1 submitted
6.2 with editor
6.4 with editor
6.6 under review

Ace-mxd 2023-06-07

5.25 Sub j - 5.31 with E - Up until today, troubled.

如此彻底 2023-06-06

23.6.6 Submitted to Journal
23.6.10 With Editor
23.6.15 Under Review
23.6.21 rrc

23.6.6 Submitted to Journal
23.6.10 With Editor
23.6.15 Under Review
23.6.21 rrc

科研小白兔 2023-06-06

I have encountered this before. When this dip appears in the journal, it means rejection and you can start preparing for the next journal.

vvv 2023-06-06

Excuse me, has anyone encountered the situation of "decision in process" after RRC?

vvv 2023-06-06

May I ask how things have been for you recently? I am also in a state of DIP now, and I am very worried.

vvv 2023-06-06

Hello, may I ask how you are doing? I am currently in the same state, very worried.

晴天Y 2023-06-06

How long?

奥德修斯 2023-06-06

My first review was sent back, the two reviewers will complete their reviews within a week, but the third reviewer has not accepted the review. The status is already RRC, and it has been 20 days since then. Have you received any results?

唐老鸭呀1 2023-06-06

Yes, very soon.

临床样本00049 2023-06-06

6.5 Submitted for review, requesting a modification, please please please please please please.

一眼光年 2023-06-06

Brother has already shifted from begging party to Amitabha QAQ.

Qiangting 2023-06-06

2023. 6.6 submit to journal

This sentence is already in English.

z9856321 2023-06-05

29 submissions, in the middle with an edit, the time has already been two days, not sure when the next step will be.

L-123 2023-06-05

Have any experts encountered a situation where "rrc" changed to "under review" during the second review? I'm afraid.

rolldemon 2023-06-05

23.4.28 submitted to journal
23.5.15 under review
23.5.28 required reviews completed
23.5.31 required reviews completed
23.6.2 required reviews completed
23.6.10 required reviews completed

Translation:
23.4.28 - Submitted to journal
23.5.15 - Under review
23.5.28 - Required reviews completed
23.5.31 - Required reviews completed
23.6.2 - Required reviews completed
23.6.10 - Required reviews completed

小男孩0911 2023-06-05

5.30 submitted to journal
6.2 with editor
6.4 under review
Amitabha Buddha, hoping for a good outcome

VALAK 2023-06-02

Thank you to the reviewers and editors for their promptness. It only took 2 months and 7 days from submission to final acceptance.

cns爱好者 2023-06-02

5.19 rrc
5.29 rrc
5.29 Major revision (all three reviewers suggested minor revisions, but the editor requested major revision)

VALAK 2023-06-02

The results haven't come out yet... I thought they would be out in two days.

晴天Y 2023-06-02

What's the situation now? I'm also RRC now.

能发篇EST吗 2023-06-02

28 May 2023 Submit
30 May 2023 - Present with editor

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started